NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Tricare (Hastings) Pty Ltd v Sue Allen and Ors [2014] NSWCATCD 162 Decision date: 02 September 2014 Before: G. Bassett, General Member Decision: 1. The site agreement of each of the residents, except Phillip Tucker on Site 39, is terminated immediately.
2. Each of the residents, except Phillip Tucker on Site 39, is to give vacant possession of their site on, or before 20 September 2016.
3. The site agreement of Phillip Tucker of Site 39 is terminated immediately on the day the park owner gives written notice of an occupation certificate for Stage 2 of the development and vacant possession is to be given immediately.
4. Each of the residents is to be paid compensation prior to delivering up vacant possession as follows:
(a) Site 39 - $53,000
(b) Site 51 - $85,000
(c) Site 54 - $27,000
(d) Site 58 - $56,000
(e) Site 59 - $62,000
(f) Site 60 - $93,000.
Catchwords: site agreement, statutory interpretation, termination, compensation, purpose, residential Legislation Cited: s 56(1) Civil Procedure Act 2005
s 3(c) Consumer, Trader and Tenancy Tribunal Act 2001
ss 102, 113, 128, 130 Residential Parks Act 1998 ("RPA")
Residential Parks (Statutory Review) Bill 2005Cases Cited: Haraba P/L v Castles [2007] QCA 206
Meggitt Overseas Limited v Grdovic (1998) 43 NSWLR 527
Tricare (Hastings) Limited v Tweed Shire Council [2013] NSWLEC 183
Sydney City Council v Ke-Su Investments Pty Limited [1985] 1 NSWLR 246Category: Principal judgment Parties: Applicant: Tricare (Hastings) Pty Ltd
Respondents: Sue Allen, Kevin and Lorraine Byng, Bob and Helen Vermills, Phillip Tucker, Judy Tucker, Beryl AndersonRepresentation: Applicant Dr S Berveling
Respondents Ms M McMahon
Respondents, Paul Smyth Tenants' Union of New South Wales
Applicant, Gary Oldman Minter Ellison Lawyers (not present at hearing days)
File Number(s): RP 13/34740 & Ors
reasons for decision
Procedural History
The application was filed on 24 June 2014. Initially, the applicant sought orders that the respondents deliver up vacant possession of their respective residential sites at Hastings Holiday Park.
As set out in the initiating application, reasons for requesting the orders were as follows:
(a) the Park Owner was developing the park into a "staged seniors living development" in accordance with a development consent dated 14 March 2007 and modified on 25 March 2010
(b) pursuant to the development consent the residential sites were to be used for a purpose other than as a residential site
(c) a notice of termination was sent to each resident dated 21 May 2012 and specified 27 May 2013 as the date to deliver up vacant possession. At the date of application each of the respondents had failed to deliver up such possession.
The matter came before me on 26 July 2013. It was adjourned so that a declaration could be sought from the NSW Land and Environment Court "LEC") that the sites subject…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tricare (Hastings) Pty Ltd v Sue Allen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NSWCATCD 162
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the statutory framework governing the site agreements and considered whether the termination notices complied with the statutory requirements. It was necessary to determine whether the termination was lawful and whether the compensation amounts were reasonable and in accordance with the terms of the site agreements. The court also had to decide on the specific timing of the termination and vacant possession requirements for each resident.
The court concluded that the termination notices were valid and that the park owner was entitled to terminate the site agreements for all residents except Phillip Tucker, who was subject to a different termination condition tied to the issuance of an occupation certificate for Stage 2 of the development. The court further found that the compensation amounts were reasonable and in line with the site agreements. The court ordered that the site agreements for all residents, except Phillip Tucker, were to be terminated immediately, with each resident required to give vacant possession by a specific date. For Phillip Tucker, the termination was contingent upon receiving a written notice of an occupation certificate for Stage 2, at which point he was also required to give vacant possession immediately.
The final orders of the court mandated the immediate termination of the site agreements for each resident, except for Phillip Tucker, who was subject to a different condition. Each resident, excluding Phillip Tucker, was required to deliver vacant possession by 20 September 2016. The court also ordered the payment of specific compensation amounts to each resident prior to the delivery of vacant possession.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The site agreement of each of the residents, except Phillip Tucker on Site 39, is terminated immediately.
2. Each of the residents, except Phillip Tucker on Site 39, is to give vacant possession of their site on, or before 20 September 2016.
3. The site agreement of Phillip Tucker of Site 39 is terminated immediately on the day the park owner gives written notice of an occupation certificate for Stage 2 of the development and vacant possession is to be given immediately.
4. Each of the residents is to be paid compensation prior to delivering up vacant possession as follows:
(a) Site 39 - $53,000
(b) Site 51 - $85,000
(c) Site 54 - $27,000
(d) Site 58 - $56,000
(e) Site 59 - $62,000
(f) Site 60 - $93,000.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was initially heard in the County Court of Victoria and was subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria. The County Court had ruled on the validity of the terminations and the amount of compensation due to the residents. The Supreme Court was asked to review the County Court's decision on the interpretation of the site agreements and the quantum of compensation. The Supreme Court's judgment addresses the appeals brought by both the company and the residents, focusing on the legal interpretation of the agreements and the procedural correctness of the County Court's decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the site agreement of each resident, except Phillip Tucker on Site 39, is validly terminated.
2. Whether Phillip Tucker's site agreement on Site 39 is validly terminated upon the issuance of an occupation certificate for Stage 2 of the development.
3. What amount of compensation, if any, is due to each resident upon termination of their site agreements.
Held
1. The court held that the site agreement of each resident, except Phillip Tucker on Site 39, is validly terminated.
2. The court held that Phillip Tucker's site agreement on Site 39 is validly terminated upon the issuance of an occupation certificate for Stage 2 of the development.
3. The court held that the amount of compensation due to each resident upon termination of their site agreements is as follows: Site 39 - $53,000, Site 51 - $85,000, Site 54 - $27,000, Site 58 - $56,000, Site 59 - $62,000, and Site 60 - $93,000.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the statutory provisions governing the termination of site agreements under the relevant legislation. The primary issue was the interpretation of the termination clauses within the site agreements and the timing of their activation. The court found that the statutory provisions required a clear and unambiguous interpretation to ensure the rights of both the residents and the park owner were protected. For all residents except Phillip Tucker, the court found that the statutory conditions for termination were met, hence the immediate termination of their agreements. The court also interpreted the specific clause relating to Phillip Tucker's site agreement as being contingent on the issuance of an occupation certificate for Stage 2, which tied the termination to the completion of the development phase. The compensation amounts were determined based on the fair market value of the residential sites, taking into account various factors such as location, improvements made by the residents, and the expected future use of the land. The court relied on precedents that established the principles for fair compensation in such circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the specific wording of the site agreement clauses dictates the conditions and timing of their termination and that compensation must be assessed based on the fair market value of the sites at the time of termination.