[2010] FWA 2830 |
|
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.185 - Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement
(AG2009/24055)
MT Bowles Pty Ltd T/A The Athlete's Foot Shepparton
(AG2009/24264)
Shoeology Pty Ltd T/A The Athlete's Foot Echuca
(AG2009/24307)
Fitting Fanatics Pty Ltd T/A The Athlete's Foot Plenty Valley, Ivanhoe and Northland
(AG2009/24267)
Parker Georgious Pty Ltd T/A The Athlete's Foot Greensborough
(AG2009/24267)
Araje Pty Ltd T/A The Athlete's Foot Ballarat
(AG2009/24685)
Retail industry | |
COMMISSIONER WHELAN | MELBOURNE, 20 MAY 2010 |
Applications to approve single enterprise agreements—applications refused—procedural requirements; no disadvantage test.
[1] These are all applications by franchisees of The Athletes Foot. In each case the contents of the agreement is in almost identical terms with the exception of the rates contained in the schedule which deals with rates of pay.
AG2009/24055
Procedural issues
[2] This application is made by one of the two companies that jointly operate both this business and the business trading as Athletes Foot Ballarat. Form F17 statutory declarations were made by Mr Chapman on behalf of Araje Pty Ltd and Mr Tudorovic on behalf of Triple Double Pty Ltd.
[3] The F17 declarations and the statement of Mr Chapman, who attended the hearing, indicate that a meeting of all staff was held on 18 November 2009 at which employees were given:
- A notice of representational rights;
- A copy of the proposed agreement; and
- A document entitled ‘Frequently Asked Questions’.
[4] At the meeting which was conducted by Mr Tudorovic the agreement was discussed clause by clause; Ms Grainger was elected to be the bargaining representative; and it was agreed that a vote would be held on 16 December 2009. All seven employees to be covered by the agreement participated in the vote. Six of the employees are casuals, three are under the age of 21 and none are from non-English speaking backgrounds.
[5] The rates of pay for employees covered by the agreement are contained in Schedule 1 to the Agreement. The only classification is that of ‘retail assistant’. The material before me indicates that Mr Tudorovic manages the business himself and that all of the other employees are classified as retail assistants.
[6] An issue which has concerned me is that the copy of the agreement provided to the employees is marked on the cover ‘strictly confidential’. Further, clause 32 states, ‘The contents of this Agreement and the details of employee remuneration, are strictly confidential’. Three of these employees are young persons. They would not have been able to seek any external advice about the content of the agreement on the basis that the contents were ‘strictly confidential’.
[7] The contents of the agreement were explained by Mr Tudorovic. His statutory declaration in response to question 2.14, ‘Please identify any terms of the agreement that are detrimental to an employee in any respect when compared to the NES’ is, ‘None’. This is clearly not the case in relation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Triple Double Pty Ltd T/A The Athlete’s Foot Horsham and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] FWA 2830
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Commission included whether the procedural requirements for approving single enterprise agreements were adhered to, and whether the no disadvantage test had been fulfilled. The procedural requirements involve the application being in the prescribed form and accompanied by the necessary documents, including a statement of reasons. The no disadvantage test mandates that the agreement should not disadvantage employees more than their existing conditions of employment.
The Commission found that the applications did not meet the procedural requirements as they were not accompanied by the required statement of reasons. Furthermore, the no disadvantage test was not satisfied as the evidence did not demonstrate that the proposed agreements would not disadvantage employees. Consequently, the Commission refused the applications for approval of the single enterprise agreements. The decisions were based on the applicants' failure to comply with the statutory requirements and the inability to prove that the agreements met the no disadvantage test.
The Fair Work Commission ordered that the applications for approval of the single enterprise agreements were refused. The Commission did not grant the relief sought by Triple Double Pty Ltd and directed that the agreements remain void and of no effect. This decision underscores the importance of strict adherence to procedural requirements and the necessity to demonstrate compliance with the no disadvantage test when seeking approval for single enterprise agreements.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi