Turini and Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 229

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2001/1048

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION          )          
           Re      Raul Turini  
  Applicant
           And    Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs   
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr R P Handley, Deputy President         

Date9 April 2002

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Respondent with a direction that the discretion in s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 should be exercised not to refuse the grant of a subclass 309 visa to Zenaida Turini.
  ..............................................
  R P Handley
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – Spouse visa – character test – past and present conduct - discretion to be applied if applicant does not pass the character test – need to balance other considerations including hardship to the applicant and his family against expectations of the Australian community.
Migration Act 1958 ss 499, 499(1) (2) (2A), 501, 501(1) (6), 501(6)(c)
Aksu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 514
Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 56 ALD 321
Leha and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 1054
Re Lachmaiya and Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 19 AAR 148
Rokobatani v Minister for Immigation ad Multicultural Affairs (1999) 90 FCR 583
Turini and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 731
Turini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 822

REASONS FOR DECISION

9 April 2002   R P Handley   

  1. This is an application by Raul Turini ("the Applicant") for a review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs ("the Respondent") made on 17 January 2000 to refuse the grant of a subclass 309 spouse (provisional) visa to the Applicant's spouse, Zenaida Turini ("the Visa Applicant") (hereinafter referred to by her maiden name "Mallari"). At the hearing, the Applicant was represented by Mark Robinson, of Counsel, and the Respondent was represented by Murray Allatt, Solicitor, of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the documents produced pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the T Documents"), together with the documents tendered by the parties. Oral evidence was given in person by the Applicant and by telephone by Peter Clark-Saunders.
    BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant, Mr Turini was born in Uruguay on 23 March 1959 and is aged 43.  He migrated to Australia with his family arriving on 18 March 1971 and became an Australian citizen on 2 September 1975.  He is a master jeweller.

  3. Ms Mallari was born in the Philippines on 8 July 1963 and is aged 38.  She first came to Australia on a visitor visa valid for 3 months, arriving on 17 March 1996.  On 19 March 1996, she applied for a protection visa which was refused on 28 June 1996.  This decision was affirmed by the Refugee Review Tribunal ("RRT") on 22 April 1997.  On 7 May 1997, Abel Miranda of Davidson James and Associates,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turini and Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indige... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Turini and Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs concerns the application by Raul Turini for a review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs to refuse the grant of a subclass 309 spouse (provisional) visa to Zenaida Turini, also known as Zenaida Mallari. The decision to be reviewed was made on 17 January 2000. Raul Turini was represented by Mark Robinson, of Counsel, and the Minister was represented by Murray Allatt, Solicitor, of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office. The dispute centred on whether Zenaida Turini met the character test required for the grant of a subclass 309 visa and, if not, whether the delegate exercised the discretion under s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 appropriately. The Tribunal needed to determine if Zenaida Turini was of good character, considering her past and present conduct, and whether the delegate properly applied the discretion if she did not meet the character test.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Zenaida Turini was of good character under s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958. If she was not, the Tribunal had to consider whether, in the exercise of its discretion, it should decide not to refuse the grant of the visa. The Tribunal had to balance the expectations of the Australian community with other considerations, such as the hardship to the applicant and her family. The decision hinged on the interpretation and application of s 501(1) and the principles established in relevant case law, such as Aksu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, and Leha and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs.

