Tringas, G. v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

CATCHWORDS

Practlce and procedure - amendment of

statement of claim -

prior order dismissing cause

of

action of

one applicant

-

---

whether other applicants can later rely upon the same cause

of action - whether existence of prior order constitutes a

bar to amendment.

Trade Practices Act 1974

ss.52,82,8?

Federal Court of Australia Rules 0.23

Cellulose Products Ptv. Ltd.

v. Truda

(1970) 92 H . N . (N.S.W.)

561

Aurel Forras Pty. Ltd.

v. Graham Karp Developments Pty. Ltd.

C19753 V.R. 202

Bate v. International Computers (Aust.) Ptv. Ltd.

(1984)

2 F.C.R. 536

Port of Melbourne Authority v. Anshun Pty. Ltd.

C19803 V.R. 321; C19813 V.R. 51; (1981) 147 C.L.R. 589

GEORGE TRINGAS

and STAVROULA TRINGAS

and

ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES (OPERATIONS) PTP.

LTD.

and ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES

LIMITED

V. No. G 99 of 1982

Northrop J.

Melbourne

12 February 1986

l

(Not considered appropriate for general distributlon.)

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

)

1

VICTORIA

DISTRICT

REGISTRY

1

V. No. G 99 of 1982

)

DIVISION

GENERAL

1

BETWEEN :

GEORGE

TRINGAS

and

STAVROULA

TRINGAS

Applicants

and

ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES (OPERATIONS)

PTY. LTD.

and

ANSETT

RANSFORT

INDUSTRIES

LIMITED

Respondents

COURT: NORTTHROP J.

U: 12 FEBRUARS 1986

W: MELBOURNE

MINUTE OF ORDER

THE COURT ORDERS THAT the motion be refused, with costs to

be

taxed.

(Settlement and entry of Or1

ders is deal

,t wi

, th in 0 . 3 6 of

th

,e

Rules of Court.)

I .I

IN THE FEilERAL COIJRT OF ATJSTRALIA

)

r

,.

1

. .

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

1

V. No. G 33 of 1982

1

DIVISION

GENERAL

)

BE-N

:

and

ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES (OPERATIONS) PTY.

LTD.

and

ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES

LIMITED

Respondents

COURT:

NORTHROP J.

W:

12 FEBRUARY 1986

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR

JUDGMENT

By deed of agreement dated 20 November 1381 Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty. Ltd. agreed tu sell

a

l

business

to

Newtons

Travel Services

Pty. Ltd. At all

material tlmes the applicants, George Tringas and

Stavroula

Tringas,

were

the

directors

and

two

of the

principal

shareholders of Newtons.

The applicants were parties to the

deed of agreement dated 20 November 1981 and under that

agreement jointly and severally guaranteed to Operations the

due and

punctual

performance

by

Newtons

of all its

obligations

contained

in

that

deed.

Under

the

deed

of

agreement the laws of

the Australian Capital Territory were

I

i

r

- 2 -

to apply to the rights and obligations of the parties to the

deed.

In July 1982, Newtons and the applicants commenced

these

proceedings

in

the

Federal

Court.

The then

three

applicants sought damages against Operatlons and its parent

company Ansett Transport Industries Limited, pursuant tn

s.82

of the

Trade

Practices

Act

1974 based

in

substance

on

breaches of 5.52 o f the Trade Practices Act and In

addition,

sought orders declaring the deed of agreement including the guarantee vold ab initicj pursuant- to 5.E7 of the Trade

Practices Act and

an order directing the repayment

of

the

moneys paid

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tringas, G. v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1986] FCA 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia presided over by Northrop J. was faced with a case involving George Tringas and Stavroula Tringas, who were directors and shareholders of Newtons Travel Services Pty. Ltd., suing Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty. Ltd. and Ansett Transport Industries Limited. The applicants sought damages, declarations, and orders regarding a deed of agreement that they had guaranteed. Operations had commenced proceedings against the Tringas for the guarantee, and Newtons' claim was dismissed by consent in the Federal Court. The Tringases sought to amend their statement of claim and defence to include claims based on the agreement and collateral warranties, damages, and a set-off based on equity. Operations and Ansett opposed the motion on grounds of futility and discretion. The court found that the existence of the prior judgment dismissing Newtons' claim barred the applicants from relying on the same cause of action. Additionally, the court exercised its discretion to refuse the motion, considering the delay in the matter and the orders already made. The motion brought by the applicants was refused, with costs to be taxed.

