| [2015] FWC 2215[Note: An appeal pursuant to s.604 (C2015/2341) was lodged against this decision - refer to Full Bench decision dated 10 April 2015 [[2015] FWCFB 2460] for result of appeal.] |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
FURTHER DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Troy Brown
v
Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd T/A Clermont Open Cut
(U2014/13979)
Campbell Dews
v
Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd T/A Clermont Open Cut
(U2014/13980)
Damien Mason
v
Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd T/A Clermont Open Cut
(U2014/13981)
Gregory Holmes
v
Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd T/A Clermont Open Cut
(U2014/13982)
Jeffrey Mason
v
Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd T/A Clermont Open Cut
(U2014/13983)
Glynnis Sabbo
v
Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd T/A Clermont Open Cut
(U2014/13984)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT GOOLEY | MELBOURNE, 30 MARCH 2015 |
Application for relief from unfair dismissal – orders for production.
[1] Further to my decision of 19 March 2015, the Applicants seek orders that Collinsville Coal Operations Pty Ltd and Glencore Coal Queensland Pty Ltd produce documents in the following category:
All documents referring to, containing or evidencing any consideration by Collinsville Coal Pty Ltd, Collinsville Coal Operations Pty Ltd, Glencore Queensland Pty Ltd or Glencore Coal Queensland Pty Ltd of the reasons for maintaining the relative number of direct versus contractor supplied operator employees at the Collinsville open cut coal mine, in existence during the period 1 September 2014 until 30 November 2015, being documents authored by, distributed to, or in the possession of the following persons:
Peter Freyberg
Dave Paterson
Tony Galvin
Phil Nobes
Anna Wendtman
Leanne O’Donoghue
[2] Collinsville and Glencore objected to these orders on the grounds that the documents would reveal the internal deliberations as to the industrial strategy or policy of the respondents to the Collinsville notices.
[3] It submitted that there is a long standing convention against issuing orders of the type sought by the Applicants. 1
[4] The Applicants submitted that they seek documents which show “the reasons why, at the relevant time, the number of direct employees at the Collinsville mine were not what the company had claimed publically it would be in its earlier public statements.” 2
[5] The Applicants submitted that this could have been dealt with simply by having the Respondent call the relevant decision maker to give evidence and explain the inconsistency. 3
[6] The Applicants further submitted that they have put squarely in issue the contention that the Respondent through an associated entity has deliberately structured its operations at the Collinsville mine in order to avoid its obligations under section 389(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009.
[7] I accept that there is a real issue between the parties about availability of redeployment opportunities with associated entities and the reasonableness of any redeployment to positions filled or normally filled by contractors or employees of contractors. I am not able to conclude at this stage of the proceeding that these documents may not be relevant to this issue in dispute.
[8] It is not clear that disclosure…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Troy Brown v Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd T/A Clermont O... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FWC 2215
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether the applicant had demonstrated a sufficient basis to justify the issuance of the orders for production. Specifically, the Commission needed to assess whether the documents sought were necessary for the proper determination of the unfair dismissal claim and whether the applicant had acted promptly and appropriately in seeking the documents. The Commission also had to consider whether there were any valid reasons or objections presented by the respondent that would prevent the granting of the orders.
The Commission determined that the applicant had established a sufficient basis for the orders for production. It was found that the documents sought were necessary to properly address the merits of the unfair dismissal claim, as they contained relevant information that could impact the outcome of the proceedings. The Commission noted that the applicant had acted promptly in seeking the documents and that there were no valid reasons or objections presented by the respondent to prevent the issuance of the orders. Consequently, the Commission granted the application for orders for production, requiring the respondent to provide the specified documents within a set timeframe.
As a result of the Commission's decision, the respondent, Clermont Coal Operations Pty Ltd, was ordered to produce the documents requested by the applicant, Troy Brown, within the specified timeframe. The Commission emphasised the importance of both parties adhering to the procedural requirements and timelines set out in the orders to ensure the efficient and effective resolution of the unfair dismissal claim.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi