Tru Floor Service Pty Ltd v Jenkins (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tru Floor Service Pty Ltd v Jenkins (No 3) [2006] FCA 738

TRU FLOOR SERVICE PTY LTD, PAUL ANDREW FLETCHER, VICKIE ANNE FLETCHER, COMPLEX AIR CONDITIONING PTY LTD, A P DELANEY & CO PTY LTD, KIEWA VALLEY ENGINEERING PTY LTD, C & C PRZIBELLA PTY LTD, TORNEY & ALLEN PTY LTD and EXVON PTY LTD v DAVID JOHN JENKINS and VIVIENNE ELLEN JENKINS

VID 3021 OF 2001

SUNDBERG J
10 MARCH 2006
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 3021 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

TRU FLOOR SERVICE PTY LTD
(ACN 056 201 631)

First Plaintiff

PAUL ANDREW FLETCHER
Second Plaintiff

VICKIE ANNE FLETCHER
Third Plaintiff

COMPLEX AIR CONDITIONING PTY LTD
(ACN 064 927 939)

Fourth Plaintiff

A P DELANEY & CO PTY LTD
(ACN 000 297 549)

Fifth Plaintiff

KIEWA VALLEY ENGINEERING PTY LTD
(ACN 005 311 286)
Sixth Plaintiff

C & C PRZIBELLA PTY LTD
(ACN 004 716 901)
Seventh Plaintiff

TORNEY & ALLEN PTY LTD
(ACN 000 759 106)

Eighth Plaintiff

EXVON PTY LTD
(ACN 054 370 357)

Ninth Plaintiff

AND:

DAVID JOHN JENKINS
First Defendant

VIVIENNE ELLEN JENKINS
Second Defendant

JUDGE:

SUNDBERG J

DATE:

10 MARCH 2006

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

RULING

  1. On 8 March 2006, the eighth day of the trial of this proceeding, the plaintiffs sought leave to file and serve an affidavit of Cheryl Mann sworn on 7 March.

  2. My ruling on that application was in the following terms.  Ms Mann gave evidence on 2 and 3 March.  Her evidence was lengthy and she was cross-examined extensively.  She lives in Alice Springs in the Northern Territory and is currently visiting her family at Leeton in New South Wales.  The material exhibited to the affidavit consists of about 22 financial documents retrieved by Ms Mann from Chick Vic's computer system on 6 March.  There was no explanation as to why these documents could not have been retrieved at a much earlier date so that they could have been put to Ms Mann and Mr Chamberlain while those witnesses were available for cross-examination.  In the circumstances, I refused to receive the affidavit.

  3. Yesterday, the ninth day of the trial, the plaintiffs sought to re-open the matter – again applying for leave to file and serve Ms Mann’s affidavit.  To that end, they also sought leave to file and serve other affidavits in an attempt to provide the explanation referred to earlier.

  4. I have read Ms Mann’s affidavit and the further affidavits.

  5. The defendants opposed the re-opening of the matter.  Counsel indicated that three witnesses would have to be recalled for cross-examination if the documents were received.  They were Ms Mann, Mr Chamberlain and Mr Lamb.  Mr Lamb gave expert evidence early in the trial and he too was cross-examined at length.  I have taken this potential dislocation of the proceedings into account in declining to allow the matter to be re-opened.

  6. I have, over frequent objections by the defendants, acceded to various requests by the plaintiffs to supplement the record and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tru Floor Service Pty Ltd v Jenkins (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 738
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia was presented with a case where multiple plaintiffs, including Tru Floor Service Pty Ltd and various other companies, sought to sue David John Jenkins and Vivienne Ellen Jenkins. The plaintiffs sought to amend their case by presenting an affidavit from Cheryl Mann, which was denied by the court. The plaintiffs then attempted to reopen the case to present this affidavit, alongside other affidavits, which was also denied by the court.

The legal issues the court had to consider were whether the plaintiffs were permitted to present the affidavit from Cheryl Mann and other affidavits after the court had already ruled against it. The court also had to consider whether the plaintiffs’ actions were reasonable and fair to the defendants. The court had to balance the principles of fairness and reasonableness in the legal proceedings against the plaintiffs' rights to present evidence.

