TSOTSIS -v- KHNEIGER & KNEIGER (No 2).
[2003] SADC 162Judge Robertson
Civil
The Plaintiff has made an application seeking an order that the Plaintiff pay the Defendants’ costs on a solicitor and client basis.
On 5 September 2003 I entered judgment for the Plaintiff in the sum of $934 together with interest of $37. I delivered written Reasons on that day. In recording that judgment I had earlier concluded that the Plaintiff on her claim was entitled to the sum of $18,176 damages and the Defendants were entitled on their cross claim to $17,242 damages. I determined that either by way of set off or pursuant to Rule 48.03(b) of the District Court Rules (“Rules”) that I was able to give judgment in favour of the Plaintiff for the difference between those two amounts, namely $934.
As part of my written Reasons, which I published on 5 September, I also ordered that each party bear their own costs. In those Reasons I set out the basis upon which I made that costs order. I also pronounced the order for costs orally when I orally entered judgment. However, immediately after I pronounced the costs order I was informed by the first named Defendant, (“Mr Khneiger”) that there was a filed offer for an amount greater than the judgment I had awarded in the Plaintiff’s favour. On receiving this information I vacated my order for costs and adjourned the question of costs for further hearing. As it turns out, Mr Khneiger was in error in that there was no filed offer pursuant to the Rules. However, the Defendants now rely upon an offer to settle the action contained in a letter from the Defendants’ solicitors to the Plaintiff’s solicitors dated 9 December 2002. This letter is described in the Defendants’ written submissions in support of this application as “the Calderbank offer”.
In the letter dated 9 December 2002, the Defendants made an offer that they would forego their cross-claim of $20,378.74 and pay to the Plaintiff the sum of $5,000 in full and final settlement of the Plaintiff’s claim. This offer was rejected by the Plaintiff’s solicitors on 13 January 2003 and a counter offer was proposed by the Plaintiff. Later a further offer was made in a letter from the Defendants’ solicitors to the Plaintiff’s solicitors dated 10 February 2003. In that letter the Defendants offered to forego their cross-claim and offered the Plaintiff $15,000 in full settlement of her claim. A further letter containing a further offer was dated 22 April 2003. In that letter, the Defendants indicated that the offer of 10 February 2003 was withdrawn. The Defendants offered to forego their cross claim of $20,378.74. They offered to pay the $15,000 referred to in the previous letter by two instalments, one to be made on 15 May 2003 and the other on 12 June 2003. The offer was to remain open only until 1.00 pm on Wednesday 23 April. This offer was rejected by the Plaintiff and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tsotsis v Khneiger & Khneiger (No 2) No. DCCIV-02-1364 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] SADC 162
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the defendants' failure to use the formal offer procedure prescribed by the court rules precluded them from relying on their settlement offers in their application for costs. The court also examined whether the plaintiff was imprudent or unreasonable in rejecting the settlement offers. The court found that the defendants' failure to use the formal offer procedure was significant and that the plaintiff's rejection of the settlement offers was reasonable, given the reduction in the plaintiff's damages as a result of expert evidence presented at trial. The court concluded that the application for costs should be refused, and each party was ordered to bear their own costs.
The court's decision highlights the importance of following court rules and procedures when making settlement offers and the need for parties to carefully consider the implications of rejecting such offers. The court also emphasised the importance of expert evidence in assessing damages claims and the need for parties to act reasonably in deciding whether to accept or reject settlement offers. The court's decision provides guidance to parties involved in litigation and the importance of adhering to court rules and procedures in the pursuit of just outcomes.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi