Tregear and Australian National University (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

Tregear and Australian National University (Compensation) [2019] AATA 316 (1 March 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/0951

Re:Peter Tregear

APPLICANT

Australian National UniversityAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:A G Melick AO SC, Deputy President

Date:1 March 2019

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matters to the Respondent for assessment of incapacity payments incurred in relation to the Applicant's mental injury occurring on 16 December 2014 pursuant to s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988, with the direction that as at 30 August 2015 the Applicant remained incapacitated for performing his substantive role as Head of the SoM. .....................................................................
A G Melick AO SC, Deputy President

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – Whether the Applicant was incapacitated for performing his substantive role as Head of the School of Music (SoM) as at 26 June 2015 and to the date of his separation on 30 August 2015 – whether the Applicant remained incapacitated for the role as Head of the SoM beyond his separation from the ANU on 30 August 2015 – Applicant did not make an absolute recovery from his ‘adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features’ – whether it was reasonable within the meaning of s 19(4)(f) of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) for the Applicant not to continue in the role of the Head of the SoM – whether the Applicant was ever offered the position to be created and called the Director of Music and, if so, whether it was reasonable within the meaning of s 19(4)(f) of the Act for the Applicant not to accept that role – Applicant entitled for incapacity payments in accordance with s 19(2) of the Act – reviewable decision set aside and remitted.

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988, ss 4, 16, 19

Cases

Dorothy Norma McHardie and Comcare [1997] AATA 264

Evans and Australian Postal Corporation [1995] AATA 691

HYJZ and Comcare [2015] AATA 766

Lonergan v Comcare [2005] FCA 377

Shanahan and Australian Postal Corporation [1995] AATA 420

Sollazzo and Comcare [2000] AATA 65

Secondary Materials

Peter Sutherland, John Ballard and Allan Anforth, Annotated Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, (The Federation Press, 11th ed, 2018)

REASONS FOR DECISION

A G Melick AO SC, Deputy President

1 March 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Mr Peter Tregear, was employed as a Professor at the School of Music (the SoM) at the Australian National University (ANU). There was much friction and many disputes between the Applicant and the SoM, the details of which are set out in greater detail below. Although he was tenured to 12 February 2017, the Applicant’s employment was terminated on 30 August 2015, pursuant to a deed between the parties on 13 August 2015.

  2. The then Respondent, Comcare, made a decision accepting liability on 1 April 2015 for treatment costs but later determined that the Applicant was no longer incapacitated for work from 26 June 2015. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tregear and Australian National University (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 316
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by Comcare, which had accepted liability for the applicant's psychological injury, 'adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features', but subsequently determined that the applicant was no longer incapacitated for work from 26 June 2015. The applicant had ceased his employment with the Australian National University (ANU) on 30 August 2015, and sought further incapacity payments reflecting the difference between his former salary and that of a lower-paid position he subsequently took in the United Kingdom. Comcare rejected this claim, asserting the applicant was no longer incapacitated and had, by moving overseas, revoked the prospect of a suitable position at the ANU. The applicant sought review of these decisions.

The court was required to determine whether the applicant remained incapacitated for his substantive role as Head of the School of Music (SoM) as at 26 June 2015 and beyond his separation from the ANU on 30 August 2015. Further, the court had to consider whether it was reasonable, within the meaning of s 19(4)(f) of the *Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (the Act), for the applicant not to continue in the role of Head of the SoM. The court also had to ascertain whether the applicant was ever offered a proposed position of Director of Music and, if so, whether it was reasonable for him not to accept that role under s 19(4)(f) of the Act.

The Deputy President found that the applicant had not made an absolute recovery from his condition. The court reasoned that the applicant's role as Head of the SoM involved significant challenges, including chronic understaffing and lack of resourcing, which contributed to his injury. Given these ongoing issues and the applicant's partial recovery, the court concluded that it was reasonable for him not to continue in the demanding role of Head of the SoM. The court also addressed the proposed Director of Music role, finding that the evidence did not establish that such a position was definitively offered to the applicant.

The reviewable decision was set aside, and the matter was remitted for redetermination. The applicant was found to be entitled to incapacity payments in accordance with s 19(2) of the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The then Respondent, Comcare, made a decision accepting liability on 1 April 2015 for treatment costs but later determined that the Applicant was no longer incapacitated for work from 26 June 2015. The Applicant has sought a review of the latter decision.BACKGROUND In 2012, the Applicant was appointed as Head of the SoM at the ANU with an initial employment period of 18 months. That contract was later extended for a further fixed term period of three years. The Applicant submitted a claim for compensation for anxiety and depression on 15 December 2014 (T8) citing the following factors as being causative of his condition:(a)managing an academic department, and undertaking requisite research, teaching and public outreach obligations;(b)long-term chronic understaffing of the school and lack of resourcing either to provide additional resourcing or provide a strategic framework to lower academic and administrative responsibilities in response; and(c)managing the impact of three (and at one point five) academic staff out of approx. 10 FTE on ongoing stress related leave, and lack of adequate and stable (i.e. not on short-term contract) professional support staff cohort. The Respondent accepted liability for ‘adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features’ on 1 April 2015 (T19). The Applicant ceased his employment with the ANU on 30 August 2015. Shortly thereafter, the Applicant sought payment of further incapacity payments to reflect the difference between his previous salary and his lower paid position at the Royal Holloway University in the United Kingdom. That claim was rejected upon the basis that the Applicant was no longer incapacitated for work as a result of the earlier accepted condition (T41). Upon a reconsideration decision, it was rejected for the same reasons together with an assertion that in moving to the United Kingdom the Applicant had revoked the prospect of a position with suitable duties at the ANU (T47, p. 205).EVIDENCE There were voluminous materials set out in the parties’ statements of facts, issues and contentions, as well as in their closing submissions. Set out below at paragraphs 10-176 are detailed facts that were either agreed by the parties or not in dispute prior to the hearing. There was no evidence led in relation to some but I was not persuaded by the Respondent to make no finding in relation to such facts as no point was taken until after all the evidence had been led, written submissions not being filed until two months after the evidence had concluded. I have inserted relevant comments or additional facts where there were some additional facts or differences as a result of the evidence and, unless otherwise stated, the above mentioned paragraphs reflect my factual findings in relation to the matters referred to therein. When initially hired on a fixed term contract, the Applicant's role as outlined in the position description was:… Lead and manage the school through the change management process, including:1Manage and deliver the implementation of the curriculum model is outlined in the School of music implementation document to ensure delivery for 2013.2Manage and deliver the staffing structure to support the new curriculum delivery.3 Manage and deliver staffing structure to support the new curriculum delivery.4Manage the schools budget to limit expenditure yet provide stability through the change process.5Ensure that resources are managed in accordance with legislation and University policy.6Foster and maintain effective relationships with key internal and external stakeholders.7Ensure that the University's commitments to current students are fulfilled.8Foster effective and professional working relationships with the College General Manager and staff and students of the School.9Conduct other duties is consistent with the classification of the position.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

That claim was rejected upon the basis that the Applicant was no longer incapacitated for work as a result of the earlier accepted condition (T41). Upon a reconsideration decision, it was rejected for the same reasons together with an assertion that in moving to the United Kingdom the Applicant had revoked the prospect of a position with suitable duties at the ANU (T47, p. 205).EVIDENCE There were voluminous materials set out in the parties’ statements of facts, issues and contentions, as well as in their closing submissions. Set out below at paragraphs 10-176 are detailed facts that were either agreed by the parties or not in dispute prior to the hearing. There was no evidence led in relation to some but I was not persuaded by the Respondent to make no finding in relation to such facts as no point was taken until after all the evidence had been led, written submissions not being filed until two months after the evidence had concluded. I have inserted relevant comments or additional facts where there were some additional facts or differences as a result of the evidence and, unless otherwise stated, the above mentioned paragraphs reflect my factual findings in relation to the matters referred to therein. When initially hired on a fixed term contract, the Applicant's role as outlined in the position description was:… Lead and manage the school through the change management process, including:1Manage and deliver the implementation of the curriculum model is outlined in the School of music implementation document to ensure delivery for 2013.2Manage and deliver the staffing structure to support the new curriculum delivery.3 Manage and deliver staffing structure to support the new curriculum delivery.4Manage the schools budget to limit expenditure yet provide stability through the change process.5Ensure that resources are managed in accordance with legislation and University policy.6Foster and maintain effective relationships with key internal and external stakeholders.7Ensure that the University's commitments to current students are fulfilled.8Foster effective and professional working relationships with the College General Manager and staff and students of the School.9Conduct other duties is consistent with the classification of the position. The Applicant was given the task of fixing pre-existing problems in the SoM. The Applicant suffered a compensable psychological injury. The Applicant was examined by his general practitioner, Dr Ann Cockburn, on 16 December 2014 who certified that he was suffering from anxiety and depression. Dr Cockburn further certified him unfit for work between 16 December 2014 and 16 January 2015. On 18 December 2014 an ‘Extraordinary SoM Staff Meeting’ was chaired by Professor Paul Pickering. In the meeting, a statement written by Dr David Irving was read in which he indicated that the SoM did not have the full support of the ANU and that the SoM was chronically understaffed (Exhibit 6, Attachment A). Included was the following:I have no confidence in the university that demonstrates insufficient support of my own head of School, and which keeps our staffing at such a critically low level… It is an economic and educational fallacy to imagine that overworked staff can engage in “unlimited growth” of student members without serious cost to the personal welfare of staff and students, and the reputation of the ANU. We need our head to be on a continuum contract and we need more academic and professional staff. Or, simply put, it is time the ANU finally honoured both the spirit and the letter of the agreement it made with its employees and the wider community in 2012.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established