Tucker and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

[2014] AATA 181 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/0884

Re

Annamarie Tucker

APPLICANT

And

Comcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

John Handley, Senior Member

Date 3 April 2014
Place Melbourne

The decision under review is set aside and in substitution it is decided:

1.   the applicant has suffered an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood (the disease) contributed in a significant degree by the employment and is deemed to have been sustained on 23 March 2011. 

2.   The disease was suffered as a result of administrative action initiated by the employer which was not reasonable and was not taken in a reasonable manner. The entitlement of the applicant to compensation is not denied by the exclusionary provisions of s. 5A(1) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1975 (SRC Act).

3.   The application is remitted to the respondent to determine the applicant’s entitlements to compensation pursuant to the SRC Act.

4.   The respondent shall pay the applicant’s legal costs and disbursements to be determined pursuant to paragraph 6.10 Guide to the Worker’s Compensation Jurisdiction (version 2.0).

.....[sgd]..................................................................

John Handley, Senior Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – diagnosis of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood conceded – whether the result of reasonable administrative action – internal review process implemented – applicant’s complaint to manager ignored – applicant not advised she was the respondent in the process – findings made against applicant – published findings provided in heavily redacted form – the process was administrative action – was not taken in a reasonable manner – procedurally unfair – the disease not excluded by section 5A – contribution to it was by a significant degree – decision set aside, substituted and remitted

Legislation
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1975, section 5A and 5B
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, sections 20(2)

Cases
Comcare v Martinez (No 2) (2013) 212 FCR 272
Keen v Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation (1998) 71 SASR 42
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Reeve (2012) 199 FCR 463

Workcover Corporation of South Australia v Summers (1995) 65 SASR 243

REASONS FOR DECISION

John Handley, Senior Member

3 April 2014

  1. Mrs Tucker, the applicant, commenced employment with the Department of Defence (the Department) in 2005.  On 10 February 2011, she was employed as a payroll officer at APS level 3 and was working in the Civilian and Overseas Personnel Administration Centre in Melbourne. 

  2. On that date, an incident, involving the applicant and another employee occurred. Appropriate officers of the employer were notified and an investigation into it was undertaken.

  3. The parties agreed that process was administrative action. The applicant contends, contrary to the position taken by the respondent, that the administrative action was not reasonable and was not taken in a reasonable manner (s. 5A of the SRC Act).

  4. The parties also agree that the applicant did suffer injury, being a disease, which arose out of or in the course of her employment being adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood.

  5. The parties do not agree…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tucker and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tucker and Comcare involved a claim for compensation for a psychological injury arising from workplace events. Tucker, the applicant, alleged that an incident on 10 February 2011, where she was asked to terminate an employee's employment without proper documentation, led to her psychological injury. The Federal Circuit Court was tasked with determining whether the administrative action taken by the employer, Comcare, constituted a reasonable act taken in a reasonable manner, thus potentially exempting Comcare from liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The court had to assess the reasonableness of the administrative action, considering the context and circumstances surrounding the event, and whether the action taken by Comcare met the standards of a reasonable employer.

The primary legal issue was whether the administrative action taken by Comcare was reasonable and executed in a reasonable manner. This involved examining the specific administrative steps taken, the rationale behind those steps, and how they impacted Tucker. The court had to consider whether the administrative action was related to the employer's business activities or operational tasks of the employee. Furthermore, it had to decide if Tucker's psychological injury could be attributed to the administrative action taken by Comcare, and if the injury was a result of reasonable administrative action executed in a reasonable manner.

In delivering the decision, the court found that Tucker's psychological injury began on 10 February 2011, coinciding with the workplace incident. However, the court concluded that the administrative action taken by Comcare was reasonable and executed in a reasonable manner. The court found that the action was taken in response to specific circumstances and did not exceed the bounds of what a reasonable employer would do under similar conditions. The court held that the injury did not result from unreasonable administrative action, thus exempting Comcare from liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth).

The final orders of the court were that Tucker's claim for compensation was dismissed, as the administrative action taken by Comcare was deemed reasonable and executed in a reasonable manner, thus absolving Comcare from liability for the injury sustained by Tucker.

Background

Background to the litigation

Having reviewed the transcript of evidence and read the documents lodged in this review and exhibited, I am satisfied and make the following findings of fact concerning the events in the workplace precipitating the administrative action:i.On 10 February 2011 the applicant was responding to a Personnel Incident Details Report concerning the salary of another employee (Exhibit R7, Annexure GF1) sent by an officer of the Department in Sydney asking her to please ensure his pay is stopped. The applicant telephoned that officer to seek clarification of the appropriate entry to be recorded and was apparently advised that termination (of employment) be entered. The applicant objected to making that entry because the Report recorded that the employee was on unauthorised leave and it was anticipated that he would submit a resignation within a few days. The applicant expressed her view that it would be improper to record that his employment was terminated without having received hardcopy documents signed by the employee.ii.At or about the time the applicant was engaged in that telephone call, Ms Hickinbotham, who was also aware of the same Report referred it to Ms Jobson. Ms Hickinbotham then noted that the applicant was processing it. She approached the applicant to notify her that Ms Jobson had been delegated to respond to the Report but did not speak with her because she was engaged in a telephone conversation (the applicant was then speaking with the officer in Sydney who wrote the Report).iii.Ms Hickinbotham then asked Ms Karavassilis, the applicant’s team leader to notify her, when she finished the telephone call that action on the report had been referred to Ms Jobson (Exhibit R7, Annexure GF1).iv.Ms Karavassilis either intervened into the telephone call or the applicant agreed to place the call on hold while she spoke with Ms Karavassilis. The applicant completed the telephone call and noted from her screen that an entry had been made against the employee that his employment had been terminated.v.The applicant left her desk and approached Ms Karavassilis who was seated at or near the desk of Ms Jobson. The applicant complained that the entry had been incorrectly entered in the absence of appropriate hardcopy documents. She said Ms Jobson refused to discuss the issue with her.vi.The applicant agreed that she was frustrated by Ms Jobson and Ms Karavassilis either not listening to or refusing to acknowledge her concerns. She agreed she was also frustrated at not having been notified by Ms Hickinbotham that the enquiry had been transferred from her.vii.The applicant agreed she did raise her voice. She denied that she confronted Ms Jobson and Ms Karavassillis. An email from Ms Jobson, dated 10 February 2011 (Exhibit R7, Annexure GF1) does not record she was confronted but alleged the applicant was very rude and advised me to “Get off my high horse”. She recorded that the applicant would not listen to her and when she tried to explain why she had made the entry in the employee’s records the applicant just stormed off. Emails written by other employees (sought and obtained at the request of Ms Jobson) in the vicinity of Ms Jobson’s desk confirm the applicant did speak in a loud voice and she did tell Ms Jobson to Get off her high horse. Some of the emails also record that the applicant stormed off. One email (from Ms Cross) records the applicant as being very aggressive in her tone and stood over Julie. The respondent did not call Ms Jobson, Ms Hickinbotham or Ms Karavassilis or any of the authors of the emails. viii.I am satisfied the applicant did speak in a loud voice. I am also satisfied that she did tell Ms Jobson to Get off her high horse. It was inappropriate for the applicant to have spoken to Ms Jobson in a loud voice, apparently also able to be heard by others. It was also inappropriate for the applicant to ask Ms Jobson to Get off her high horse, it being an expression intended to convey, by the applicant, that Ms Jobson was acting in a superior or condescending manner.ix.To confront a person suggests an element of hostility or defiance. Because I am satisfied the applicant did storm off, I do not find that she confronted Ms Jobson, rather I find that the applicant became satisfied that it was pointless having any further conversation and she decided to return to her desk. In the transcript at page 23 she denied that she told Mr Favaro that she had confronted Ms Jobson. (Mr Favaro did not record in his report, which included a summary of the interview with the applicant that she confronted Ms Jobson. In cross examination the applicant denied (Transcript, page 18) that she confronted Ms Jobson. When she was asked the question (Transcript, page 23) You didn’t confront her? the applicant said I did. Later the applicant said that she did raise her voice but not when I first confronted her.) x.I am unable to explain the differences in the answers given by the applicant to similar questions. I do not now know whether the applicant understood the meaning of the word confront or whether her use of it bears the same interpretation as I have applied above or by counsel in cross-examination. As best I can, having reconstructed the conversation by regard to the applicant’s evidence and the documented evidence, I remain satisfied that the applicant did not confront Ms Jobson.xi.Shortly after the applicant returned to her desk she was approached by Ms Karavassilis who enquired whether she would participate in a roundtable discussion with her, Ms Jobson and Ms Hickinbotham. The applicant agreed to do so. That discussion did not ever take place. (Later that day, the applicant sought a meeting with Mr Edward. The meeting occurred on the following day and it was agreed that Mr Edward would seek a QA).xii.During the afternoon of 10 February 2011 Ms Jobson threw a note on the applicant’s desk with words to the effect I’ve done what you wanted me to do (Transcript, page 36).The entry terminating the employee was reversed and he was recorded as being on leave without pay. That appears also to be confirmed by the email from Ms Jobson who recorded that she had spoken with the officer in Sydney and approval had been given to her to record that the employee have an entry in his records of LWOP (leave without pay).Background

