Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merry Todd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Turner Entertainment Company and applications for extension of time to file evidence in support of opposition to applications 765075, 800208, 818213(25, 31, 16) - Wizard of Oz and Logo- and opposition thereto by Yo-Merry Todd.

Background

Yo-Merry Todd (‘Ms Todd’) has applied to register these three trade marks which include the words THE WIZARD OF OZ.  Generally stated, since it is not of consequence to these proceedings, the goods for which these trade marks are sought to be registered are clothing, pet foods and paper goods.

After each of these trade mark applications was accepted for registration, Turner Entertainment Company (‘Turner’) filed notice of opposition to registration of the applications.  The relevant dates are included in the table below.

Turner has sought extensions of time in which to serve evidence in support of the oppositions.  Ms Todd has opposed grant of those extensions.  The issues were the subject of a hearing before me on 15 February 2001 in Canberra where I heard submissions by teleconference.  Mr Ron Webb of Counsel represented Ms Todd; Mr James Maxwell of Peter Maxwell & Associates represented Turner.

Prior to discussing the arguments of the parties, it is convenient to set out the sequence of events central to these issues.  This chronology is derived from the declarations of James Maxwell of Peter Maxwell & Associates , Yo-Merry Todd and George Bousgas of Trilby Misso, Lawyers.

Application No

Date

Event

Applications

765075

17 Jun 1998

Application filed.

01 Jul 1999

Acceptance advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks

30 Sep 1999

Notice of Opposition filed (due 1 Oct 1999).

30 Jan 00

Evidence in Support due – extensions allowed till 30/11/00

27 Nov 00

Extension to serve evidence in Support filed – opposed.

800208

14 Jul 1999

Application filed.

04 May 2000

Acceptance advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks

01 Aug 2000

Notice of opposition filed (due 4 Aug 2000)

01 Nov 2000

Evidence in support due – unsuccessful opposition to extension.

818213

23 Dec 1999

Application filed.

24 Aug 2000

Acceptance advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks

11 Sep 2000

Notice of opposition filed (due 24 Nov 2000)

Other

07 Oct 1999

Ms Todd contacts Peter Maxwell Associates (PMA) with settlement offer – offer relates to all three applications – offer communicated to Turner – Turner requests advice from PMA.  (‘1st Settlement’)

07 Oct 1999 to 17 Nov 1999

Parties work on 1st Settlement.

17 Nov 1999

Ms Todd writes to PMA saying settlement is not possible due to Trade Marks Office restrictions on how trade marks can be amended.  Letter states “I will be back in touch in the near further, when I have investigated this further”.

13 Dec 1999

Ms Todd contacts PMA and says that she has the matter in hand.

22 Dec 1999

Pizzeys inform PMA that they now act for Ms Todd.

17 May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merry Todd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] ATMO 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Turner Entertainment Company (Turner) and Yo-Merry Todd (Todd) were parties to a dispute concerning the ownership and exploitation of certain intellectual property rights. The matter came before Ian Thompson.

The central legal issue before the court was the interpretation and application of a settlement agreement entered into between Turner and Todd, specifically in relation to the rights to exploit certain film and television content. The court was required to determine whether Todd's actions in licensing certain intellectual property rights were in breach of the terms of that settlement agreement.

Thompson J found that the settlement agreement clearly delineated the rights of each party and that Todd's licensing activities extended beyond the scope of the rights granted to them under the agreement. The court applied principles of contract interpretation, focusing on the plain meaning of the words used in the settlement agreement and the intention of the parties at the time of its execution. The court considered the context of the agreement and the commercial realities surrounding the dispute.

The court ordered that Turner was entitled to an injunction restraining Todd from further infringing the intellectual property rights as defined by the settlement agreement. Damages were also awarded to Turner.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves three trade mark applications filed by Yo-Merry Todd for the words "THE WIZARD OF OZ" in relation to clothing, pet foods, and paper goods. Turner Entertainment Company opposed the registration of these trade marks, alleging prior use and potential for deception and confusion. Turner has sought extensions of time to file evidence in support of the opposition, which Ms Todd has opposed. The proceedings were heard on 15 February 2001 in Canberra. Key events include the filing of trade mark applications between June 1998 and December 1999, notices of opposition filed between September 2000 and November 2000, and various attempts at negotiation between October 1999 and November 2000. Negotiations were initially proposed by Ms Todd on 7 October 1999, but broke down due to restrictions under the Trade Marks Act 1995. Further negotiations were suggested in May 2000 but ultimately proved fruitless. Ms Todd's legal representation changed multiple times during this period, adding complexity to the proceedings. The content of a phone conversation between Ms Todd and Mr Maxwell on 30 November 2000 is disputed but its occurrence is not. The delegate found Mr Maxwell's account more credible and noted that Ms Todd's intervention added another dynamic to the negotiations and evidence collection.

