Trower v Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
32 CLR 585

THE COMMONWEALTH Public Service (Commonwealth)-Transferred officers-Officer in Public Service of H. C. OF

State-Transfer to Public Service of Commonwealth-Break in service of State between establishment of Commonwealth and time of transfer-The Constitu- tion (63 &64 Vict. C. 12), sec. 84-Commonwealth Public Service Act 1902-1918 BRISBANE, (No. 5 of 1902-No. 46 of 1918), sec. 60.

Sec. 84 of the Constitution deals in the first three paragraphs with the rights of officers of Departments of the Public Service of a State transferred to the Commonwealth, and provides that " any such officer who is retained in the service of the Commonwealth shall preserve all his existing and accruing rights, and shall be entitled to retire from office at the time, and on the pension or retiring allowance, which would be permitted by the law of the State if his service with the Commonwealth were a continuation of his service with the State." The fourth paragraph of the section enacts that "any officer who is, at the establishment of the Commonwealth, in the Public Service of a State,

32 CLR 586

and who is, by consent of the Governor of the State with the advice of the Executive Council thereof, transferred to the Public Service of the Common- wealth, shall have the same rights as if he had been an officer of a Department transferred to the Commonwealth and were retained in the service of the

The plaintiff was a classified officer in the Public Service of the State of Queensland on 1st January 1901, the date of the establishment of the Common- wealth. In January 1904 he ceased to be an officer in that Public Service, but in March 1904 he was again appointed thereto, and continued therein until October 1917, when he was appointed to the Commonwealth office of Director of Lands in the Northern Territory and was transferred to the Public Service of the Commonwealth and in that office he remained until his services were dispensed with in August 1921.

Held, that the plaintiff acquired no right under the last paragraph of sec. 84, as that provision relates only to officers in the Public Service of a State who, at the time of their transfer to the Public Service of the Commonwealth, had rights against the State based on continuous employment in the Public Service of the State from a date prior to the establishment of the Commonwealth

CASE REFERRED.

The plaintiff. Horace Melville Trower, instituted an action against the Commonwealth claiming (1) a declaration that he is still an officer of the Public Service of the Commonwealth (2) a declaration that he is entitled to retain his office of Director of Lands until such office is determined according to law and in accordance with the provisions of the Queensland Public Service Act of 1896 (3) a declaration that he was wrongly deprived of his said office on or about 22nd August 1921 (4) an order for reinstatement thereto (5) an order for payment of salary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trower v Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1923] HCA 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Horace Melville Trower, brought an action against the Commonwealth seeking declarations regarding his employment status, reinstatement to his position as Director of Lands in the Northern Territory, and damages for wrongful dismissal. The core of the dispute centred on whether Mr. Trower, a former Queensland Public Service officer, was entitled to retain certain rights under section 84 of the Australian Constitution upon his transfer to the Commonwealth Public Service. The matter was heard by the Full Court of the High Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was the interpretation of section 84 of the Constitution, specifically its application to officers who were in the Public Service of a State at the establishment of the Commonwealth but had a break in their State service before being transferred to the Commonwealth Public Service. The plaintiff contended that he met the criteria of section 84, while the Commonwealth argued that a continuous period of service from the establishment of the Commonwealth to the date of transfer was a prerequisite for acquiring rights under that section.

The Court held that the plaintiff did not acquire rights under the last paragraph of section 84 of the Constitution. The reasoning was that this provision, and indeed section 84 as a whole, was intended to protect officers whose service with the State was continuous from the establishment of the Commonwealth until their transfer to the Commonwealth. The break in Mr. Trower's service with the Queensland Public Service, occurring after the establishment of the Commonwealth and before his transfer to the Commonwealth, meant that he did not possess the requisite continuity of service to bring him within the ambit of section 84. His re-entry into the Queensland Public Service in 1904 established a new basis for his employment, and his subsequent transfer to the Commonwealth in 1917 did not revive any rights stemming from his pre-1901 State service.

Although the Court had formed an opinion on the question of section 84, it abstained from pronouncing formal judgment. This was because it was suggested that the plaintiff might have rights under section 60 of the Commonwealth Public Service Act 1902-1918, a question not fully argued. The Court reserved leave for the plaintiff to make further application regarding this alternative claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.