TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by TRS QUALITY, INC. to applications under section 92 of the Act by SYDNEY RED LINE RETAILING PTY LTD to remove trade mark numbers 329405, 701474, 706434 (various classes) - RADIOSHACK etc- in the name of TRS QUALITY INC.
Delegate: T. E. Williams Representation: Opponent: Ben Fitzpatrick of counsel instructed by Tony Lolis of Davies Collison Cave
Applicant: No appearance, no submissionsDecision: 2011 ATMO 11
S 96 removal opposition - use on some goods only. Factors to be assessed in refusing to remove registration. Removal refused.Background
TRS Quality Inc (“TRS”) is registered as the owner of trade marks 329405, 701474 and 706434 (“the registrations”). The registrations are for, respectively, the trade marks RADIO SHACK, RADIOSHACK and RadioShack; collectively, “the trade marks” although for convenience in what follows I will sometimes refer to them in the singular, as “the trade mark” or “the registration”. The registrations relate to goods and services as specified below:
329405
Class 37: Services for repairing electrical, video and sound reproducing and transmitting equipment, and electromechanical equipment, electromechanical instruments and components therefor
Class 42: Retailing, mail order stores, industrial sales and after sales services dealing in electronic equipment, radio and sound reproducing equipment, electrical and electronic devices, instrumemnts (sic) equipment and componenets (sic)[1] and parts, mechanical devices, tools and other hardware, optical and phtographic (sic) equipment, electrical and mechanical games and toys701474 and 706434
Class 9: Radios, tuners, amplifiers, speakers, and speaker enclosures; radio receiving apparatus, microphones and switches; intercoms, wireless remote control units, and wireless room monitors; electronic communications equipment; namely, pagers, telephones and facsimile machines and parts therefor; phonograph needles and phonograph records, record players and recording tapes; electronic calculators, dry cell batteries, electrical telephone answering apparatus and telephone amplifiers; microcomputer systems comprising microprocessors, keyboards, video displays, in the nature of CRT's for use in connection with computer displays, computer memories, and data cassette recorders and cassettes having software recorded thereon; video equipment; namely, televisions and satellite TV antennas; optical goods, drafting equipment, slide rules, and drafting sets; multitesters for measuring voltage currents and resistance, voltmeters, ohmmeters, exposure meters, thickness gauges, compasses, microscopes, binoculars, combination telescopes and microscopes, microphotograph attachments, magnifying lenses, built-in test lamps for photographic flash guns, and photographic timers; radar detectors for automotive use, battery testers, DC power supplies, electronic thermometers; electrical components; namely, interference filters, connectors, wire, ground rods, clips, switches, transistors, IC gates, potentiometers, resistors, amplifiers, voltage regulators, flip-flop trigger circuits, counters/dividers for use as IC tuners, IC drivers, voltage comparators, rectifiers, diodes, capacitors, tubular electrolytes, printed circuit boards and terminals therefor, CB and scanner antennas, components for CB antennas, UHF/VHF television antennas, FM antennas, UHF converter/tuner antenna parts, coaxial cables, twin lead cables, electric soldering irons, soldering guns, electrical engraving pencils, remote control television timer, bicycle radios, photoelectric-eye relay units, antenna rotors, AC line interference filters and battery chargers; VCR multiplying system, decoder/amplifier, video processor, camcorder/VCR dubbing processor, video…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read TRS Quality Inc v Sydney Red Line Retailing Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] ATMO 11
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether TRS had discharged its onus under section 100 of the Act to demonstrate that its trade marks had been used in Australia within the relevant period in respect of the goods for which they were registered. Specifically, the court had to determine if there was sufficient evidence of use for all registered goods, and if not, whether there were circumstances justifying the retention of the registration for goods on which the trade mark had not been used, pursuant to sections 101(3) or 101(4) of the Act.
The court considered evidence from TRS indicating use of the trade mark on a range of consumer electronic items. However, it was noted that the trade mark was registered for a more extensive list of electronic and electrical items in class 9 for which no evidence of use was presented. TRS argued that due to the convergence of technology and the evolving nature of electronic products, it was difficult to draw fixed lines between different categories of class 9 goods, and that consumer expectations had been shaped by large electronics companies offering a wide array of products. The court referred to established principles regarding the discretion not to remove a trade mark, even where grounds for removal exist, if it is reasonable to retain the registration. Factors considered included whether there had been abandonment of the trade mark, whether the registered proprietor retained a residual reputation, and whether the applicant for removal had taken steps to ascertain the register.
The court found that while there was evidence of use for certain goods, the trade mark was liable to be removed in respect of those goods for which no use had been demonstrated. However, exercising its discretion under section 101(3) of the Act, and considering the arguments regarding technological convergence and consumer expectations, the court determined that it was reasonable to retain the registration for all goods for which it was registered.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.