Tronson v White

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
27 CLR 344

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

QUEENSLAND. Insolvency-Fraudulent preference-Debt due to two creditors jointly-Payment to

one of them having knowledge of debtor's financial circumstances-Payment by that creditor to the other-Transfer of realty diminishing property divisible SYDNEY,

among creditors-Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd.) (38 Vict. No. 5), secs. 44, 105, 107, 108, 109.

An insolvent had been indebted to A and B jointly in the sum of £200, and he had paid that sum to A in circumstances making the transaction a fraudulent preference under sec. 107 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd). A immediately paid £100 to B,

Held, that A was rightly ordered to repay to the trustee for the insolvent Sec. 109 of the Insolvency Act 1874 provides that every conveyance or transfer made by any debtor unable to pay his debts as they become due from his own moneys and the effect whereof is to diminish the property to be divided amongst his creditors shall, if a petition for adjudication of insol- vency be presented against the debtor within six months thereafter and adjudication of insolvency be made thereon, be deemed fraudulent and void as against the trustee unless there is proof by the party alleging the validity of the transaction that the conveyance was made in good faith.

The insolvent transferred realty to A within the period above mentioned for £1,500; it was worth at least £1,650, and the insolvent was then unable to pay his debts as they became due from his own moneys.

Held, that the difference in value placed on A the onus of showing good faith, which, on the evidence, she had not discharged.

27 CLR 345

Decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland: In re Tronson: White v. Mary Tronson, (1919) S.R. (Qd.), 250, affirmed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Queensland.

On 25th November 1918 Thomas Bleakeley Tronson assigned his estate for the benefit of his creditors, and on 11th December 1918 a petition for adjudication of insolvency was presented by one of his creditors, based on the assignment as an act of insolvency. On 20th December 1918 an adjudication of insolvency was made on this petition, and on 3rd January 1919 Thomas Edward White was appointed by the creditors trustee of the property of the insol- vent. Prior to these events Mary Tronson (the insolvent's daughter-in-law) and one Albert Wessling had been associated in the working of a farm, which was owned by Mary Tronson and was worked by Wessling under an arrangement whereby Mary Tronson received one-half the proceeds as rent and Wessling received the balance for his work on the farm. Part of the proceeds of the farm were from time to time sold to the insolvent, and he became indebted to Mary Tronson and Wessling in the sum of £208, in respect of which he, about May 1918, gave Mary Tronson a promis- sory note payable on demand for £200. In November 1918 insol- vent was in financial difficulties, and was pressed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tronson v White and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1919] HCA 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from the Supreme Court of Queensland regarding transactions entered into by an insolvent, Thomas Bleakeley Tronson, shortly before his estate was assigned for the benefit of creditors and he was adjudicated insolvent. The appellant, Mary Tronson, was the insolvent's daughter-in-law. The trustee of the insolvent's estate, Thomas Edward White, sought to have two transactions declared fraudulent preferences and void. The first transaction involved the insolvent paying £200 to Mary Tronson and Albert Wessling, who were jointly owed this sum. The second transaction was the transfer of certain real estate by the insolvent to Mary Tronson for £1,500.

The legal issues before the court were whether the payment of £200 to Mary Tronson and Albert Wessling constituted a fraudulent preference under section 107 of the *Insolvency Act 1874* (Qd), and whether the transfer of the real estate was void as against the trustee under section 109 of the same Act. Specifically, the court had to determine if Mary Tronson had knowledge of the insolvent's financial circumstances at the time of the payment, and if the transfer of the realty diminished the property divisible among creditors and was made in good faith.

The High Court affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland. Regarding the £200 payment, the Court found that the insolvent owed a single, indivisible debt of £200 to Mary Tronson and Albert Wessling jointly. As Mary Tronson was aware of the insolvent's financial difficulties and received the payment on behalf of both creditors, she was held responsible for the entire amount, including the £100 paid to Wessling. The Court concluded that the payment was made with the view of giving a preference and that Mary Tronson was not a payee in good faith. Concerning the real estate transfer, the Court held that it fell under section 109 of the *Insolvency Act 1874* (Qd) as a transaction that diminished the property divisible among creditors. The difference in value between the sale price and the property's worth placed the onus on Mary Tronson to prove the transaction was made in good faith. The Court found that she failed to discharge this onus, particularly as there was doubt as to whether the £500 paid to the insolvent (or towards his mortgage) was her own money.

