Trident Seafoods Corporation v Trident Foods Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Trident Foods Pty Limited to three applications under s92 of the Act by Trident Seafoods Corporation to remove registered trade marks 266625, 400953, 400955 (29,31) - TRIDENT – in the name of Trident Foods Pty Limited.

Delegate:

Cristy Condon

Representation:

Opponent: Sue Chrysanthou of Counsel instructed by Helen Peachy of Hodgkinson McInnes Patents

Applicant: Andrew Fox of Counsel instructed by Albert Terry of Terry Trade Mark Attorneys

Decision:

2016 ATMO 45

Section 92(4)(b) Application for removal of registered trade marks under sub-ss92(4)(b) – established 400955; Registrar’s discretion applied 266625 and 400953 trade marks to remain on the Register - 400955 to be removed from Register - No costs award – each party to bear its own costs.

Background

  1. This matter concerns three non-use applications (‘the applications’) for removal of three trade marks from the Register of Trade Marks (‘the Register’) under s92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’).

  2. All three applications were filed by Trident Seafoods Corporation (‘the removal applicant’) on 7 February 2014 and each sought removal of the relevant trade mark in respect of all the goods for which it is currently registered.

  3. Details of these registered trade marks (‘the Trident Trade Marks’) are extracted below:

    ·Trade Mark No.: 266625

    Trade Mark: TRIDENT

    Owner: Trident Foods Pty Limited

    Specification of goods:

    Class 29: Fish and fish products

    Registered from: 15 March 1973

    ·Trade Mark No.: 400953

    Trade Mark: TRIDENT

    Owner: Trident Foods Pty Limited

    Specification of goods:

    Class 29: Meat, fish, poultry and game, including sardines, mackerel,       pilchards, crab, oysters, mussels, and prawns; meat extracts, preserved,             dried and cooked fruits and vegetables, jellies, jams, eggs, preservatives          and pickles

    Registered from: 8 December 1983

·Trade Mark No.: 400955

Trade Mark: TRIDENT

Owner: Trident Foods Pty Limited

Specification of goods:

Class 31: Grains not included in other classes; living animals, fresh fruits and vegetables, seeds; live plants and flowers; malt

Registered from: 8 December 1983

  1. The ‘relevant goods’ means all the goods in all three Trident Trade Marks.

  2. In due course the applications were advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks, following which time Trident Foods Pty Limited (‘the removal opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose each application, giving the following reasons in the Statement of Grounds and Particulars for opposing removal of the trade marks:

    a)        The opponent has used the Trident Trade Marks in good faith in Australia.

    (b)      The Registrar should exercise her discretion not to remove the Trident Trade Marks from the Register.

  3. Both parties provided evidence to support their respective positions as provided for by the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’).  Once most of the evidence had been served and filed the parties requested to be heard.  Each party has also filed out of time evidence and has requested consideration of this information under regulation 21.19.

  4. I conducted the hearing as a delegate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trident Seafoods Corporation v Trident Foods Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ATMO 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerns an application by Trident Foods Pty Ltd (the removal opponent) to remove from the Australian Register of Trade Marks the trade mark "TRIDENT" registered by Trident Seafoods Corporation (the removal applicant). The proceedings were before the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The primary legal issue before the Registrar was whether to admit certain evidence filed by the removal opponent, specifically Exhibits 5 and 6 attached to a declaration by Helen Peachey. These exhibits comprised screenshots of the United States Patent and Trade Mark Office (USPTO) trade mark database showing the removal applicant's registrations in that jurisdiction, and screenshots of the removal applicant's website displaying its "Trident Trade Mark" applied to seafood products. The removal opponent's own trade mark application in Australia was also noted.

The Registrar considered Regulation 21.19 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995, which permits the Registrar to use relevant information not known to a party, provided that party is given notice and an opportunity to make representations. The Registrar was satisfied that the exhibits contained relevant information and that the removal opponent had inadvertently omitted them due to a filing error. The Registrar also noted that the removal applicant had been aware of this information for some time. Consequently, the Registrar allowed the requested information into evidence. The Registrar declined to admit a further declaration by Albert Terry on behalf of the removal applicant, citing its low probative value and late filing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence filed in accordance with the Regulations by the parties consists of five declarations in respect of all three applications. These are summarised below:The Removal Opponent’s Evidence in SupportDeclaration made by Wayne McIntosh and dated 2 October 2014 with Exhibits 1- 4 and 7-16 (‘the first McIntosh declaration’) Regulation 21.19 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 provides:Registrar may use information available(1) If:(a) information that is available to the Registrar is relevant to proceedings before the Registrar; and(b) the Registrar has reason to believe that the information is not known to a party to the proceedings; and(c) the Registrar proposes to take the information into account in making a decision in the proceedings;before making the decision the Registrar must: (d) provide the information to the party; and(e) give the party a reasonable opportunity to make representations about the information.(2) For the purposes of paragraph (1)(e), the representations may be made in writing or at a hearing or by such other means as the Registrar reasonably allows The first McIntosh declaration referred to but did not include Exhibits 5 and 6. On 27 May 2015 the removal opponent filed a declaration made by Helen Peachey dated 27 May 2015 which encloses those exhibits and articulates why they were inadvertently omitted from the first McIntosh declaration. Due to an error in the filing process, the removal opponent was under the mistaken impression that Exhibits 5 and 6, which had been prepared on 2 October 2014 had been filed with Objective Connect. Objective Connect issues a standard notification upon the filing of declarations, and in this case the notification was issued to the removal opponent on 30 March 2015. It did not give the removal opponent any indication that Exhibits 5 and 6 were missing. Indeed, I think it is also reasonable to conclude that the removal applicant has been aware of this information and therefore its probative value for a considerable time. I am satisfied the Exhibits contain relevant information[6] and in these circumstances, I am satisfied I should allow the requested information into evidence under regulation 21.19. [6] Exhibit 5 is screenshots of the United States Patent and Trade Mark Office (USPTO) Trade Mark Electronic Search System (TESS) and the details of the removal applicant’s trade mark registrations which are registered in that jurisdiction. Exhibit 6 is printed screenshots of the removal applicant’s website and shows the removal applicant’s Trident Trade Mark and how it is applied to its seafood products. The removal opponent’s trade mark has been filed in Australia see trade mark application no. 1555536. Accordingly, the declaration made by Helen Peachey dated 27 May 2015 and the attached Exhibits 5 and 6 are now included in the evidence and will be considered in this matter The removal applicant has also made a request for the Registrar to take into account material contained in a further declaration made by Albert Terry[7] under regulation 21.19 but I choose not to allow this declaration into these proceedings. This is primarily due to its low probative value and extremely late filing[8]. I also note that Ms. Chrysanthou, on behalf of the removal applicant, objected to this evidence being considered (for the same reasons I have outlined) and that Mr. Fox, on behalf of the removal applicant, did not take issue with her representations during the oral hearing.[7] Declaration made by Albert Terry dated 8 March 2016. [8] Filed 8 March 2016

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established