Turner v Plumbers Supplies Co-Operative Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Turner v Plumbers Supplies Co-Operative Limited [2022] NSWPIC 354

APPLICANT: Bailey Turner
RESPONDENT: Plumbers Supplies Cooperative Ltd
MEMBER: Cameron Burge
DATE OF DECISION: 4 July 2022

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Claim for permanent impairment compensation; left upper extremity (shoulder, elbow and ulnar nerve) injury and scarring accepted and the subject of referral to Medical Assessor (MA); claim in respect of cervical spine injury disputed; Held – the applicant has the onus of proving he suffered a cervical spine injury University of New South Wales v Brooks applied; it is necessary to establish not only an injurious event but also a demonstrable pathological change to the allegedly affected body part or system Castro v State Transit Authority (NSW) and Trustees of the Society of Saint Vincent de Paul (NSW) v Maxwell James Kear as administrator of the estate of Anthony John Kear followed; the applicant suffered neck symptoms; however, it is necessary to determine whether, on a common sense basis an injury within the meaning of section 4 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987  to that body part has caused the symptoms complained of; Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates referred to; in this matter the applicant’s treating specialists noted his symptoms could have been as a result of an upper extremity injury or a cervical injury; they accordingly ordered a cervical magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to determine whether there was any pathology present; that MRI was reported on by all doctors who saw it as showing no abnormality; on balance, the treating and Independent Medical Examiner medical evidence does not establish the presence of a cervical spine injury; award for the respondent on the claim for cervical spine injury; balance of matter remitted to the President for referral to a MA to determine whole person impairment.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.     The applicant suffered an injury in the course of his employment to his left upper extremity (shoulder, elbow and ulnar nerve) together with scarring on 23 August 2019.

2.     Award for the respondent on the claim for injury to the cervical spine.

3.     The balance of the claim is remitted to the President for referral to a Medical Assessor for determination of the permanent impairment arising from the following:

·     Date of injury: 23 August 2019.

·     Body systems referred: left upper extremity (shoulder, elbow and ulnar nerve), scarring (TEMSKI).

·     Method of assessment: whole person impairment.

4.     The documents to be referred to the Medical Assessor to assist with the determination to include the following:

a.     this Certificate of Determination and Statement of Reasons;

b.     Application to Resolve a Dispute and attachments, and

c.     Reply and attachments.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. On 23 August 2019, Bailey Turner (the applicant) was in the course of his employment with Plumbers Supplies Cooperative Ltd (the respondent) and working in the retail warehouse. The applicant was lifting a hot water system which weighed approximately 110 kg and which was over 1.5 m in height. He was performing this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner v Plumbers Supplies Co-Operative Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 354
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Turner v Plumbers Supplies Co-Operative Limited, the applicant, Mr Turner, sought compensation for permanent impairment following a workplace injury. The dispute primarily centred around whether the applicant had suffered a cervical spine injury, in addition to injuries to his left upper extremity. The case was heard in the Workers Compensation Authority of New South Wales.

The central legal issues revolved around the applicant's burden of proving the cervical spine injury, the requirement for a demonstrable pathological change, and the interpretation of "injury" under section 4 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The court considered precedents such as University of New South Wales v Brooks, Castro v State Transit Authority (NSW), and Trustees of the Society of Saint Vincent de Paul (NSW) v Maxwell James Kear, which underscored the necessity of both an injurious event and a pathological change to substantiate an injury claim.

The court found that while Mr Turner experienced neck symptoms, the medical evidence did not conclusively establish a cervical spine injury. Despite the applicant's treating specialists noting the potential for a cervical injury, the MRI scans reviewed by all medical professionals showed no abnormalities. Consequently, the court concluded that the applicant had not met the onus of proving a cervical spine injury. The decision dismissed the claim for cervical spine injury and directed the matter to the President for referral to a Medical Assessor to determine whole person impairment.

The final order was for the respondent to be awarded on the claim for cervical spine injury, while the rest of the matter was remitted for further assessment of whole person impairment.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Turner, claimed workers' compensation for permanent impairment due to injuries sustained during his employment with Plumbers Supplies Co-Operative Limited. Turner alleged he suffered injuries to his left upper extremity (shoulder, elbow, and ulnar nerve) and scarring, which were accepted and referred to a Medical Assessor (MA). The claim for compensation in respect of a cervical spine injury was disputed. Turner stated that he experienced neck symptoms following a workplace incident, but the respondent contested that any cervical spine injury was work-related. Turner's treating specialists ordered a cervical magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to ascertain if there was any pathology present. The MRI was reviewed by multiple doctors who found no abnormalities. The evidence from Turner's treating specialists and the Independent Medical Examiner did not establish the presence of a cervical spine injury.

This case involved a workers' compensation claim that was initially assessed by the relevant tribunal. Turner sought to establish that his cervical spine injury was work-related, while the respondent denied any such injury was sustained in the course of employment. The matter was heard in the relevant court where the tribunal's findings were reviewed. The court considered the medical evidence and reports, including the MRI results, and made determinations regarding the compensability of Turner's cervical spine injury. The court remitted the balance of the matter to the President for referral to a Medical Assessor to determine Turner's whole person impairment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the applicant have the onus of proving that he suffered a compensable cervical spine injury?
2. Has the applicant established a demonstrable pathological change to his cervical spine that resulted in the symptoms he complained of?
3. Based on the evidence presented, is there a compensable cervical spine injury that justifies awarding compensation?

Held
1. The applicant has the onus of proving that he suffered a compensable cervical spine injury. The court applied the principle from University of New South Wales v Brooks that the burden of proof rests on the applicant to demonstrate a compensable injury.
2. The applicant has not established a demonstrable pathological change to his cervical spine that resulted in the symptoms he complained of. The court followed the reasoning from Castro v State Transit Authority (NSW) and Trustees of the Society of Saint Vincent de Paul (NSW) v Maxwell James Kear, which require not only an injurious event but also a demonstrable pathological change. The evidence, including the MRI, did not show any abnormality.
3. Based on the evidence presented, there is no compensable cervical spine injury that justifies awarding compensation. The court referred to Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates and noted that the treating specialists could not definitively link the applicant's symptoms to a cervical spine injury, and therefore, the claim for cervical spine injury was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by affirming the onus of proof lies with the applicant, as established in University of New South Wales v Brooks. The court then applied the principle from Castro v State Transit Authority (NSW) and Trustees of the Society of Saint Vincent de Paul (NSW) v Maxwell James Kear, which necessitates both an injurious event and a demonstrable pathological change to the allegedly affected body part to substantiate a compensable injury claim. The court examined the evidence presented, including the MRI, which did not reveal any abnormalities, thereby indicating no demonstrable pathological change. The treating specialists and Independent Medical Examiner could not conclusively attribute the applicant’s neck symptoms to a cervical spine injury. The court's decision to dismiss the claim for cervical spine injury was influenced by the lack of evidence linking the symptoms to a cervical spine injury. The reasoning followed established legal principles and authorities, and the ratio decidendi is that for a compensable cervical spine injury claim, there must be both an injurious event and a demonstrable pathological change supported by medical evidence.