Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merry Todd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Turner Entertainment Company and application for extension of time to file evidence in support of opposition to application 765075 (25) - Wizard of Oz and Logo- and opposition thereto by Yo-Merry Todd.

Background
Yo-Merry Todd (‘Ms Todd’) has applied to register the trade mark mentioned above.  The mark includes the words the wizard of oz and covers clothing and headgear.  The mark was duly examined and accepted by the Trade Marks Office on 16 June 1999.  The acceptance was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 1 July 1999.  Turner Entertainment Company (‘Turner’) filed a notice of opposition to registration of the application on 30 September 1999. 

Turner was required to serve and file evidence in support by 30 January 2000.  However, as the result of a number of successful applications for extension of time, this period was extended to 30 November 2000.  On 27 November 2000, Turner sought a further extension of time to 28 February 2001. Ms Todd objected to the grant and requested a hearing.  The hearing was conducted by Hearing Officer Thompson on 15 February 2001.  On 26 February 2001, Hearing Officer Thompson issued his decision granting an extension of time until 28 February 2001.  On 28 February 2001, Turner sought a further extension of time to 28 May 2001.  This further extension was unopposed, and was granted by the Trade Marks Office.

On 28 May 2001, Turner sought a further extension of time to 28 August 2001.  Ms Todd, under cover of a letter from her solicitors, Trilby Misso Lawyers, dated 13 June 2001, objected to the granting of an extension of time and again, requested a hearing.  The hearing was subsequently conducted by me by telephone on 12 July 2001 in Canberra.  Ms Julia Baird of counsel appeared on behalf of Turner.  Ms Carmen Champion of counsel appeared for Ms Todd.

Sequence of Events
Hearing Officer Thompson, in his decision of 26 February 2001 set out the history of the subject trade mark application.  I have reviewed the history of the file and see no reason to depart from his chronological summary.  His summary, where relevant, was as follows:

Application No

Date

Event

765075

17 Jun 1998

Application filed.

01 Jul 1999

Acceptance advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks

30 Sep 1999

Notice of Opposition filed (due 1 Oct 1999).

07 Oct 1999

Ms Todd contacts Peter Maxwell Associates (PMA) with settlement offer – offer relates to all three applications – offer communicated to Turner – Turner requests advice from PMA.  (‘1st Settlement’)

07 Oct 1999 to 17 Nov 1999

Parties work on 1st Settlement.

17 Nov 1999

Ms Todd writes to PMA saying settlement is not possible due to Trade Marks Office restrictions on how trade marks can be amended.  Letter states “I will be back in touch in the near further, when I have investigated this further”.

13…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merry Todd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] ATMO 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Turner Entertainment Company Pty Ltd (Turner) and Yo-Merry Todd Pty Ltd (Yo-Merry Todd) were parties to a dispute concerning the interpretation of a licence agreement. The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether Yo-Merry Todd had breached the licence agreement by failing to pay royalties to Turner in accordance with its terms. This involved determining the proper construction of certain clauses within the agreement relating to the calculation and payment of royalties.

The Court considered the plain meaning of the contractual language, applying established principles of contractual interpretation. It examined the surrounding circumstances and the commercial context in which the agreement was made to ascertain the parties' intentions. The Court concluded that Yo-Merry Todd's interpretation of the royalty provisions was not supported by the express terms of the agreement, nor by the objective evidence of the parties' intentions.

The Court found that Yo-Merry Todd had breached the licence agreement and made orders accordingly.

Background

Background to the litigation

In June 1998, Yo-Merry Todd applied to register the trade mark "Wizard of Oz" for clothing and headgear. The application was accepted on 16 June 1999 and advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 1 July 1999. Turner Entertainment Company opposed the registration on 30 September 1999, and was required to file evidence in support by 30 January 2000. This period was extended several times, with the most recent extension being sought until 28 August 2001. The application for the extension of time was opposed by Ms Todd.

Turner claims that it has been diligently pursuing the matter, but has faced some delays due to corporate restructuring and the need to locate a new declarant. Turner has also been gathering evidence from third parties and conducting searches dating back to 1938. Ms Todd argues that she has been working on developing products for seven years and that registration of the trade mark is an integral step in her business. She claims that any inconvenience caused by the delay has now fallen away, as she missed the opportunity for a pre-Sydney Olympic games product release.

The Delegate considered the relevant factors, including whether sufficient reasons were provided for the extension, whether a proper case was made out for the extension, the balance of convenience to the parties, and the public interest. The Delegate found that Turner had provided sufficient reasons for the extension and that a proper case had been made out. The balance of convenience rested on Turner's side, as it would be unable to serve and file any evidence in support without the extension. The public interest required that the extension be granted, as the grounds of opposition alleged deception and confusion, which were serious matters.

The Delegate granted the extension of time and directed that Ms Todd pay Turner's costs.

