Tuckwell v Westpac Banking Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Tuckwell v Westpac Banking Corporation [2024] NSWPIC 227
APPLICANT: Jann Tuckwell
RESPONDENT: Westpac Banking Corporation
MEMBER: Carolyn Rimmer
DATE OF DECISION: 2 May 2024
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Claim for costs of centralisation rhinoplasty surgery; accepted injury to the face and nose; respondent disputed that the proposed surgery was reasonably necessary; applicant failed to discharge the onus upon her to establish that the surgery was necessary as a result of the injury to her face and nose on 3 March 2022; Held – award for the respondent.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     Award in favour of the respondent in respect of the claim for the surgery proposed by Professor Deva in his report of 25 July 2023 in relation to a centralisation rhinoplasty. 

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Jann Tuckwell (the applicant) was employed by Westpac Banking Corporation (the respondent) as a customer service officer.

  2. On 3 March 2022, the applicant sustained an injury to her face, including her right cheek and nose, when she fell while ascending a staircase.

  3. The applicant made a claim for medical treatment proposed by Professor Anand Deva, in his report of 25 July 2023, in relation to surgery, namely, a centralisation rhinoplasty as a result of the injury on 3 March 2022.

  4. The respondent disputed liability for the claim for the proposed surgery to the nose.

ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION

  1. The parties agree that the following issue remains in dispute:

    (a)    whether the surgery to the nose proposed by Professor Anand Deva, namely, a centralisation rhinoplasty, is reasonably necessary as a result of the injury to the nose on 3 March 2022.

PROCEDURE BEFORE THE PERSONAL INJURY COMMISSION

  1. The parties attended a conciliation conference and arbitration via video link on
    18 April 2024. The applicant was represented by Mr Luke Morgan, who was instructed by
    Ms Basema Elmasri of Turner Freeman Lawyers. The respondent was represented by
    Mr Fraser Doak, who was instructed by Ms Olivia Sommerton of Hall & Wilcox Lawyers.
    Mr Roddy Nicholson from the respondent also attended the conciliation conference and arbitration.

  2. I am satisfied that the parties to the dispute understand the nature of the application and the legal implications of any assertion made in the information supplied.  I have used my best endeavours in attempting to bring the parties to the dispute to a settlement acceptable to all of them.  I am satisfied that the parties have had sufficient opportunity to explore settlement and that they have been unable to reach an agreed resolution of the dispute. 

EVIDENCE

Documentary evidence

  1. The following documents were in evidence before the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) and considered in making this determination:

    (a)    Application to Resolve a Dispute and attached documents, and

    (b)    Reply and attached documents.

Submissions

  1. The submissions of the parties during the arbitration were recorded and I do not propose to repeat each of the arguments of counsel in these reasons.

  2. However, the respondent submitted that any deviation of the tip of the applicant’s nose…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tuckwell v Westpac Banking Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPIC 227
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Tuckwell, sought to recover the costs of centralisation rhinoplasty surgery from the respondent, Westpac Banking Corporation. The dispute arose from an injury to the applicant's face and nose on 3 March 2022. The respondent contested the necessity of the proposed surgery, arguing that the applicant had not met the burden of proving it was a consequence of the injury. The case was determined in the Workers Compensation Court of Victoria.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the applicant had successfully demonstrated that the centralisation rhinoplasty surgery was reasonably necessary as a result of her injury. The primary focus was on whether the applicant had discharged the onus of proving the necessity of the surgery, considering the evidence presented regarding the injury and its aftermath. The court also needed to assess the reasonableness of the medical advice and the overall medical necessity of the proposed procedure.

The court found that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to establish that the proposed surgery was reasonably necessary as a direct consequence of her injury. The evidence presented did not adequately demonstrate the medical necessity of the procedure, nor did it support the claim that the surgery was a direct result of the injury. Consequently, the court ruled in favour of the respondent, dismissing the applicant's claim for costs related to the centralisation rhinoplasty surgery.

The final orders of the court were in favour of the respondent, Westpac Banking Corporation. The applicant's claim for the costs of the centralisation rhinoplasty surgery was dismissed. The court held that the onus of proof had not been discharged by the applicant, and therefore, the respondent was not liable for the expenses associated with the surgery. The decision emphasised the need for clear and compelling evidence to support claims for medical expenses in workers compensation cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established