Tremlett and Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 1244

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2001/1818

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      BRUCE HENRY TREMLETT      
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS     
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon RNJ Purvis QC, Deputy President     

Date4 December 2002

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed.   

[SGD] The Hon RNJ Purvis QC
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – spouse visa – character test – past and present general conduct – fraudulent protection visa application and associated review – fabricated claims as refugee – overstaying visa by three years – working unlawfully and accessing Medicare entitlements – marriage to Review Applicant whilst unlawfully in Australia - maintaining falsity during interview process for spouse visa – claims that fraudulent protection visa application advocated by migration agent no excuse for conduct – Visa Applicant highly educated and aware of nature of the protection visa application and fabricated claims - high risk of recidivism - hardship to husband – level and duration of fraudulent behaviour not outweighed by hardship to husband - refusal to exercise discretion in favour of Visa Applicant – refusal seen to have general deterrent value to  the community

Migration Act 1958 sections 234(1), 499, 501

Irving v Minister of State for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422
Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 56 ALD 321
Re Lachmaiya and Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 19 AAR 148
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 90 FCR 583

REASONS FOR DECISION

4 December  2002            The Hon RNJ Purvis QC, Deputy President                 

APPLICATION

  1. This is an application made by Bruce Henry Tremlett (the Review Applicant) under date the 23 November 2001 seeking review by the Tribunal of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Respondent) under date the 27 October 2001. By such decision the Respondent refused to grant to Ms Nacita Tremlett (the Visa Applicant) a Combined Class UF Subclass 309 Spouse (Provisional) and Class BC Subclass 100 Spouse (Migrant) Visa, application for the same having been made by her on the 28 March 2001.

  2. In the reasons given by the Respondent for refusing the visa application it was inter alia stated (T5, pp 10, 11 & 14):

    "Assessment – "Past" General Conduct:

    ·     I have taken into account the following matters in assessing the past general conduct of the applicant:

    ·     The applicant applied for a protection visa using fabricated claims, knowing that she was not a "refugee" and for reasons other than a genuine need to seek Australia's protection;

    ·     The applicant applied for review with the Refugee Review Tribunal using fabricated claims, also knowing she was not a "refugee" and for reasons other than a genuine need to seek Australia's protection;

    ·     The applicant overstayed her visa by more than three years and worked unlawfully during the time she was an unlawful non-citizen;

    ·     The applicant did not attempt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tremlett and Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 1244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tremlett and Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs involved a dispute concerning the refusal of a spouse visa application by the Visa Applicant, Nacita Tremlett, who had previously overstayed a protection visa and engaged in fraudulent activities while in Australia. The matter was brought before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for review, where the central legal issues were whether the Visa Applicant's past conduct and character disqualified her from meeting the character requirements under the Migration Act 1958 and whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion in her favour despite the demonstrated misconduct.