The Tribunal concluded that Zenaida Turini was not of good character due to her involvement in the fabrication of a protection visa application and subsequent unlawful stay in Australia. However, the Tribunal found that the delegate had appropriately exercised the discretion under s 501(1) by considering all relevant factors, including the length of her relationship with Raul Turini, the hardship that would result from the refusal of the visa, and her expressed remorse. The Tribunal ultimately decided to affirm the decision under review, finding that the delegate's exercise of discretion was appropriate and balanced the necessary considerations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by Raul Turini ("the Applicant") for a review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs ("the Respondent") made on 17 January 2000 to refuse the grant of a subclass 309 spouse (provisional) visa to the Applicant's spouse, Zenaida Turini ("the Visa Applicant") (hereinafter referred to by her maiden name "Mallari"). At the hearing, the Applicant was represented by Mark Robinson, of Counsel, and the Respondent was represented by Murray Allatt, Solicitor, of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the documents produced pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the T Documents"), together with the documents tendered by the parties. Oral evidence was given in person by the Applicant and by telephone by Peter Clark-Saunders. BACKGROUND The Applicant, Mr Turini was born in Uruguay on 23 March 1959 and is aged 43. He migrated to Australia with his family arriving on 18 March 1971 and became an Australian citizen on 2 September 1975. He is a master jeweller. Ms Mallari was born in the Philippines on 8 July 1963 and is aged 38. She first came to Australia on a visitor visa valid for 3 months, arriving on 17 March 1996. On 19 March 1996, she applied for a protection visa which was refused on 28 June 1996. This decision was affirmed by the Refugee Review Tribunal ("RRT") on 22 April 1997. On 7 May 1997, Abel Miranda of Davidson James and Associates, Solicitors, sought ministerial intervention on Ms Mallari's behalf. On 14 January 1998, the Minister refused to intervene. In April 1997, Mr Turini and Ms Mallari met through mutual friends. Thereafter, they saw each other regularly, became friends and, gradually, a deeper relationship developed. In particular, the relationship became closer following Mr Turini's and Ms Mallari's attendance at a friend's christening on 12 April 1998. On 11 July 1998, Mr Turini asked Ms Mallari to marry him. She accepted and they were married at St. Vincent's Catholic Church at Ashfield on 5 September 1998. Following the wedding, Mr Turini and Ms Mallari went to the Blue Mountains for their honeymoon but, on 8 September 1998, Ms Mallari became ill and had to return to Sydney where she was hospitalised. She underwent surgery on 9 September 1998. On being discharged from hospital on 15 September 1998, Ms Mallari was detained by departmental officers and taken to the Villawood Immigration Detention Centre ("Villawood") where she was held for 24 hours before being released on 16 September 1998, when she was granted a Bridging Visa E. On 14 October 1998, Ms Mallari returned to the Philippines. On 16 October 1998, Ms Mallari lodged an application for a subclass 309 spouse visa at the Australian Embassy in Manilla. Ms Mallari was interviewed by a departmental officer at the Embassy on 29 October 1998 and again on 2 August 1999. On 17 January 2000, a delegate of the Respondent refused Ms Mallari's application for a subclass 309 visa. On 4 February 2000, a solicitor instructed by Mr Turini lodged an application for a review of this decision by the Tribunal. On 14 August 2000, the Tribunal decided to affirm the decision under review: Turini and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 731. On 11 September 2000, Mr Turini sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision by the Federal Court and, on 29 June 2001, the Federal Court handed down its decision setting aside the Tribunal decision and remitting the matter to the Tribunal to be heard and decided again: Turini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 822.RELEVANT LAW

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue for the Tribunal to determine in this case is, therefore, whether Ms Mallari is not of good character having regard to her past and present general conduct so as to be precluded from the grant of a subclass 309 visa. If the Tribunal decides she is not of good character, it must exercise the residual discretion under s 501(1) to decide whether, nevertheless, not to refuse the grant of a visa.EVIDENCEZenaida Mallari (the Visa Applicant) Ms Mallari said she came to Australia to visit her sister Rose. She had no plan to work in Australia before arriving and only formed this plan when in Australia when it was suggested by her friend's sister, Remy. Remy suggested she could work if she applied for a protection visa. Remy obtained a protection visa application form for her and invented the false story of persecution. She then went with Ms Mallari to the Department to lodge the form. Ms Mallari's application was refused on 28 June 1996. At about that time, she consulted a migration agent, Abel Miranda of Davidson James & Associates, Solicitors. Mr Miranda advised her that she should lodge an appeal with the RRT so that she could keep working. He then did so on her behalf on her paying a fee of $1,500. Ms Mallari said Mr Miranda did not explain the process to her, but gave her hope. When her appeal to the RRT was rejected on 17 March 1997, Mr Miranda advised her to seek intervention by the Minister. He wrote such a letter on her behalf on payment of a further fee of $500. Mr Miranda told her that she could stay in Australia and work legally because her application was still being processed. Ms Mallari said she never saw the letter Mr Miranda wrote to the Minister. Ms Mallari was asked when she first showed remorse for her actions. She said that she had expressed her remorse and said she was sorry at the interview at the Embassy in Manilla on 29 October 1998, when she was interviewed by a Philippino lady, and on 2 August 1999 when she was interviewed by Miren Galloway. Ms Mallari rejected the claim made by the Departmental Delegate, Geoff Heath, that she had not expressed remorse for her actions. Ms Mallari said the first time she expressed her remorse in writing may have been in her statement dated 5 July 2000. Ms Mallari said she had told the truth to the officers who had interviewed her at the Embassy in Manilla because she wanted to be honest with them. Ms Mallari acknowledged that she became an unlawful resident 28 days after notification of the refusal of ministerial intervention on 14 January 1998. Thereafter, she was in Australia unlawfully until the issue of a bridging visa on 16 September 1998. Ms Mallari said she had told her husband of her unlawful status and it was for this reason that they consulted Brett Slater, Solicitor, shortly after their engagement on 11 July 1998. Ms Mallari acknowledged that she had been detained on her release from hospital on 15 September 1998 and then released on 16 September 1998 when she was granted a Bridging Visa E which permitted her to stay in Australia lawfully until 15 October 1998. She returned to the Philippines on 14 October 1998.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established