TSC v Department for Health and Wellbeing

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

TSC v DEPARTMENT FOR HEALTH AND WELLBEING

[2021] SASCA 93

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Justice Doyle, the Honourable Justice Livesey and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

9 September 2021

HEALTH LAW - TREATMENT AND CARE OF MENTALLY ILL PERSONS - COMMUNITY TREATMENT ORDERS

Appeal from a decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The applicant has a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia and a comorbid diagnosis of PTSD.  He accepts the diagnosis of PTSD, but not the diagnosis of schizophrenia. The applicant has been subject to a number of community treatment orders since 2016.

Upon an application by the applicant’s treating doctor, the Tribunal made a level 2 community treatment order in respect of the applicant. In its review jurisdiction, the Tribunal affirmed the decision.

The primary issue on appeal was whether the applicant had impaired decision-making capacity relating to appropriate treatment of his mental illness, within the meaning of ss 16(1) and 5A(2) of the Mental Health Act 2009 (SA).

Held (by the Court), granting leave to appeal but dismissing the appeal:

1. The concepts of capacity to ‘understand’ information and capacity to ‘use’ information, as they appear in sub-ss 5A(2)(a)(i) and (iii), overlap. A conclusion that a person does not understand some piece of information relating to a decision about health care does not necessarily mean they are incapable of understanding or using it. However, the totality of the evidence may support that further conclusion.

2. The Tribunal did not err in the inferences it drew from the evidence. Its conclusion that the applicant had impaired decision-making capacity was not affected by error.

Mental Health Act 2009 (SA) Pts 4, 5; Divs 1, 2; ss 16(1). 5A(1), 5A(2), 5A(3); South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) ss 70(4), 70(5), 71(1)(a)(ii), 71(2), 71(3a), 71(3b); Mental Capacity Act 2005 (UK) s 3(1); Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic) s 68(1); Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic) s 32, referred to.
Re AKS [2016] SACAT 19; PBU & NJE v Mental Health Tribunal (2019) 56 VR 141; R v Cooper [2009] 1 WLR 1786; Starson v Swayze [2003] 1 SCR 722; GKK v Department of Health and Ageing [2018] SACAT 30; Lee v NSW Crime Commission (2013) 251 CLR 196; Furesh v Schor (2013) 45 WAR 546, considered.

TSC v DEPARTMENT FOR HEALTH AND WELLBEING
[2021] SASCA 93

Court of Appeal – Civil:  Doyle, Livesey and Bleby JJA

  1. THE COURT: Part 4 of the Mental Health Act 2009 (SA) provides for orders for the treatment of persons with mental illness, described as ‘community treatment orders’. Division 1 provides for level 1 community treatment orders, which may be made by a medical practitioner or an authorised medical professional. Division 2 provides for level 2 community treatment orders. These may be made by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’), under s 16 of the Act. Community…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TSC v Department for Health and Wellbeing and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASCA 93
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of South Australia heard an appeal from a decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The appeal concerned a level 2 community treatment order made in respect of the applicant, who has a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia and a comorbid diagnosis of PTSD. The applicant accepted the PTSD diagnosis but not the schizophrenia diagnosis. He had been subject to community treatment orders since 2016 and had previously been admitted to hospital as an involuntary patient following behaviour indicative of his mental illness, including non-compliance with prescribed psychiatric medication.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Tribunal had erred in its determination that the applicant possessed impaired decision-making capacity concerning his mental illness, as defined by sections 16(1) and 5A(2) of the *Mental Health Act 2009* (SA). This required an analysis of the statutory concept of impaired decision-making capacity and its application to the applicant's circumstances, particularly in relation to his understanding and use of information relevant to his treatment.

The Court affirmed the Tribunal's interpretation of impaired decision-making capacity, which drew upon principles established in *PBU & NJE v Mental Health Tribunal*. The Tribunal had correctly stated that capacity requires understanding, retaining, and using relevant information to make a decision, and communicating that decision. The Court noted that a person could still have capacity even if their decisions were considered illogical or irrational by others, and that the assessment should focus on capacity rather than behaviour. The Court found that the concepts of understanding and using information overlapped, and that a failure to understand some information did not automatically equate to an inability to understand or use it, although the totality of evidence could support such a conclusion.

The Court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in the inferences it drew from the evidence presented. Consequently, its finding that the applicant had impaired decision-making capacity was not affected by error. Leave to appeal was granted, but the appeal itself was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held (by the Court), granting leave to appeal but dismissing the appeal:

1. The concepts of capacity to ‘understand’ information and capacity to ‘use’ information, as they appear in sub-ss 5A(2)(a)(i) and (iii), overlap. A conclusion that a person does not understand some piece of information relating to a decision about health care does not necessarily mean they are incapable of understanding or using it. However, the totality of the evidence may support that further conclusion.