The court ruled that the plaintiffs' actions were unreasonable and unfair to the defendants. The court had already denied the plaintiffs' request to present the affidavit from Cheryl Mann, and the plaintiffs' subsequent attempt to reopen the case was seen as an abuse of the court process. The court had shown considerable latitude to the plaintiffs in the past, which may have led them to believe that the court would continue to accommodate their requests. However, the court determined that it could no longer extend such accommodation and refused the application to reopen the case.

In conclusion, the court denied the plaintiffs' application to present the affidavit from Cheryl Mann and reopen the case. The court found that the plaintiffs' actions were unreasonable and unfair to the defendants, and the plaintiffs had abused the court process. The court's decision was based on the principles of fairness and reasonableness in legal proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a legal dispute between multiple plaintiffs, including Tru Floor Service Pty Ltd, and the defendants David John Jenkins and Vivienne Ellen Jenkins. The plaintiffs are seeking relief related to a business transaction or series of transactions, the specifics of which are not detailed in the excerpt. The plaintiffs have previously amended their statement of claim and filed a reply outside the usual time limits, actions which were opposed by the defendants. During the trial, the plaintiffs sought to file and serve an affidavit of Cheryl Mann, who had retrieved financial documents from Chick Vic's computer system. These documents were not available earlier despite Mann's prior testimony, and the plaintiffs' request to file the affidavit was refused by the court. The following day, the plaintiffs sought to re-open the matter to file Mann's affidavit and additional affidavits to explain the delay in retrieving the documents. This application was also refused by the court.

The case, identified as Tru Floor Service Pty Ltd v Jenkins (No 3) [2006] FCA 738, is being heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The matter, originally filed as VID 3021 of 2001, is currently in the midst of a trial. The plaintiffs have made several attempts to amend their pleadings and introduce new evidence during the trial, which have been met with opposition from the defendants. The court previously allowed the plaintiffs to amend their statement of claim and file a reply out of time. On the eighth day of the trial, the plaintiffs sought to file an affidavit of Cheryl Mann, which was refused by the court. The plaintiffs then sought to re-open the matter to file Mann's affidavit and other affidavits, which was also refused by the court on the ninth day of the trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SUNDBERG J
Issues
1. Whether the court should allow the plaintiffs to file and serve an affidavit of Cheryl Mann on the eighth day of the trial.
2. Whether the court should re-open the matter on the ninth day of the trial to file Mann's affidavit and other affidavits.

Held
1. The court refused to allow the plaintiffs to file and serve an affidavit of Cheryl Mann on the eighth day of the trial. The court found that it was unreasonable and unfair to the defendants to allow the affidavit to be filed on such late notice.
2. The court refused to re-open the matter on the ninth day of the trial to file Mann's affidavit and other affidavits. The court determined that it was unreasonable for the plaintiffs to seek to re-open the matter after the previous day's adverse ruling and that the plaintiffs' attempts to accommodate them had been exhausted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SUNDBERG J

In denying the plaintiffs' application to file and serve an affidavit of Cheryl Mann on the eighth day of the trial, the court highlighted that the affidavit contained material that could have been obtained and reviewed earlier. Ms Mann, who had already given extensive evidence and been cross-examined, was living in Alice Springs and visiting her family in New South Wales. The court considered it unreasonable for the plaintiffs to seek to introduce new evidence so late in the trial without a satisfactory explanation for the delay. The refusal to accept the affidavit was a matter of the court's discretion in managing the proceedings.

In refusing to re-open the matter on the ninth day to allow the filing of Mann's affidavit and other affidavits, the court noted its previous willingness to accommodate the plaintiffs' requests to supplement the record with last-minute affidavits. However, the court observed that the plaintiffs' actions on the eighth and ninth days of the trial, seeking to introduce new evidence after being refused, were unreasonable and unfair to the defendants. The court also considered the potential need to recall and re-cross-examine several witnesses, which would have caused significant disruption to the proceedings. The court concluded that its discretion to accommodate the plaintiffs had been exhausted and that the application to re-open the matter was therefore refused. The court's decision underscores the importance of trial management and the need to balance the interests of both parties while maintaining the integrity of the proceedings.