IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Melbourne No M14 of 2001
In the matter of -
An application for Writs of Certiorari, Mandamus and Prohibition and an Injunction against THE HONOURABLE PHILIP RUDDOCK, THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent
Ex parte –
TRUONG VAN LUY
Applicant
HAYNE J
(In Chambers)
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT MELBOURNE ON THURSDAY, 22 MARCH 2001, AT 9.37 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR A.F.L. KROHN: May it please the Court, I appear for the prosecutor. (instructed by Terence T. O’Brien)
MR S.G.E. McLEISH: If the Court pleases, I seek leave to appear for the respondent. (instructed by Blake Dawson Waldron)
HIS HONOUR: Now, Mr Krohn, I have read the papers in the matter and before we get into it too far there is one aspect of it to which I wanted to draw particular attention. In the draft order nisi in its amended form, which is exhibit TOB7, there is reference in ground 6 to matters of a kind the subject of the matters of Jia and White which are presently reserved for judgment in the Court. I cannot say to you today when judgment in those matters will be given but, on its face, it would seem that those matters, and the judgment in those matters, would bear directly upon questions of the kind sought to be raised by ground 6.
MR KROHN: Yes, I accept that, your Honour.
HIS HONOUR: Now, in those circumstances, what do you say I should do? In particular, should I today go forward at all in the application or should I wait until the Court’s reasons for decision in Jia and White are published?
MR KROHN: Your Honour, in relation to that, if I may first make a very brief clarification and an apology to the Court. If your Honour sees the proposed amended ground 6, the word “actual” in the third line of the ground ought not to be there.
HIS HONOUR: Yes.
MR KROHN: The proposed ground is simply that there is a reasonable apprehension of bias.
HIS HONOUR: Yes.
MR KROHN: Now, your Honour, having said that, it may be that the judgment of the Court in Jia and White may bear directly on the matter of reasonable apprehension of bias, but it may perhaps incline more to a consideration of the actual bias ground. I do not know that. I simply mention that. The main concern that the prosecutor would have if this matter were adjourned is that he is at present in detention.
HIS HONOUR: Yes, I understand that. But let it be assumed we go forward today, let it be assumed further that on going forward you were to succeed in obtaining an order nisi, what effect would the grant of an order nisi have on the continued detention of the applicant?
MR KROHN: The order nisi of itself would not, your Honour, but the prosecutor…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Truong - Ex parte MIMA and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] HCATrans 71
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the protection visa was affected by an error of law, specifically whether the Minister failed to consider relevant considerations or took into account irrelevant considerations when making the decision. This involved an examination of the scope of the Minister's obligations under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the principles of administrative law concerning the proper exercise of discretionary powers.
Hayne J found that the Minister's delegate had failed to consider a significant portion of the evidence provided by the applicant, which was relevant to the assessment of his claims for protection. This failure constituted an error of law, as it meant the delegate did not properly consider all relevant considerations before making the decision. The court applied the principle that administrative decision-makers must genuinely consider all material before them that is relevant to the exercise of their statutory power.
The court made orders quashing the decision of the Minister and remitting the application for a protection visa to the Minister for reconsideration according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
Truong Van Luy had previously been sentenced to 16 months imprisonment for drug trafficking in October 1997. He was given a Camp Clearance Visa on 11 January 1990 and came to Australia soon after. Between 1994 and 1998, he committed several criminal offences. In September 1998, a delegate of the Minister ordered Truong Van Luy's deportation from Australia. Truong Van Luy sought review of this decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which set aside the decision to deport him on 12 March 1999.
Truong Van Luy's application for order nisi is based on six grounds, including the allegation that the Minister erred in law and acted without jurisdiction by failing to give proper genuine and realistic consideration to all relevant matters in making the decision, failing to set out in writing his reasons for the cancellation, and denying procedural fairness to Truong Van Luy by falling into jurisdictional error in that there was a reasonable apprehension that the decision was affected by actual bias.
The central contention made by Truong Van Luy was that the document entitled "Issues for Consideration for Possible Visa Cancellation under Section 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958" and on which there is endorsed the Minister's decision is a document insufficient to inform him precisely what were the considerations that were decisive in his case, or what were the comparative weightings applied to the various matters mentioned in that document by the Minister in exercising his discretion to cancel the applicant's visa.
The Court found that no arguable case for the grant of an order nisi of the kind sought was made out and dismissed the application.
The matter came before the High Court of Australia in an application for writs of certiorari, mandamus, and prohibition, and an injunction against the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs of the Commonwealth of Australia. The application was brought by Truong Van Luy, a non-citizen whose visa had been cancelled under the Migration Act 1958. The application was heard in chambers and arguments were presented by Mr Krohn for the applicant and Mr McLeish for the respondent. The Court considered the applicant's grounds for the grant of an order nisi, including the failure to give reasons, the failure to take into account relevant considerations, the unreasonableness of the decision, and the reasonable apprehension of bias. The Court also considered whether an interlocutory stay should be granted. The Court found that no arguable case was made out on the grounds advanced and dismissed the application with costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the document provided to the applicant as the "decision record" sufficiently comply with the obligation under section 501G of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to set out the reasons for the cancellation of the applicant's visa?
2. Did the Minister fail to give proper genuine and realistic consideration to all relevant matters in making the decision to cancel the applicant's visa, as required by Ministerial Policy Direction No. 17 – Visa Refusal and cancellation under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) or as otherwise required by law?
3. Did the Minister fail to take into account relevant considerations in making the decision to cancel the applicant's visa, specifically:
a. The fact that the applicant's drug offences were at the lower end of the scale and engaged in for the purpose of funding his own habit?
b. The risk of the applicant re-offending?
c. The availability of a destination for compulsory removal of the applicant if his visa were cancelled?
d. The role of the applicant's relationship with his sister in connection with his future prospects for living a beneficial life in the community?
4. Is there a reasonable apprehension of bias in the Minister's exercise of his discretion to cancel the applicant's visa, such that it may be argued that the Minister will not approach the exercise of his discretion with an open mind or a mind open to persuasion in favour of the applicant?
5. Was the decision to cancel the applicant's visa so unreasonable that no reasonable Minister could have made it?
6. Should the Court grant an interlocutory stay to prevent the Minister from taking steps to remove the applicant from Australia or exercising his discretion to cancel the applicant's visa, pending the determination of the substantive application?
Held
1. The document provided to the applicant did not sufficiently comply with the obligation under section 501G of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to set out the reasons for the cancellation of the applicant's visa. The court found that the document did not adequately explain the logical chain of reasoning and the process of reasoning adopted by the Minister to come to the decision.
2. The Minister did not fail to give proper genuine and realistic consideration to all relevant matters in making the decision to cancel the applicant's visa. The court found that the Minister had considered the relevant matters and assigned particular weight to them, in line with the ministerial direction.
3. The Minister did not fail to take into account relevant considerations in making the decision to cancel the applicant's visa, specifically:
a. The fact that the applicant's drug offences were at the lower end of the scale and engaged in for the purpose of funding his own habit: The court found that this matter was expressly taken into account in the decision.
b. The risk of the applicant re-offending: The court found that this matter was considerably treated in the issues document.
c. The availability of a destination for compulsory removal of the applicant if his visa were cancelled: The court found that the failure to advert to this fact was not a failure to advert to a relevant circumstance.
d. The role of the applicant's relationship with his sister in connection with his future prospects for living a beneficial life in the community: The court found that this matter was expressly dealt with in the issues document.
4. There was no reasonable apprehension of bias in the Minister's exercise of his discretion to cancel the applicant's visa. The court found that the statements made by the Minister did not reveal a reasonable apprehension that the Minister would not exercise his discretion with an open mind or a mind open to persuasion in favour of the applicant.
5. The decision to cancel the applicant's visa was not so unreasonable that no reasonable Minister could have made it. The court found that the Minister's decision was within the realm of reason, even considering the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's contrary opinion.
6. The court did not grant an interlocutory stay to prevent the Minister from taking steps to remove the applicant from Australia or exercising his discretion to cancel the applicant's visa, pending the determination of the substantive application. The court dismissed the application.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered several issues in the case, including whether the document provided to the applicant as the "decision record" complied with the obligation under section 501G of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to set out the reasons for the cancellation of the applicant's visa, whether the Minister failed to give proper genuine and realistic consideration to all relevant matters, whether the Minister failed to take into account relevant considerations, whether there was a reasonable apprehension of bias, whether the decision to cancel the visa was so unreasonable that no reasonable Minister could have made it, and whether the Court should grant an interlocutory stay. The court found that the document provided did not sufficiently comply with the obligation to set out reasons, but this did not amount to jurisdictional error. The court also found that the Minister had taken into account relevant considerations and that there was no reasonable apprehension of bias. Furthermore, the court held that the decision to cancel the visa was not so unreasonable that no reasonable Minister could have made it. Finally, the court declined to grant an interlocutory stay, finding that the application was not arguable. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court will not interfere with the exercise of a Minister's discretion under the Migration Act unless there is a clear legal error or failure to take into account relevant considerations.