Tse v Evans as trustee in bankruptcy for Ngo

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tse v Evans as trustee in bankruptcy for Ngo [2024] FCA 787  

File number(s): NSD 551 of 2024
Judgment of: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 10 July 2024
Date of publication: 18 July 2024
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY – application by liquidator for leave to proceed against bankrupt in Supreme Court proceeding pursuant to s 58(3)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – principles applicable to exercise of discretion to grant leave to proceed – where trustee of bankrupt neither consents nor opposes the relief sought by the liquidator.
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 58(3)(b)
Cases cited:

Alesco Corporation Limited v Te Maari [2015] NSWSC 469

Hillig in the matter of Battaglia [2019] FCA 2191

Yan v Spyrakis as trustee in bankruptcy for Liu [2022] FCA 872

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 24
Date of hearing: 10 July 2024
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr S Jacobs; Mr K Lwin
Solicitor for the Applicants: YML Legal
Solicitor for the Respondent: Ms B Aoude of Kerrs Law Pty Ltd

ORDERS

NSD 551 of 2024
BETWEEN:

GORDON KAR MING TSE

First Applicant

TIEHONG CHEN

Second Applicant

AND:

FLEUR EVANS & DAVID SAMPSON AS TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY FOR VIET TRUNG NGO
Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

PERRY J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 JULY 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants have leave to adduce evidence in respect of prayer for substantive relief 1 pursuant to s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) in the form of that served being:

(a)the affidavit of Gordon Kar Ming Tse affirmed 10 April 2024 together with Exhibit GT-1;

(b)the affidavit of Tiehong Chen affirmed 10 April 2024 together with Exhibit   TC-1;

(c)the affidavit of Hai Xia Song affirmed 10 April 2024 together with Exhibit     HS-1;

(d)the affidavit of Yang Liu affirmed 11 April 2024 together with Exhibit YL-1;

(e)the affidavit of Kanin Lwin affirmed 25 April 2024 together with Exhibit       CH-1.

2.Leave is granted under s 58(3)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) to the applicants to continue proceeding no. 2023/00231043 in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against Viet Trung Ngo, the first defendant in those proceedings.

3.In the event that no agreement is reached on the issue of costs, on or before 4:00pm on Wednesday 24 July 2024, the applicants are to file and serve a short submission, of no more than 5 pages, in support of their position in respect of costs.

4.On or before 4:00pm on Wednesday 31 July 2024, the respondent is to file and serve any submission, of no more than 5 pages, in response on the issue of costs.

5.On or before 4:00pm on Wednesday 7 August 2024, the applicants are to file and serve any submissions in reply of no more than 3 pages.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

PERRY J:

1.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tse v Evans as trustee in bankruptcy for Ngo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 787
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Tse v Evans as trustee in bankruptcy for Ngo, the applicants sought leave to proceed against the bankrupt, Viet Trung Ngo, in Supreme Court proceedings under section 58(3)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The application was brought by the liquidators of a company, who sought to continue legal action that had been initiated before Ngo's bankruptcy, aiming to determine claims against Ngo alongside other parties. The trustee in bankruptcy neither consented to nor opposed the application.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicants were entitled to proceed with the Supreme Court proceedings against Ngo despite his bankruptcy, under the specific conditions outlined in the Bankruptcy Act. The court had to consider the relevant statutory provisions and case law to determine whether the principles supporting the grant of leave were met in this case.

The court's reasoning was based on established principles governing the grant of leave under section 58(3)(b). The court noted that leave is generally granted when the proceeding involves parties other than the bankrupt, when it is in the interests of justice for the claims against the bankrupt to be decided concurrently with those against other parties, and when the issues are complex and best resolved through a contested trial rather than a proof of debt. Additionally, the lack of opposition from the trustee and the absence of any indication that the application was made to gain an unfair advantage over other creditors were significant factors. The court found that these principles aligned with the circumstances of the case, leading to the conclusion that leave should be granted to the applicants to proceed against Ngo in the Supreme Court.

The final orders granted leave to the applicants to continue the Supreme Court proceedings against Ngo, permitted the submission of specific affidavits and exhibits in support of the substantive relief, and outlined a timeline for the submission and response on the issue of costs. The court reserved the decision on costs pending further submissions from the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants have leave to adduce evidence in respect of prayer for substantive relief 1 pursuant to s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) in the form of that served being:

(a) the affidavit of Gordon Kar Ming Tse affirmed 10 April 2024 together with Exhibit GT-1;

(b) the affidavit of Tiehong Chen affirmed 10 April 2024 together with Exhibit TC-1;

(c) the affidavit of Hai Xia Song affirmed 10 April 2024 together with Exhibit HS-1;

(d) the affidavit of Yang Liu affirmed 11 April 2024 together with Exhibit YL-1;

(e) the affidavit of Kanin Lwin affirmed 25 April 2024 together with Exhibit CH-1.

2. Leave is granted under s 58(3)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) to the applicants to continue proceeding no. 2023/00231043 in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against Viet Trung Ngo, the first defendant in those proceedings.

3. In the event that no agreement is reached on the issue of costs, on or before 4:00pm on Wednesday 24 July 2024, the applicants are to file and serve a short submission, of no more than 5 pages, in support of their position in respect of costs.