Background

Background to the litigation

By a deed of agreement dated 20 November 1981, Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty. Ltd. agreed to sell a business to Newtons Travel Services Pty. Ltd. George and Stavroula Tringas were directors and principal shareholders of Newtons, and were parties to the agreement, under which they jointly and severally guaranteed Newtons' obligations. In July 1982, the Tringases and Newtons commenced proceedings against Operations and its parent company, Ansett Transport Industries Limited, seeking damages for breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974, and orders to declare the deed of agreement void and to repay moneys paid by Newtons to Operations. Operations commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory against the Tringases for the amount due under the guarantee. In October 1982, the Federal Court ordered Newtons to provide security for costs, and the action was stayed until security was given. Newtons was wound up in June 1983, and the proceedings against Operations were dismissed by consent in February 1984. Operations then brought a cross-claim in the Federal Court for the amount due under the guarantee. The Tringases sought leave to amend their statement of claim, defence to the cross-claim, and application to include new claims based on breaches of the agreement and collateral warranties, and to set off damages suffered by Newtons against Operations' cross-claim.

The case originated in the Federal Court of Australia with the filing of a statement of claim by Newtons Travel Services Pty. Ltd., George Tringas, and Stavroula Tringas against Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty. Ltd. and Ansett Transport Industries Limited in July 1982. The proceedings were stayed in October 1982 due to an order for security for costs, which was not met by Newtons. Newtons was wound up in June 1983, and the claim by Newtons was dismissed by consent in February 1984. Operations then brought a cross-claim in the Federal Court for the amount due under the guarantee. The Tringases sought leave to amend their pleadings to include new claims based on breaches of the agreement and collateral warranties, and to set off damages suffered by Newtons against Operations' cross-claim. The motions for amendment came before Northrop J. on 6 February 1986.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the existence of a prior order dismissing a cause of action constitutes a bar to other parties relying on the same cause of action.
2. Whether the delay in bringing the motion to amend and the resulting prejudice to the respondents constitutes grounds to refuse the amendment on discretionary grounds.

Held
1. The existence of a prior order dismissing a cause of action constitutes a bar to other parties relying on the same cause of action. The court held that the applicants cannot rely on any claim that Newtons may have against Operations because the judgment against Newtons is a bar to the applicants in relying upon any such claim.
2. The delay in bringing the motion to amend and the resulting prejudice to the respondents constitutes grounds to refuse the amendment on discretionary grounds. The court refused to grant leave to amend the statement of claim, the defence to the cross-claim, and the application due to the delay and prejudice to the respondents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of whether the existence of a prior order dismissing a cause of action bars other parties from relying on the same cause of action. The court found that the judgment against Newtons, which dismissed the claim based on breaches of the Trade Practices Act, constituted a bar to the applicants in relying upon any claim that Newtons may have against Operations. The court relied on the principle that a dismissal or judgment in an action merges the cause of action in the judgment, and that cause of action cannot then be relied upon by the party to those proceedings. Other persons cannot raise the same issue in other proceedings.

The court also considered whether the delay in bringing the motion to amend and the resulting prejudice to the respondents constituted grounds to refuse the amendment on discretionary grounds. The court found that the delay and prejudice to the respondents warranted refusing the motion to amend the statement of claim, the defence to the cross-claim, and the application. The court balanced the equities of the applicants against the existence of the judgment and decided that, in all the circumstances, it would refuse to grant leave to amend on discretionary grounds. The court's decision was based on the principle that where a claim is being made or sought to be made, which cannot possibly succeed, the Court should refuse to give leave to so amend a statement of claim as to raise that particular claim. The court also considered the prejudice to the respondents due to the delay in bringing the motion to amend.