Trojan Resorts Pty Ltd v Emprove Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

[2017] QCA 153

COURT OF APPEAL

GOTTERSON JA

Appeal No 5387 of 2017
QCAT No 403 of 2015

TROJAN RESORTS PTY LTD  First Respondent/Applicant
ACN 155 640 029

v

EMPROVE HOLDINGS PTY LTD  Appellant/First Respondent
ACN 130 063 900

BODY CORPORATE FOR THE RESERVE CTS 31561         Second Respondent/Second
Respondent

JAMES ANDREW LOVEL  Not a Party to the Appeal/
  Third Respondent

BRISBANE

THURSDAY, 20 JULY 2017

JUDGMENT

GOTTERSON JA:  On 30 May 2017, Emprove Holdings Pty Ltd filed an application in this Court to which Trojan Resorts Pty Ltd is First Respondent and Body Corporate for The Reserve CTS 31561 is Second Respondent.  The application seeks leave to appeal against two decisions made in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (“QCAT”).  One is the decision of a member of QCAT made on 1 September 2015.  I shall refer to this decision as the Primary Decision.  The second is a refusal by the Appeal Tribunal of QCAT of an application for leave to appeal to it against the Primary Decision made on 2 May 2017.  Leave was required because the proposed appeal involved mixed questions of fact and law.  I shall refer to that decision as the Appeal Tribunal Decision.  A declaration is also sought that Emprove Holdings has standing to appeal the Primary Decision.

The application before me today is an application by Trojan Resorts which was filed on 21 June 2017.  It seeks orders that the application filed by Emprove Holdings be dismissed, struck out, or alternatively, stayed.  There is an application in the alternative for security for costs.  Mr James Lovel is named as Third Respondent to Trojan Resorts’ application.

Mr Lovel is the chairperson of the Body Corporate for The Reserve CTS 31561.  It is the body corporate for “The Reserve”, a residential develop situated at Varsity Lakes.  Emprove Holdings, which is wholly owned by Mr Lovel, is the registered owner of strata titled residential apartments in The Reserve.  At the 30 September 2014, Trojan Resorts and the Body Corporate were the parties to Management and Letting Agreements dated 20 August 2003 for The Reserve.

On 30 September 2014, the Body Corporate, at its annual general meeting, resolved to terminate the two agreements.  Mr Lovel cast all of Emprove Holdings’ three votes in favour of the motion to terminate.

Proceedings were then instituted in QCAT, to which Trojan Resorts and the Body Corporate, and they alone, were parties.  The Primary Decision made in those proceedings was that the terminations were invalid and of no effect.

At an extraordinary general meeting held on 31 March 2016, the members of the Body Corporate resolved to appeal to the Appeal Tribunal of QCAT against the Primary Decision.  On this occasion too, Mr Lovel cast all of Emprove Holdings’ votes in favour of the resolution.  Mr Lovel says that he was disappointed that the Body Corporate’s lawyer did not call him as a witness at the first hearing.

It is in these circumstances that Emprove Holdings has filed its application in this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trojan Resorts Pty Ltd v Emprove Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QCA 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal, Gotterson JA heard an appeal by Emprove Holdings Pty Ltd against two decisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The first decision, known as the Primary Decision, was made on 1 September 2015, and the second, the Appeal Tribunal Decision, was made on 2 May 2017. Emprove Holdings sought leave to appeal these decisions to the Court of Appeal. Trojan Resorts Pty Ltd, one of the parties to the QCAT proceedings, responded by filing an application to dismiss or stay the appeal by Emprove Holdings and seeking security for costs. The key issue before the court was whether Emprove Holdings, which was not a party to the QCAT proceedings, had standing to appeal the decisions of QCAT.

The court found that Emprove Holdings did not have the legal standing to appeal the QCAT decisions. Section 150 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) allowed a person who was an applicant for leave to appeal to the Appeal Tribunal to apply to the Court of Appeal against a refusal by the Appeal Tribunal of leave to appeal, but only with the leave of the Court of Appeal. In this case, Emprove Holdings was neither a party to the QCAT proceedings nor the applicant for leave to appeal to the Appeal Tribunal, which was refused. Therefore, it did not have the standing to appeal the QCAT decisions to the Court of Appeal. The court also noted that Emprove Holdings was not competent to appeal the Primary Decision to the Appeal Tribunal or directly to the Court of Appeal.

Consequently, the application by Emprove Holdings to appeal the QCAT decisions was struck out. Emprove Holdings was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal and the costs of the application filed by Trojan Resorts on a standard basis. The court refused an application for a certificate under the Appeal Costs Fund Act 1973 (Qld), noting that while the appeal involved a question of construction for which no authority was provided, it did not warrant the grant of a certificate.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the dispute between Trojan Resorts Pty Ltd and Emprove Holdings Pty Ltd over the management and letting agreements for The Reserve, a residential development at Varsity Lakes. The Body Corporate for The Reserve CTS 31561 is also a party to the case. Emprove Holdings, wholly owned by James Lovel, who is also the chairperson of the Body Corporate, owns strata titled residential apartments in The Reserve. On 30 September 2014, the Body Corporate terminated the Management and Letting Agreements with Trojan Resorts. Emprove Holdings voted in favour of the termination. Proceedings were subsequently instituted in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT), where it was decided that the terminations were invalid and of no effect. The members of the Body Corporate then resolved to appeal against this decision to the Appeal Tribunal of QCAT. This appeal was refused, leading to Emprove Holdings filing an application in the Court of Appeal seeking leave to appeal against the Appeal Tribunal’s decision and the Primary Decision.

Emprove Holdings filed an application on 30 May 2017 to the Court of Appeal seeking leave to appeal against two decisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The first was the Primary Decision made on 1 September 2015, invalidating the termination of the Management and Letting Agreements. The second was the Appeal Tribunal Decision of 2 May 2017, which refused Emprove Holdings' application for leave to appeal the Primary Decision. Emprove Holdings also sought a declaration that it had standing to appeal the Primary Decision. In response, Trojan Resorts filed an application on 21 June 2017, seeking orders to dismiss, strike out, or alternatively, stay the application by Emprove Holdings, and requesting security for costs. The matter came before Gotterson JA in the Court of Appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Emprove Holdings is competent to appeal the Appeal Tribunal’s Decision and the Primary Decision to the Court of Appeal.
2. Whether Emprove Holdings has standing to appeal the Primary Decision.
3. Whether the application filed by Emprove Holdings should be dismissed, struck out, or stayed, and whether security for costs should be granted.

Held
1. Emprove Holdings is not competent to appeal the Appeal Tribunal's Decision and the Primary Decision to the Court of Appeal.
2. Emprove Holdings does not have standing to appeal the Primary Decision.
3. The application filed by Emprove Holdings is struck out. Emprove Holdings is ordered to pay Trojan Resort's costs on the standard basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Under the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009, only a person who was an applicant for leave to appeal to the Appeal Tribunal can appeal to the Court of Appeal against a refusal by the Appeal Tribunal of leave to appeal, subject to obtaining leave from the Court of Appeal. Emprove Holdings was not the applicant for leave to appeal to the Appeal Tribunal, nor was it a party to the proceedings in QCAT, making it incompetent to appeal. This reasoning aligns with the provisions in the Act that limit the right to appeal to parties of the proceeding in QCAT. As Emprove Holdings was neither a party nor the applicant for leave to appeal, it lacked the necessary standing to appeal either the Appeal Tribunal's Decision or the Primary Decision. The court found that the application filed by Emprove Holdings should be struck out, with Emprove Holdings ordered to pay Trojan Resort's costs on the standard basis.