4. On or before 4:00pm on Wednesday 31 July 2024, the respondent is to file and serve any submission, of no more than 5 pages, in response on the issue of costs.

5. On or before 4:00pm on Wednesday 7 August 2024, the applicants are to file and serve any submissions in reply of no more than 3 pages.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the hearing on 10 July 2024, I granted leave to the applicants to proceed against Mr Ngo, with my reasons to be published subsequently. These are my reasons for making those orders. 2. EVIDENCE In support of their application for leave, the applicants relied upon the following affidavits:(1)Affidavit of Gordon Kar Ming Tse affirmed 10 April 2024 and Exhibit GT-1(2)Affidavit of Tiehong Chen affirmed 10 April 2024 and Exhibit TC-1.(3)Affidavit of Yang Liu, accountant, affirmed 11 April 2024 and Exhibit YL-1.(4)Affidavit of Hai Xia Song, bookkeeper, affirmed 10 April 2024 and Exhibit HS-1.(5)Affidavit of Kanin Lwin, solicitor, affirmed 25 April 2024 and Exhibit CH-1.(6)Affidavit of Kanin Lwin affirmed 26 April 2024 and Exhibit KL-3.(7)Affidavit of Kanin Lwin affirmed 20 May 2024 and Exhibit KL-3A. The applicants also filed written submissions in advance of the hearing of the application.3. LEGAL PRINCIPLES The Bankruptcy Act does not specify the factors to be taken into account in considering whether leave should be granted under s 58(3)(b) of the Bankrupcty Act. While the discretion is at large, in Yan v Spyrakis as trustee in bankruptcy for Liu [2022] FCA 872, Katzmann J at [11] identified the following matters as weighing in favour of an applicant for leave:(1)the proceeding the subject of the application involves parties other than the bankrupt and it might be necessary for the bankrupt to become a party: Re Rose; Ex parte Devaban Pty Ltd [1994] FCA 1082 (Hill J);(2)it is in the interests of justice that the claims made against the bankrupt are determined at the same time as the court determines the claims against the other parties: National Australia Bank Limited v Moore [2012] FCA 865 at [20] (Robertson J);(3)the facts are complex and the issues would be better and more comprehensively dealt with in a contested trial than if the creditor were required to lodge a proof of debt against the debtor alone: Allanson [v Midland Credit Ltd [1977] FCA 14;] 30 FLR at 114; 16 ALR at 48;(4)there is no opposition from the trustee in bankruptcy: SBA Music Pty Ltd v Hall (No 2) [2014] FCA 1116 at [28] (Wigney J); Health Services Union v Jackson (No 3) [2015] FCA 694 at [19] (Tracey J);(5)the proceeding was commenced well before the date of the bankruptcy and there is no evidence to suggest that the application was made to gain an advantage over other creditors: Stoker (Trustee), in the matter of Starr (Bankrupt) v Starr [2011] FCA 746 at [22] (Jacobson J); Jackson at [20]; and(6)the proceeding is otherwise ready for hearing such that the interests of unsecured creditors were unlikely to be prejudiced: Jackson at [20]. Similarly, in Hillig in the matter of Battaglia [2019] FCA 2191, Wigney J summarised the relevant principles at [6] to [8] as follows: The principles concerning leave under s 58(3)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act are fairly well settled. The purpose of the requirement for leave is to ensure that a bankrupt is not subjected to a multiplicity of actions which would be both expensive and time-consuming, and in some cases unnecessary: see Zervas v Burkitt [2019] NSWCA 112 at [15].The requirement for leave focusses attention on the choice between litigation and the proof of debt procedure in a bankruptcy. It will generally be appropriate for leave to be granted in cases where the issues would be better and more comprehensively dealt with by a contested trial of the action in a court proceeding than would be the case if the creditor was required to lodge a proof of debt in the debtor’s bankruptcy: see Allanson v Midland Credit Ltd (1977) 30 FLR 108; [1977] FCA 66. That would particularly be the case where the creditor’s claims involve other parties.The relevant factors to be taken into account cannot be stated exhaustively and will vary from case to case: see Burkitt at [15]. Nevertheless, the factors generally considered to be relevant to such applications include: the amount and seriousness of the claims; the degree and complexity of the legal and factual issues involved; the stage to which the proceedings have progressed; the risk that the same issues would be re-litigated if the claims were to be the subject of a proof of debt; whether the claim has arguable merit; whether proceedings are already in motion at the time of the bankruptcy; whether the proceedings will result in prejudice to creditors; whether the claim is in the nature of a test case for the interest or large class of potential claimants; whether the grant of leave will result in further litigation; whether the cost of the hearing will be disproportionate to the size of the bankrupt estate; the risk of delay; and whether pre-trial procedures such as discovery and interrogatories are likely to be required or beneficial: see Cassegrain v Gerard Cassegrain & Co Pty Limited (in liq) [2012] NSWCA 435 at [33].4. CONSIDERATIONS IN SUPPORT OF THE GRANT OF LEAVE

Decision

Reasons for decision

As such, this case squarely aligns with the kinds of situations in which leave is typically granted. 5. CONCLUSION In all of the circumstances, leave should be granted to the applicants to proceed against Mr Ngo in Supreme Court of New South Wales proceeding No. 2023/00231043. I note that at the hearing, I reserved the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established