Turle v Johnson No. Scgrg-98-1505 Judgment No. S7024

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

TURLE v JOHNSON
[1998] SASC 7024

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. MULLIGHAN J This is an appeal against sentence.  The appellant was charged on the complaint of the respondent, an employee of the Commonwealth Services Delivery Agency, with 24 offences against the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth). He pleaded guilty to all charges before a learned Magistrate and was convicted. On 8th October 1998 a sentence of imprisonment for 15 months was imposed. The learned Magistrate ordered that the appellant was to be released after serving six months of that sentence upon his entering into a bond in the sum of $10 to be of good behaviour for a period of 24 months. He was also ordered to pay costs and fees amounting to $129 and $5,998.20 by way of reparation.

  2. The sole ground of appeal is that the sentence is manifestly excessive.  At the outset of the hearing of the appeal, Mr Griffiths acknowledged, correctly in my view, that the decision of the learned Magistrate to impose a sentence of imprisonment and not to order immediate release was within the proper exercise of the sentencing discretion.  The complaint is that he erred in the exercise of the sentencing discretion in fixing the length of the sentence and the period to be served before release both of which are said to be manifestly excessive.

  3. The charges against the appellant must be regarded as serious breaches of the law.  The appellant was regarded as a sole parent at relevant times and was receiving a part Sole Parent Pension of $335.20 per fortnight.  He was entitled to additional income of $81.10 per fortnight.  However, he obtained employment with Pace Trading Pty Ltd on 16th January 1997 and earned income of $739.61 per week.  He did not disclose that employment to the Department of Social Security Agency and consequently retained the Pension to which he was not entitled for the period from 23rd January 1997 until 13th November 1997.  The total amount of the overpayment was $5,998.20.

  4. The first 22 charges relate to receiving the pension and are breaches of s1347(b) of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth). The remaining two charges relate to false statements made by him in Sole Parent Review forms lodged by the appellant on 18th September 1997 and 28th November 1997 wherein he stated on each occasion that he had not undertaken any paid work during the previous twelve weeks when, in fact, he had paid employment with Pace Trading Pty Ltd. This conduct is a breach of s1344(1)(a) of the Act. The maximum penalty for each of these offences is imprisonment for twelve months: s1350. The Court may impose a penalty for all the offences which must not exceed the sum of the maximum penalties which could be imposed if penalties were imposed for each offence separately: s1353.

  5. The appellant is aged 37 years.  He was educated to the level of year 11 and after leaving school was employed in various jobs over the years as a driver, engraver,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turle v Johnson No. Scgrg-98-1505 Judgment No. S7024 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 7024
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Turle v Johnson No. Scgrg-98-1505 Judgment No. S7024 involved an appeal against sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court. The appellant, Turle, was convicted on 24 counts of offences under the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) for fraudulently claiming benefits while employed. The primary issue was whether the sentence of 15 months imprisonment, with a requirement to serve six months, was manifestly excessive. The appeal argued that the sentence was disproportionately harsh given the appellant's personal circumstances and potential for rehabilitation.

The court considered the nature of the offences, the appellant's background, and the principles of sentencing, particularly the need for deterrence and the possibility of rehabilitation. Turle had a significant history of drug addiction and criminal activity, but also demonstrated periods of sobriety and responsibility, particularly in his role as a father and his efforts to improve his life situation. The court acknowledged the importance of deterrence for offences against social security but also highlighted the need to consider mitigating factors, especially regarding the appellant's prospects for rehabilitation.

The court concluded that the original sentence was indeed excessive. The period to be served in custody was disproportionate to the appellant's personal circumstances and potential for rehabilitation. The appeal was allowed, and the sentence was varied to reduce the period to be served in custody to three months, while the overall sentence of 15 months imprisonment was confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Turle, was charged with 24 offences against the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) on the complaint of the respondent, an employee of the Commonwealth Services Delivery Agency. Turle pleaded guilty to all charges before a learned Magistrate and was convicted. He was sentenced to imprisonment for 15 months, with the condition that he would be released after serving six months upon entering into a bond of $10 to be of good behaviour for a period of 24 months. Turle was also ordered to pay costs and fees amounting to $129 and $5,998.20 by way of reparation. Turle had not disclosed his employment with Pace Trading Pty Ltd to the Department of Social Security, resulting in him retaining a Sole Parent Pension to which he was not entitled. The total amount of the overpayment was $5,998.20.

This case is an appeal against sentence. The appellant was initially convicted and sentenced by a learned Magistrate. The appeal against the sentence was heard by Mulligahn J in the South Australian Supreme Court. The sole ground of appeal is that the sentence is manifestly excessive. The appellant's legal representative acknowledged that the decision to impose a sentence of imprisonment and not to order immediate release was within the proper exercise of the sentencing discretion. However, it was argued that the learned Magistrate erred in the exercise of the sentencing discretion in fixing the length of the sentence and the period to be served before release.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MULLIGHAN J
Issues
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the learned Magistrate is manifestly excessive.
2. If so, what should be the appropriate period for the appellant to serve in custody.

Held
1. The sentence imposed by the learned Magistrate is manifestly excessive in that the appellant should not be required to serve six months of the 15-month sentence in custody.
2. The appropriate period for the appellant to serve in custody is three months.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MULLIGHAN J

The appeal against sentence was heard by Mulligahn J. The court began by acknowledging that the learned Magistrate's decision to impose a term of imprisonment was within the proper exercise of the sentencing discretion. However, the court found that the length of the sentence and the period to be served in custody were manifestly excessive. The court applied the principle of deterrence to sentencing, particularly in cases involving fraud against the welfare system, but also recognised the importance of considering mitigating factors and the prospects of rehabilitation. The court noted that the appellant had a long history of offending, but most of these were minor offences and there had been no convictions for dishonesty since 1989. The court considered the appellant's personal circumstances, including his responsibility to his children and defacto wife, his employment history, his response to his drug addiction, and his plea of guilty and co-operation. The court concluded that the learned Magistrate erred in not giving due emphasis to these mitigating factors and that the requirement to serve six months in custody was excessive. The court reduced the period to be served in custody to three months, which it found to be an appropriate balance between punishment, deterrence, and the encouragement of rehabilitation. The appeal was allowed for this limited purpose, and the head sentence was confirmed with the modification of the custodial period to three months. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in sentencing for offences against the welfare system, while the deterrent purpose of punishment must be paramount, mitigating factors and the prospects of rehabilitation must also be considered, particularly when determining the length of the custodial period.