2. The Tribunal did not err in the inferences it drew from the evidence. Its conclusion that the applicant had impaired decision-making capacity was not affected by error.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant challenges the Tribunal’s application of the statutory concept ‘impaired decision-making capacity’ relating to the appropriate treatment of his mental illness. This challenge requires analysis of that concept and of the Tribunal’s interpretation and application of that concept in the case of the applicant.Background The applicant is 59 years old. He has a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia and a comorbid diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). He accepts the diagnosis of PTSD, but not the diagnosis of schizophrenia. The Tribunal accepted both diagnoses. While the applicant does not accept that he suffers from schizophrenia, he did not invite the Tribunal on review to find that the diagnosis was wrong. The applicant has been subject to a number of community treatment orders since 2016. During periods when he has not been subject to a community treatment order he has, on a number of occasions, been admitted to hospital following non‑compliance with his prescribed psychiatric medication. In August and September 2020, the applicant was subjected to an inpatient treatment order, by which he was admitted to hospital as an involuntary patient. This occurred after he had attended at the Bedford Park Medical Clinic, where he complained that staff were ‘raping him with their yellow eyes’, said that he was the Messiah with seven billion people to care for and requested the GP to ‘remove the microchip that was in his head’, which had been placed there by an ‘evil American Anaesthesiologist’. He was aggressive and hostile, and had to be transferred to hospital by police. He was discharged from hospital on 9 September 2020. He was prescribed ‘aripiprazole 400mg IM 4 weekly’. Aripiprazole is an anti-psychotic medication. The prescription was for what is commonly described as a ‘depot’ injection every four weeks, a slow-release form of delivery of the medication that obviates the need to take daily oral doses. The applicant did not attend for his depot injection on 15 September 2020 nor, in the event, on 13 October or 4 November. After the first of these non‑attendances, on 28 September 2020 his treating doctor, Dr Marwan Kassir, applied for a level 2 community treatment order concerning the applicant. The hearing was held by telephone on 27 October 2020. Dr Kassir was unable to attend, although the medical report prepared by him was before the Tribunal. A different doctor, a Dr Khan, attended in support of the application. By this stage, the applicant had missed two depot injection appointments. On 28 October 2020, the Tribunal found that the evidence met the requirements of s 16 of the Act and made a community treatment order for 12 months, expiring on 27 October 2021. The application for review The applicant sought a review of the order. On the review, the Tribunal was required to examine the decision at first instance on the evidence before it on that first occasion, but could allow further evidence or material to be presented as it thought fit.[1] Its obligation was to reach the correct or preferable decision but, in doing so, to have regard to and give appropriate weight to the decision of the Tribunal at first instance.[2][1] South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) s 70(4).[2] South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) s 70(5).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant’s complaint is not directed to the Tribunal’s initial characterisation of the test in s 16(1)(c). Rather, he submits that the Tribunal misapplied the test when it came to considering the facts. This complaint can be considered together with the other complaints, that the Tribunal drew inferences that were not available and that the Tribunal’s conclusion was not open on the evidence.The test for impaired decision-making capacity Section 5A of the Mental Health Act, set out above, provides both a definition and descriptive limits of the concept of impaired decision-making capacity as that concept is used in s 16(1)(c). The Tribunal’s statement of the test was orthodox. In explaining its understanding of the concept of ‘capacity’ in this legislative context, it drew on the decision of PBU & NJE v Mental Health Tribunal (‘PBU’),[4] which explored the concept in the similar, but not identical, legislative context of the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). To this end, the Tribunal said:[5]We accept that a person does not have to fully understand all of the precise details of the mental illness and the treatment but the person must be able to understand information relevant to the decision; the person must be able to retain that information at least for a sufficient period as to be able to use it to make a decision; and then the person must be able to communicate that decision.We accept that a person may still have decision making capacity, even if they make a decision which carries an adverse outcome for them or which others consider illogical or irrational, or with which others disagree and in this regard, the MHA does not impose a test requiring an outcome which is in the best interests of the person, or which is even reasonable.We accept that variation in human behaviour is normal and what is regarded by one person as normal may well be regarded by another as abnormal and therefore, in making the assessment required by the MHA [Mental Health Act], the Tribunal should try to avoid making an assessment as to whether or not a person meets this criteria based on their behaviour, but should strive to make the assessment based on whether or not the person has the capacity to make the decision in the manner outlined in paragraph 47 above.[4] (2019) 56 VR 141.[5] Order of the Tribunal (Internal Review of a Level 2 Community Treatment Order) 2020/SIR000302 at [47]-[49]. PBU concerned, in part, the interpretation of s 68(1) of the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). That section provides, relevantly:68 Capacity to give informed consent under this Act(1) A person has the capacity to give informed consent under this Act if the person—(a)understands the information he or she is given that is relevant to the decision; and(b)is able to remember the information that is relevant to the decision; and(c)is able to use or weigh information that is relevant to the decision; and(d)is able to communicate the decision he or she makes by speech, gestures or any other means.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established