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For reasons which will follow I think it is doubtful that the administrative action initiated by the employer falls within any of the above events. The type of administrative action that may be initiated is not limited to the events recorded above. For reasons which will follow, I am satisfied that the process initiated by the employer, as learnt by this review, was administrative action. THE EVIDENCE Evidence was heard from the applicant, a former workmate, two doctors and three officers from the Department. A significant number of documents were also received into evidence and will be identified later in these reasons.The applicant The applicant and her counsel relied on an 18-page statement of her proposed evidence which was lodged prior to the commencement of the hearing and received as Exhibit A1. On 10 February 2011 the applicant received an Applix message, through the i-Enterprise communication system used by the Department, requesting, as she understood it, that an employee be terminated from employment. She recorded in her statement that the request made of her was inappropriate and irregular because other hard copy documentation (separation documents) in support of that request had not been provided to her. The applicant rang the employee’s manager who informed her that the employee had been working from his home. The Department wanted him to return to work at his workstation or to resign. Whilst the manager understood that the employee would resign, resignation papers had not been completed. In those circumstances the applicant recorded that she notified the manager, during the telephone discussion, that in the absence of that documentation she could not process a termination. She also recorded that she notified the manager that the Department could be exposed to an application for unfair dismissal and therefore an immediate solution to the issue would be to record the employee as being on leave without pay until he had decided to return to work at his workstation or to resign. During that discussion the applicant recorded that her supervisor, Stella Karavassilis approached her at her desk and was attempting to intervene the discussion. She placed the telephone call to the manager on hold and was told by Ms Karavassilis that the senior personnel officer in charge of her section, Janelle Hickinbotham, had authorised the termination of the employee’s employment. She described the approach by Ms Karavassilis as being quite brusque (Exhibit A1 at [9]). The applicant asked Ms Karavassilis to wait until she had completed the telephone call. The applicant completed the call with the manager and noticed from her computer screen that an entry had been made against the employee that his employment had being terminated. The applicant approached the workstation occupied by Julie Jobson, the team leader of the separations team where Ms Karavassilis was also seated. She recorded that she wanted to discuss with both of them her concerns that procedures had not been followed correctly. But I was more concerned that the Department of Defence might be exposed to criticism within ranks, public reputational damage, or financial liability for wrongful dismissal if the Applix request had been premature or otherwise in error. I was also concerned for the interests and well-being of the Defence employee whose pay had been terminated in case there had been error (Exhibit A1 at [12]).

Decision

Reasons for decision

In her report of 1 July 2013 (pages 2 and 3), Dr Rodda disagreed with the opinion of Dr Rose that the date of injury should be found to be 19 August 2011. She was satisfied that the beginning of the illness occurred on 10 February 2011, being the day of the incident in the workplace. She also reported that the onset could have been the occasion that she experienced chest pain, as Dr Rose reported. Alternatively, it could have been the occasion that she first sought psychiatric treatment. She concluded that it was difficult to pin down its occurrence to any particular moment in time in this case. CONCLUSION AND REASONS FOR DECISION Section 5A(1) of the SRC Act provides that the injury, disease or ailment (as the respondent contended – refer s. 5B(1) of the SRC Act) will not attract liability on the part of the respondent if it was suffered:·as a result of reasonable administrative action·taken in a reasonable manner·in respect of the employee’s employment.Reasonable In Comcare v Martinez(No 2) (2013) 212 FCR 272, Robertson J agreed with the decision of Lander J in Keen v Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation (1998) 71 SASR 42 at pages 47-48 (Keen) which relevantly stated:Whether the administrative action was taken in a reasonable manner by the employer will depend on the administrative action, the facts and circumstances giving rise to the requirement for the administrative action, the way in which the administrative action impacts upon the worker and the circumstances in which the administrative action was implemented and any other matters relevant to determining whether the administration [sic] action was taken in a reasonable manner by the employer. In Keen, Bleby J, at page 63, decided: …. In this case, whether administrative action is taken in a reasonable manner is very much a question of objective fact, and is to be determined against the ordinary standards of reasonable employers in all the circumstances of the case. Whether administrative action is reasonable or is taken in a reasonable manner depends first on the finding of the primary facts as to what occurred in the taking of the administrative action, namely what decision was made, who made it and why it was made, what was done, what was omitted to be done and the factual background against which the decision was made or implemented.Administrative action In the Full Court decision of Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Reeve (2012) 199 FCR 463 (Reeve), Rares and Tracey JJ at [74] decided that the administrative action does not contemplate the way in which the employee was to perform the employment itself or what were his or her duties or tasks in doing so. Administrative action contemplates taking steps under his or her contract of employment. Gray J at [31] decided the word administrative relates to the business or activity conducted by the employer, as opposed to operational activity which is a reference to the employee’s duties or the manner of performing them.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the circumstances surrounding the administrative action taken by the employer. It was found that the employer did not follow proper procedures in terminating the employee's employment, as there was no hardcopy documentation to support the decision. Additionally, the applicant was not consulted or informed about the transfer of responsibility for the incident report to another employee, which led to further frustration and stress. The court held that the employer's actions were unreasonable based on the facts and circumstances of the case.

The court also considered the impact of the administrative action on the applicant, finding that it contributed to her psychological injury. The stress and frustration experienced by the applicant due to the unreasonable administrative action led her to seek psychiatric treatment and ultimately resulted in her illness. The court concluded that the administrative action was a contributing factor to the applicant's psychological injury.

Finally, the court examined whether the administrative action was reasonable under Section 5A(1) of the SRC Act. Since the court had already found the administrative action to be unreasonable, it did not exempt the employer from liability under the Act. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that an employer's liability under Section 5A(1) of the SRC Act is not exempt if the administrative action taken was unreasonable in the circumstances.