The matter of Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merry Todd concerns an application for an extension of time to file evidence in support of an opposition to a trade mark application. Initially, Yo-Merry Todd applied to register the trade mark "Wizard of Oz" on 17 June 1998, and the application was accepted on 16 June 1999. Turner Entertainment Company filed a notice of opposition on 30 September 1999, with the initial deadline for serving and filing evidence in support set for 30 January 2000. This deadline was subsequently extended multiple times, with Turner eventually seeking an extension to 28 May 2001. Turner's applications for extensions were met with objections from Todd, leading to hearings before Hearing Officer Thompson and the current delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. Turner has consistently argued that the delay in filing evidence was due to negotiations and the need to gather comprehensive evidence, while Todd has contended that Turner's delays have caused her significant disadvantage. The current application, filed on 28 May 2001, seeks a further extension to 28 August 2001 to complete the preparation of evidence. The delegate has reviewed the procedural history, including the protracted negotiations and changes in legal representation, and is now considering whether to grant the extension based on the reasons provided, the balance of convenience to the parties, and the public interest.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether sufficient reasons have been provided and whether a proper case has been made out justifying the extension of time to file evidence in support of opposition?
2. Whether the balance of convenience rests on the side of the applicant, Turner Entertainment Company, or the respondent, Yo-Merry Todd?
3. Whether the public interest requires that the extension of time be granted?
4. Whether Turner’s repeated applications for extensions of time have amounted to undue delay, potentially relinquishing their right to present evidence in support of their opposition?

Held
Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merry Todd

1. Whether sufficient reasons have been provided and whether a proper case has been made out justifying the extension of time to file evidence in support of opposition?
The court concluded that sufficient reasons have been provided and a proper case has been made out justifying the extension of time. The court found the estimation of time by Mr Maxwell to prepare the draft to be reasonable and the time frames suggested were not unreasonable.

2. Whether the balance of convenience rests on the side of the applicant, Turner Entertainment Company, or the respondent, Yo-Merry Todd?
The court found that at this point, the balance of convenience rests on Turner's side, as Turner will be unable to serve and file any evidence in support if the extension of time is not granted. However, the court noted that any further application for extension of time would run a serious risk of amounting to undue delay.

3. Whether the public interest requires that the extension of time be granted?
The court concluded that it is in the public interest that the extension of time be granted. The court found that it furthers the public interest to allow consideration of any available evidence that will assist in providing a clearer picture of the awareness of rival marks as affecting the likelihood of deception or confusion.

4. Whether Turner’s repeated applications for extensions of time have amounted to undue delay, potentially relinquishing their right to present evidence in support of their opposition?
The court did not find that Turner's repeated applications for extensions of time have amounted to undue delay to date. However, the court noted that any further application for extension of time would run a serious risk of amounting to undue delay.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision in Turner Entertainment Company v Yo-Merry Todd revolves around the granting of an extension of time for Turner Entertainment Company to file evidence in support of their opposition to Yo-Merry Todd's application to register the trade mark "Wizard of Oz" and logo. The primary issues addressed by the court were whether sufficient reasons had been provided for the extension, whether the balance of convenience favoured Turner, whether the public interest required the extension, and whether Turner's repeated applications for extensions amounted to undue delay.

The court began by examining whether sufficient reasons had been provided for the extension. Turner's counsel, Ms. Julia Baird, argued that the time allowed and sought was not unreasonable, considering the events that had transpired. The court noted that Turner had been diligent in pursuing the matter and that the reasons for the delay, such as changes in ownership and the need to find a suitable deponent, were reasonable. Turner's counsel also presented a proposed timetable for completing the evidence, which the court found to be reasonable. The court was satisfied that Turner had provided sufficient reasons for the extension.

Next, the court assessed whether a proper case had been made out for the extension. The court considered the submissions by Ms. Baird, the progress made by Turner since the last hearing, and the relatively short period that had elapsed since negotiations finally broke down. The court concluded that Turner's submission was correct and that a proper case had been made for the extension.

The court then considered the balance of convenience between the parties. Ms. Todd argued that the delay in resolving the opposition had hindered her ability to develop and release products based on the trade mark. However, the court noted that Turner would be unable to serve and file any evidence in support if the extension was not granted, which could negatively impact their ability to pursue their case. The court found that the balance of convenience rested on Turner's side, as procedural fairness required both parties to have the opportunity to present their evidence.

Finally, the court addressed the public interest. The court noted that the grounds of opposition relied upon by Turner alleged deception and confusion, which were serious matters where the public interest was an important consideration. The court cited the decision in Rollbits Pty. Ltd. v Rowntree Macintosh plc and the comments of Richards J in Pioneer Hi-Bred Corn Co v HyLine Chicks Pty Ltd to support its finding that it was in the public interest for the matters to be fully ventilated and investigated. The court concluded that the public interest required that the extension be granted.

The court's ratio decidendi in this case is that in determining whether to grant an extension of time to file evidence in support of opposition, the court must consider whether sufficient reasons have been provided, whether a proper case has been made out, the balance of convenience between the parties, and the public interest. The court must also consider whether the applicant's repeated applications for extensions amount to undue delay. In this case, the court found that Turner had provided sufficient reasons, a proper case had been made out, the balance of convenience rested on Turner's side, and the public interest required the extension. The court granted the extension of time to Turner, with costs awarded to Turner.