The Tribunal found that the Visa Applicant had engaged in a series of fraudulent activities, including the submission of a false protection visa application and associated claims of being a refugee, which she maintained even after being questioned by immigration officers. Despite the involvement of a migration agent in advising her on the fraudulent application, the Tribunal held that the Visa Applicant was equally responsible for her actions, as she was well-educated and aware of the falsity of her claims. The Tribunal further noted that the Visa Applicant had continued to work unlawfully and access Medicare benefits, and married the Review Applicant while still in Australia unlawfully. The Tribunal concluded that the Visa Applicant's extensive history of fraudulent behaviour and her willingness to maintain the deception significantly undermined her credibility and character, rendering her ineligible for a spouse visa under section 501 of the Migration Act.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal highlighted the importance of maintaining public trust in the visa application process and the potential deterrent effect of refusing the visa in this case. The Tribunal acknowledged the hardship to the Review Applicant and his family but determined that the level and duration of the Visa Applicant's fraudulent conduct outweighed the personal circumstances presented. Consequently, the Tribunal upheld the Minister's decision to refuse the spouse visa application. The Tribunal emphasised that the refusal served as a warning to others considering similar fraudulent behaviour and that the Visa Applicant's propensity for wrongdoing, despite knowing the consequences, precluded the exercise of discretion in her favour.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no indication on the part of the relatives of their experiencing any adverse consequence beyond the absence of the Visa Applicant in Australia upon the visa not been granted.DECISION The Tribunal has giving consideration to each of the above factors attributing weight to them according to their significance in the totality of the factual situation. The Respondent and its officers have the responsibility of assessing numerous applications for visas from persons seeking to enter Australia, the applicants seeking to remain for varying periods of time. It is an onerous task and to a measurable extent dependent upon the honesty of an applicant in answering questions and making representations. Not all of these aspects can be exhaustibly investigated and a degree of trust is maintained in the truthfulness of an applicant. If this were not to be so, the resources required to be applied to the migration process would be far beyond those presently available. More so applicants who are honest, trustworthy and forthcoming would be hindered and possibly prejudiced by the then intrusiveness of an investigation. Where it is shown as in this matter that an Applicant perpetrated a litany of untruths upon which she relied for a relatively lengthy period of time only confessing to their inaccuracy at a second interview with an officer of the Respondent in Manila, a situation arises leading inevitably to such a lack of trust or confidence in the Applicant. It can be no defence to say that the advice of an agent or lawyer was only being followed when the Applicant knew of the falsity of the representations, knew that what she was doing was wrong and knew that she was using the untruths to obtain a benefit that would not otherwise be available to her. The conduct of the agent/lawyer may have been reprehensible but without the cooperation and participation of the Visa Applicant as an accessory, he would not be or have been able to prefect the stratagem of enabling persons to remain in Australia without proper cause for lengthy periods of time earning money in the meantime, this in defiance of the provisions of the Act. But the involvement of the Visa Applicant with the agent/lawyer in the nefarious scheme was consequent upon her being introduced to the agent/lawyer by a relative and/or a friend. Whether his modus operandi was known to the relative/friend is not apparent. However, the refusal of a visa in the circumstances of this matter will surely send a warning to those minded to act in a similar fashion. Whilst the Visa Applicant if granted a visa is unlikely to commit acts of a like wrongful nature, she has shown a propensity to use means which she knew were wrong in order to gain her own end. She maintained the subterfuge. She did not tell her husband of her status until he questioned her and even then she referred to a bridging visa which was not current. She did not reveal her untruths or her status to her sister, Ms Manaog who only came to know about the falsities when shown the written material by Mr Lombard. In somewhat of an understatement, Ms Manaog said, "I am disappointed about it. All other members of the family did the right thing."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal having considered the past and present conduct of the Visa Applicant outlined above and as particularised in the reasons for decision of the Respondent is satisfied regardless of the admission made by her representative that the Visa Applicant is within the meaning of section 501 of the Act not of good character.THE MIGRATION AGENT/SOLICITOR The Visa Applicant is a well educated lady and had been a school teacher in the Philippines specialising in English for well neigh 34 years. Her details of tertiary education as they appear on her protection visa application (C36) make mention of her attending the Manila Central University, University of Eastern Philippines and Christ the King College. Even be it the late Mr Gonzales advised her to make and give false representations, she knew that what she was doing was wrong both as to her initial application and her application to the Refugee Review Tribunal. She knew that her ability to initially extend her stay in Australia was only by reason of her applications so based on lies. She met the Review Applicant and was able to marry him as a consequence of her stay in Australia under false pretences. The Visa Applicant can not avoid her primary responsibility for the false representations by reason of the unlawful conduct of Mr Gonzales and activity, not isolated, in respect of which on the basis of evidence before the Tribunal, he was under investigation by the Migration Agents Registration Authority. The Visa Applicant was prepared to use the procedure advocated by Mr Gonzales in order to obtain her own ends.THE REVIEW APPLICANT The Review Applicant is now 65 years of age, having retired from his occupation as a truck driver in 1980. He has been in receipt of a pension since retiring. He is in regular contact with his children and one grand daughter. Dr Stevens, a psychologist, in his report of 5 March 2002 prepared at the request of the representative of the Review Applicant after interviewing the Review Applicant face to face and the Visa Applicant by telephone stated:"Considering the advanced years of Mr and Mrs Tremlett, the unlikelihood of harm to the community and the difficulties and tragic circumstances in both their personal lives, there is a high probability that their marriage represents something of a 'last chance' for happiness within an intimate relationship for both Bruce and Nacita Tremlett. Bruce at this stage of life and health is not likely to adjust well to life in the Philippines. I think there are strong grounds here for compassion. Neither of these people appeared to me to be deceitful or evasive. On the contrary, they were frank and direct in their statements. I am confident their relationship is genuine as is their suffering in being separated. There also appears to be grounds for considering the needs of Nacita Tremlett's family in Australia. I therefore am supportive of Bruce Tremlett's appeal to have Nacita Tremlett's Spouse Visa application approved." Results emanating from formal tests applied by him to the Review Applicant, led Dr Stevens to conclude:"… His stress score was elevated as was the depression subscale measuring 'affective' depression, suggesting higher than normal levels of sadness and loss of normal pleasures. There was also an elevated 'Borderline-Identity' score, which is suggestive of a person struggling with uncertainty in major life issues and a loss of a sense of purpose.These results were consistent with, and supportive of, hypotheses generated by the clinical interview. His Positive Impression score is typical of an Australian male of an older generation playing down his suffering and presenting a brave face. As such, his scores would tend to be an under-estimation of his actual levels of stress, sadness and uncertainty regarding his future" (Exhibit A).