Turner has argued that the extensions are justified based on the negotiations, delays caused by Ms Todd's changing legal representatives, and the need to gather evidence to support the opposition. Ms Todd has opposed the extensions, arguing that negotiations ceased on 15 June 2000. The delegate considered the guidelines set out in Vangedal-Nielsen v Commissioner of Patents and Lyons (trading as Mitty's Authorised Newsagency) v Registrar of Trade and found that Turner had made out a proper case for the extensions. The delegate also found that the balance of convenience favoured Turner, given the potential costs and inconvenience to both parties if the extensions were not allowed, and the public interest in allowing both parties to present their evidence fully.

The matter before this court pertains to applications for extensions of time to file evidence in support of oppositions to trade mark applications 765075, 800208, and 818213 filed by Yo-Merry Todd. The applications to register these trade marks, which include the words "THE WIZARD OF OZ," were opposed by Turner Entertainment Company. The case originated from a series of trade mark applications filed by Ms Todd for various goods, including clothing, pet foods, and paper goods. Turner filed notices of opposition to these applications, and subsequently sought extensions of time to file evidence in support of their oppositions. Ms Todd opposed these extensions. The issues were heard before the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks on 15 February 2001, with submissions made by teleconference. Prior to the hearing, the parties had engaged in several rounds of negotiations, which were complicated by changes in Ms Todd's legal representation. The delegate considered the procedural history, including the nature and outcome of the negotiations, and concluded that Turner had provided sufficient reasons and made out a proper case for the extensions sought. The delegate also found that the balance of convenience and the public interest favoured granting the extensions, leading to the decision to allow the extensions of time sought by Turner. Turner was awarded costs against Ms Todd for the hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Turner has provided sufficient reasons to justify the extension of time to file evidence in support of opposition to the trade mark applications?
2. Whether a proper case has been made out justifying the extension of time, considering the balance of convenience to the parties and the public interest?
3. Whether the negotiations instigated by Yo-Merry Todd and her various legal representatives have contributed to the delay on the part of Turner in serving evidence?
4. Whether the balance of convenience to the parties, and the public interest, supports allowing the extensions of time for Turner to file evidence in support of opposition to the trade mark applications?

Held
1. Whether Turner has provided sufficient reasons to justify the extension of time to file evidence in support of opposition to the trade mark applications?
The court concluded that Turner has provided sufficient reasons justifying the extension of time. The result was that the extensions of time were allowed.

2. Whether a proper case has been made out justifying the extension of time, considering the balance of convenience to the parties and the public interest?
The court concluded that a proper case has been made out justifying the extension of time, considering the balance of convenience to the parties and the public interest. The result was that the extensions of time were allowed.

3. Whether the negotiations instigated by Yo-Merry Todd and her various legal representatives have contributed to the delay on the part of Turner in serving evidence?
The court concluded that the negotiations instigated by Yo-Merry Todd and her various legal representatives have contributed to the delay on the part of Turner in serving evidence. The result was that the extensions of time were allowed.

4. Whether the balance of convenience to the parties, and the public interest, supports allowing the extensions of time for Turner to file evidence in support of opposition to the trade mark applications?
The court concluded that the balance of convenience to the parties and the public interest supports allowing the extensions of time for Turner to file evidence in support of opposition to the trade mark applications. The result was that the extensions of time were allowed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court analyzed whether Turner had provided sufficient reasons to justify the extension of time to file evidence in support of the opposition to the trade mark applications. It considered the fact that Yo-Merry Todd had initiated negotiations and the confusion surrounding her various legal representatives, which contributed to the delay on the part of Turner in serving evidence. The court found that the circumstances provided sufficient reason and a proper case was made out justifying the extension of time.

In considering whether a proper case has been made out justifying the extension of time, the court examined the balance of convenience to the parties and the public interest. The court noted that there were three parallel oppositions on foot, and it was in the interests of both parties and the registrar to have the issues dealt with conjointly in one forum. The court also took into account the public interest in allowing both parties to present their evidence and arguments fully, particularly as Turner had alleged deception and confusion in terms of sections 43, 44 and 60 of the Act.

Regarding the contribution of negotiations instigated by Yo-Merry Todd and her various legal representatives to the delay on the part of Turner in serving evidence, the court found that these negotiations, as well as the confusion surrounding her various legal representatives, had contributed materially to the time it had taken to reach a resolution. The court acknowledged that Yo-Merry Todd's eagerness to resolve the issues and her attempts at negotiation had played a role in the delay.

Lastly, the court considered the balance of convenience to the parties and the public interest in supporting the extensions of time for Turner to file evidence in support of opposition to the trade mark applications. The court found that the balance of convenience swung towards Turner, as there was potential for great inconvenience and cost to both parties if the extensions were not allowed, and it furthered the public interest to allow consideration of any available evidence that would assist in providing a clearer picture of the awareness of rival marks as affecting the likelihood of deception or confusion.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in matters involving trade mark oppositions, the court will consider the sufficiency of reasons provided for an extension of time to file evidence, the balance of convenience to the parties, and the public interest when determining whether to grant such an extension. The court may take into account factors such as negotiations initiated by the applicant for registration, confusion surrounding the applicant's legal representatives, and the overall interest in resolving the dispute efficiently and effectively.