Tsu Chien Su and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

[2014] AATA  644

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2013/4349; 4354; 4355

Re

Tsu Chien Su

APPLICANT

And

Tax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S E Frost
Mr N Gaudion, Member

Date 4 September 2014
Place Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the determination of the Board that Mr Su not be permitted to apply for registration as a tax agent for a period of three years from 9 September 2013.

.......................[SGD].................................................

Deputy President S E Frost

CATCHWORDS

TAX AGENTS – registration as tax agent – termination of registration – rejection of application for renewal of registration – prohibition on applying for registration for three years – whether length of non-application period excessive – whether fit and proper person – breaches of Code of Professional Conduct – unsatisfactory understanding of role as tax agent – shortcomings in integrity – concerns over competence as a tax agent – lack of insight into the seriousness of shortcomings – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Tax Agents Services Act 2009; ss 20-25, 30-10, 40-5, 40-25, 50-20

CASES

Tax Practitioners Board v Su [2014] FCA 731

Re Li and Tax Practitioners Board [2014] AATA 299
Re Tung and Tax Practitioners Board [2012] AATA 615

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S E Frost
Mr N Gaudion, Member

4 September 2014

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Tsu Chien Su, came to Australia in 1979 and has been an Australian citizen since 1984.  In 2005 he commenced practice as a registered tax agent under the business name John Su & Co.

  2. He continued to operate that business until the respondent Board, having determined that he was no longer a fit and proper person, decided to terminate his registration as a tax agent.  As a result of that decision Mr Su’s registration as a tax agent ceased on 9 September 2013.  The Board also decided to reject Mr Su’s application for renewal of his tax agent registration, and to determine a period of three years (from 9 September 2013) during which he is prohibited from applying for registration as a tax agent.

  3. Mr Su does not contest the Board’s decisions to terminate his registration and to reject his application for renewal.  However, he considers that the three-year non-application period is excessive.  He has applied to the Tribunal for review of that decision. 

    ISSUE

  4. The sole issue for determination by the Tribunal is whether the non-application period of three years imposed upon Mr Su is the correct or preferable decision.  We have decided that it is.  Our reasons follow.

    BACKGROUND

  5. The behaviour of Mr Su that led to the Board’s decision took place over a five-week period from 6 July 2011 to 9 August 2011.  There is no dispute about the content of that behaviour.

  6. Shortly after the end of the 2011 income year, Mr Su was approached by two men, Mr Alam and Mr Rahman, who claimed to be representatives of the recruitment company Adecco.  They asked him to prepare a large number of income tax returns for people they claimed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tsu Chien Su and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 644
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tsu Chien Su and the Tax Practitioners Board involved a dispute over the non-application period of three years imposed upon Mr Su, following his termination as a tax agent. The sole issue before the Tribunal was whether this non-application period was appropriate. The Tribunal determined that it was, and outlined its reasons for this decision. Mr Su had lodged numerous tax returns containing false information at the instruction of intermediaries who had provided him with fraudulent payment summaries. These returns resulted in the payment of significant tax refunds into bank accounts controlled by the intermediaries. Mr Su did not take reasonable steps to verify the information he was provided with or the identities of his clients.

The legal issues before the court centred around the appropriateness of the three-year non-application period imposed on Mr Su by the Board. The Board had terminated Mr Su's registration for breaching various sections of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (TAS Act) and had determined a non-application period of three years, during which he was not permitted to apply for registration. Mr Su argued that this period was excessive given his already substantial pecuniary penalty and his admission of wrongdoing. The court needed to determine whether the non-application period was justified and proportionate to Mr Su's actions.

The court considered the gravity of Mr Su's actions, including his failure to act honestly, provide services competently, take reasonable care in establishing his clients' true circumstances, and advise clients of their rights and obligations. The court also noted that Mr Su had already faced a $70,000 penalty for his contraventions. However, the court found that the non-application period was appropriate given the significant nature of Mr Su's breaches and the need to protect the public from potential future misconduct by him. The court concluded that the three-year period was proportionate to the seriousness of Mr Su's actions and the need for public protection.

The Tribunal upheld the decision of the Tax Practitioners Board, affirming that the three-year non-application period was the correct and preferable decision. The Tribunal found that the penalty was justified and proportionate to Mr Su's breaches of the TAS Act and the need to maintain public confidence in the tax agent profession. The court rejected Mr Su's argument that the non-application period was excessive, given the significant nature of his misconduct and the need to deter similar conduct in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The sole issue for determination by the Tribunal is whether the non-application period of three years imposed upon Mr Su is the correct or preferable decision. We have decided that it is. Our reasons follow.BACKGROUND The behaviour of Mr Su that led to the Board’s decision took place over a five-week period from 6 July 2011 to 9 August 2011. There is no dispute about the content of that behaviour. Shortly after the end of the 2011 income year, Mr Su was approached by two men, Mr Alam and Mr Rahman, who claimed to be representatives of the recruitment company Adecco. They asked him to prepare a large number of income tax returns for people they claimed were their clients. Each man handed Mr Su a business card which appeared to indicate that they worked for Adecco. They provided no further means of identification, and Mr Su did not ask for any. After that initial meeting, Mr Rahman attended Mr Su’s office on “10 to 14” additional occasions. On each of those occasions Mr Rahman provided to Mr Su certain information in relation to between five and 10 taxpayers – allegedly clients of Adecco – including taxpayer names, tax file numbers, payment summaries and bank account details. Armed with that information, Mr Su was asked to prepare and lodge tax returns for those taxpayers. He did so. Mr Su eventually lodged 164 tax returns on the instructions of Mr Rahman and of a third intermediary, a person known by Mr Su as “Sunny”. All of those tax returns contained false information. The pay-as-you-go (PAYG) tax amounts claimed to have been withheld were overstated. The income figures were wrong. Deductions were claimed that were not allowable. In many cases the returns were processed by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) and refunds were paid into the nominated bank accounts. Most of the refunds were between $3,000 and $5,000 per tax return. The taxpayers themselves had no relationship with Mr Alam, Mr Rahman or Sunny. They had not even heard of them. They had certainly not authorised any of them to engage Mr Su to lodge their tax returns. Somehow these three men – the “intermediaries” – had come into possession of the taxpayers’ names and tax file numbers. They had created fraudulent payment summaries and had caused Mr Su to lodge tax returns which would result in the payment of refunds into the bank accounts that they, the intermediaries, controlled. Mr Su had taken no steps to confirm the bona fides of any of the intermediaries. He had not asked for any identification of any of the taxpayers and had not asked to be introduced to any of them. He had made no personal contact with any of them. Mr Su did not use the ATO’s tax agent portal to check the accuracy of any of the payment summaries relating to the returns he lodged, or any of the details relating to the taxpayers. As a result, the tax returns that he lodged reflected not only incorrect income figures and incorrect PAYG tax amounts withheld, but in some cases even got the taxpayer’s gender wrong.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The pecuniary penalty proceedings were heard by the Federal Court in June 2014. On 10 July 2014 Jagot J imposed a penalty of $70,000 on Mr Su for 50 contraventions of the TAS Act: Tax Practitioners Board v Su [2014] FCA 731.THE REASONS FOR THE BOARD’S DECISIONS The reasons given by the Board for terminating Mr Su’s registration as a tax agent and imposing a non-application period of three years include that Mr Su breached various sections of the TAS Act and that the Board was not satisfied that Mr Su is a fit and proper person to be a tax agent. Specifically, the Board considered that Mr Su had breached four provisions of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) set out in s 30-10 of the TAS Act, namely:·s 30-10(1) – that he failed to act honestly and with integrity;·s 30-10(7) – that he failed to provide his services competently;·s 30-10(9) – that he failed to take reasonable care in establishing his clients’ true circumstances; and·s 30-10(12) – that he failed to advise clients of their rights and obligations under the relevant laws. The Board also formed the view that Mr Su had breached s 50-20 of the TAS Act by making a false and misleading statement to the ATO. The Board terminated Mr Su’s registration under s 40-5 and rejected his application for renewal of his registration under s 20-25 of the TAS Act. Having terminated Mr Su’s registration, the Board was empowered under s 40-25(1) to determine a period, of not more than 5 years, during which he was not permitted to apply for registration. Under this provision it determined a non-application period of three years. Mr Su does not dispute the findings of the Board or its decision to terminate his registration as a tax agent. He only disputes the length of the non-application period on the basis that it is excessive.WHY DOES MR SU SAY THAT THE NON-APPLICATION PERIOD IS EXCESSIVE? Mr Su submits that the imposition of a non-application period of three years is disproportionate to his offending conduct. He says it is so great as to crush him, particularly given that he has already had a $70,000 pecuniary penalty imposed upon him by the Federal Court. He acknowledges that his conduct was reckless but notes that it took place over a short period of time in circumstances where the intermediaries were engaging in fraudulent conduct. Further, he feels that as he has received a pecuniary penalty and admitted his wrongdoing, any further penalty or punishment should be a modest one. Mr Su notes that he has modified his work practices. He now ensures that he identifies all new clients by insisting that they attend his premises so he can meet them face-to-face. He requires them to produce at least one piece of photo identification such as a passport, drivers licence or government or student identification card. He requires, in addition to that, at least one other identification document such as a prior year notice of assessment from the ATO, a birth certificate, Medicare card or a recent bank statement. He says that he seeks information relating to their residency status for tax purposes and he also asks them for their tax file number so that he can access the ATO portal to verify the information he has been given. He is now confident that his revised work practices will either reduce or eliminate the likelihood of a recurrence of what happened in 2011.CONSIDERATION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As a result of their scam, the intermediaries appear to have enriched themselves to the extent of some hundreds of thousands of dollars, at the expense of the Australian taxpayer.THE ATO AND THE BOARD INVESTIGATE MR SU’S PRACTICE; HIS REGISTRATION IS TERMINATED AND A PENALTY IS IMPOSED In September 2011 the ATO commenced an investigation in relation to tax returns lodged by Mr Su. In January 2013 the Board commenced its own investigation, focusing on whether Mr Su’s conduct breached the Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (TAS Act). In August 2013 the Board wrote to Mr Su to inform him that it had completed its investigation. It notified him that it had decided to terminate his registration as a tax agent; that it had determined that he would not be permitted to apply for registration as a tax agent for a period of three years; and that it would be applying to the Federal Court for payment of a pecuniary penalty in respect of various contraventions of the TAS Act. The pecuniary penalty proceedings were heard by the Federal Court in June 2014. On 10 July 2014 Jagot J imposed a penalty of $70,000 on Mr Su for 50 contraventions of the TAS Act: Tax Practitioners Board v Su [2014] FCA 731.THE REASONS FOR THE BOARD’S DECISIONS The reasons given by the Board for terminating Mr Su’s registration as a tax agent and imposing a non-application period of three years include that Mr Su breached various sections of the TAS Act and that the Board was not satisfied that Mr Su is a fit and proper person to be a tax agent. Specifically, the Board considered that Mr Su had breached four provisions of the Code of Professional Conduct (the Code) set out in s 30-10 of the TAS Act, namely:·s 30-10(1) – that he failed to act honestly and with integrity;·s 30-10(7) – that he failed to provide his services competently;·s 30-10(9) – that he failed to take reasonable care in establishing his clients’ true circumstances; and·s 30-10(12) – that he failed to advise clients of their rights and obligations under the relevant laws. The Board also formed the view that Mr Su had breached s 50-20 of the TAS Act by making a false and misleading statement to the ATO. The Board terminated Mr Su’s registration under s 40-5 and rejected his application for renewal of his registration under s 20-25 of the TAS Act. Having terminated Mr Su’s registration, the Board was empowered under s 40-25(1) to determine a period, of not more than 5 years, during which he was not permitted to apply for registration. Under this provision it determined a non-application period of three years. Mr Su does not dispute the findings of the Board or its decision to terminate his registration as a tax agent. He only disputes the length of the non-application period on the basis that it is excessive.WHY DOES MR SU SAY THAT THE NON-APPLICATION PERIOD IS EXCESSIVE? Mr Su submits that the imposition of a non-application period of three years is disproportionate to his offending conduct. He says it is so great as to crush him, particularly given that he has already had a $70,000 pecuniary penalty imposed upon him by the Federal Court. He acknowledges that his conduct was reckless but notes that it took place over a short period of time in circumstances where the intermediaries were engaging in fraudulent conduct. Further, he feels that as he has received a pecuniary penalty and admitted his wrongdoing, any further penalty or punishment should be a modest one.