The appeal was dismissed, with costs awarded to the respondent, save for any increase in costs due to the appeal being transferred from Brisbane to Sydney, which the respondent was ordered to pay to the appellant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thomas Bleakeley Tronson, an insolvent, owed a joint debt of £200 to Mary Tronson and Albert Wessling. In November 1918, Tronson faced financial difficulties and was pressured by Mary Tronson to pay the debt. On 4th November, Tronson drew a cheque for £200 payable to "Tronson and Wessling," which was handed to Mary Tronson's husband. The cheque was cashed, and Mary Tronson received £100, which she immediately paid to Wessling. On 7th November, Tronson transferred certain real estate to Mary Tronson for £1,500, despite being unable to pay his debts as they became due from his own moneys. The real estate was worth at least £1,650. On 25th November, Tronson assigned his estate for the benefit of his creditors, and on 11th December, a petition for adjudication of insolvency was presented against him. On 20th December, an adjudication of insolvency was made, and Thomas Edward White was appointed trustee of Tronson's property. An application was made by White, the trustee, for a declaration that the payment to Mary Tronson of £200 was a fraudulent preference, and that the transfer of realty was a fraudulent preference, and that both transactions were void, and for an order directing repayment of the £200 and a transfer of the realty to the trustee. The insolvent had since died, and it was admitted that on 4th and 7th November, the insolvent was unable to pay his debts as they became due from his own moneys. Chubb J. found that the payment of £200 was fraudulent and void and that the transfer of realty diminished the property to be divided among the creditors, since the evidence was that the realty was worth at least £150 to £200 more than it was sold for. Chubb J. made the declaration and order as asked. Mary Tronson appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court against the order for payment of the £200 in respect of the £100 paid to Wessling and against the order for transfer of the realty. The Full Court affirmed the decision of Chubb J.: In re Tronson; White v. Mary Tronson. Mary Tronson now appealed to the High Court against the decision of the Full Court.

This case, Tronson v White, is an appeal against the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The insolvency proceedings began when Thomas Bleakeley Tronson assigned his estate for the benefit of his creditors on 25 November 1918. On 11 December 1918, a creditor presented a petition for adjudication of insolvency against Tronson, which was successful on 20 December 1918. Thomas Edward White was appointed trustee of Tronson's insolvent estate on 3 January 1919. The appellant, Mary Tronson, is the insolvent's daughter-in-law, and she and Albert Wessling had been working a farm owned by Mary Tronson. Tronson had become indebted to Mary Tronson and Wessling in the sum of £200, for which he gave Mary Tronson a promissory note. On 4 November 1918, Tronson paid Mary Tronson £200, who then paid £100 to Wessling. Prior to 7 November 1918, Tronson transferred certain real estate to Mary Tronson for £1,500, which was mortgaged to the Queensland National Bank. An application was made on behalf of White, the trustee of the insolvent, for a declaration that the payment to Mary Tronson of £200 and the transfer of realty were fraudulent preferences, and for an order directing repayment of the £200 and a transfer of the realty to the trustee. Chubb J. found the payment and transfer to be fraudulent and void. Mary Tronson appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court, which affirmed Chubb J.'s decision. Mary Tronson then appealed to the High Court against the Full Court's decision. The High Court dismissed the appeal with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the payment of £100 to Wessling by Mary Tronson is considered a fraudulent preference under section 107 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).

2. Whether the transfer of realty from the insolvent to Mary Tronson is a fraudulent preference under section 109 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).

3. Whether Mary Tronson can establish good faith in relation to the transaction under section 109 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).

4. Whether the difference in value of the realty is substantial enough to call upon Mary Tronson to discharge the burden of establishing good faith.

5. Whether the Court has the power to make any order in the matter for the purpose of doing complete justice under section 22 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).

Held
1. Whether the payment of £100 to Wessling by Mary Tronson is considered a fraudulent preference under section 107 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).
The court held that the payment of £100 to Wessling by Mary Tronson is a fraudulent preference under section 107 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd), and Mary Tronson is responsible for repaying the amount to the trustee.

2. Whether the transfer of realty from the insolvent to Mary Tronson is a fraudulent preference under section 109 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).
The court held that the transfer of realty from the insolvent to Mary Tronson is a fraudulent preference under section 109 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd), and the transaction is void against the trustee.

3. Whether Mary Tronson can establish good faith in relation to the transaction under section 109 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).
The court held that Mary Tronson cannot establish good faith in relation to the transaction, as she failed to prove that the £500 was her own money and not the insolvent's money.

4. Whether the difference in value of the realty is substantial enough to call upon Mary Tronson to discharge the burden of establishing good faith.
The court held that the difference in value of the realty is substantial enough to call upon Mary Tronson to discharge the burden of establishing good faith.

5. Whether the Court has the power to make any order in the matter for the purpose of doing complete justice under section 22 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd).
The court held that it has the power to make any order in the matter for the purpose of doing complete justice under section 22 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd), and the trustee has a legal right to the land subject to the Bank's rights.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia in the case of Tronson v White addressed several issues concerning the insolvency of Thomas Bleakeley Tronson and transactions conducted by him prior to his insolvency. The primary issues centered around whether certain payments and a transfer of realty were fraudulent preferences under the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd) and whether Mary Tronson, the insolvent's daughter-in-law, could establish good faith in relation to these transactions. The Court also considered whether the Court had the power to make an order in the matter for the purpose of doing complete justice.

Firstly, the Court found that the payment of £100 by Thomas Tronson to Mary Tronson, who then immediately paid £100 to Albert Wessling, constituted a fraudulent preference under section 107 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd). The Court held that the payment was made with the view of giving the creditors a preference. Mary Tronson, who was fully aware of Tronson's financial difficulties, could not be considered a payee in good faith within the meaning of section 107. This conclusion was affirmed by both the primary and appellate courts.

Secondly, the Court considered the transfer of realty from Tronson to Mary Tronson for £1,500, which was worth at least £1,650. The Court held that this transaction was a fraudulent preference under section 109 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd). The transaction diminished the property to be divided among Tronson's creditors, and the difference in value was substantial enough to impose the burden on Mary Tronson to establish good faith in relation to the transaction. The evidence showed that the realty was worth at least £150 to £200 more than the sale price, and the Court found that Mary Tronson had not discharged this burden.

Thirdly, regarding the issue of good faith, the Court found that Mary Tronson could not establish that the £500 she paid for the realty came from her own money rather than Tronson's money. This failure to prove the source of the funds contributed to the conclusion that she did not act in good faith.

Fourthly, the Court examined whether the difference in the value of the realty was substantial enough to call upon Mary Tronson to discharge the burden of establishing good faith. The Court agreed with the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Queensland that the difference in value was sufficiently substantial.

Lastly, the Court considered whether it had the power to make any order in the matter for the purpose of doing complete justice under section 22 of the Insolvency Act 1874 (Qd). The Court found that it had full power to make such an order, and since Mary Tronson had failed to establish any equity or just reason for qualifying the order for transfer, the order for transfer of the realty to the trustee was upheld.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a transaction conducted by an insolvent, which diminishes the property available for distribution among creditors, is considered a fraudulent preference if it can be shown that the insolvent was unable to pay his debts as they became due from his own moneys. Furthermore, if the transaction involves a substantial difference in value, the burden shifts to the recipient to prove good faith. In this case, Mary Tronson failed to meet this burden, leading to the conclusion that the transactions were fraudulent and void against the trustee. The Court also confirmed its power under section 22 of the Insolvency Act to make orders for the purpose of doing complete justice.