Transport of NSW v El-Harris

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL PANEL
CITATION: Transport of NSW v El-Harris [2024] NSWPICMP 203
APPELLANT: Transport of NSW
RESPONDENT: Mustapha El-Harris
APPEAL PANEL
MEMBER: Jane Peacock
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Raj Thandavan
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Robert Payten
DATE OF DECISION: 9 April 2024
CATCHWORDS: 

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Hearing loss due to occupational noise exposure; employer appealed on the basis of a failure to take account of hearing loss in employment outside of New South Wales by making a deduction or apportionment; Appeal Panel found no error; 46-year employment history of noisy employment since 1971; if noise induced hearing loss is considered to have occurred over the whole of this period, the contribution of any pre-existing injury in the period between 1972 and 1974 to the level of permanent impairment assessed as a result of injury deemed to have occurred in 2017 after 40 years of exposure to noise in the employ of the appellant, is negligible and should not be appropriately the subject of a deduction or apportionment in the circumstances of this case; Held – Medical Assessment Certificate confirmed.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO APPEAL

  1. On 28 December 2023 Transport of NSW (the appellant) lodged an Application to Appeal Against the Decision of a Medical Assessor. The medical dispute was assessed by
    Dr Henley C Harrison, a Medical Assessor, who issued a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) on 5 December 2023.

  2. The appellant relies on the following grounds of appeal under s 327(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (1998 Act):

    ·        availability of additional relevant information (being additional information that was not available to, and that could not reasonably have been obtained by, the appellant before the medical assessment appealed against);

    ·        the assessment was made on the basis of incorrect criteria, and

    ·        the MAC contains a demonstrable error.

  3. The delegate is satisfied that, on the face of the application, at least one ground of appeal has been made out. The Appeal Panel has conducted a review of the original medical assessment but limited to the ground(s) of appeal on which the appeal is made.

  4. Rule 128 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (PIC Rules) and Procedural Direction PIC7 – Appeals, reviews, reconsiderations and correction of obvious errors in medical disputes set out the practice and procedure in relation to the medical appeal process under s 328 of the 1998 Act. An Appeal Panel determines its own procedures in accordance with r 128(1) of the PIC Rules.

  5. The assessment of permanent impairment is conducted in accordance with the SIRA NSW Workers Compensation Guidelines for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 4th ed
    1 March 2021 (the Guidelines) and the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 5th ed (AMA 5).

PRELIMINARY REVIEW

  1. The Appeal Panel conducted a preliminary review of the original medical assessment in the absence of the parties and in accordance with the Procedural Direction PIC7.

  2. The appellant did not seek that the worker be re-examined by a Medical Assessor who…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Transport of NSW v El-Harris and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 203
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Transport of NSW appealed against a decision that it was liable to pay workers compensation to El-Harris for his hearing loss. El-Harris had worked for Transport for 40 years, during which time he was exposed to significant occupational noise. The dispute was between the employer and the employee over whether the employer should be liable for the full extent of the employee's hearing loss, or whether a deduction should be made for hearing loss that predated the employment with Transport. The appeal was heard by an Appeal Panel of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The central legal issue was whether the employer could be held liable for the full extent of the employee's hearing loss, or whether a deduction could be made for hearing loss that occurred prior to the employee's employment with Transport. The appeal panel had to decide if there was any error in the finding that no deduction should be made for the pre-existing hearing loss, and if not, whether it was appropriate to make a deduction for hearing loss that occurred outside of NSW.

The Appeal Panel found no error in the original decision. The Panel held that given the significant occupational noise exposure during the 40 years of employment with Transport, the contribution of any pre-existing injury to the level of permanent impairment was negligible and should not be the subject of a deduction or apportionment. The Panel noted that the Medical Assessment Certificate confirmed the assessment of the impairment and the reasons for not making a deduction for the pre-existing hearing loss. The Panel found that the employer's liability for the employee's hearing loss should not be reduced on the basis of hearing loss that occurred outside of NSW.

No further orders were made by the Appeal Panel.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Medical Assessor explained his impairment assessment as follows:“1. THE FACTS ON WHICH THE ASSESSMENT IS BASEDThe facts on which I have based my assessment of whole person impairment are:The date of injury is after 1 January 2002 so the 1988 NAL Tables and the WorkCover Guides Fourth Edition – reissued 1 March 2021 have been used to calculate percentages of hearing loss and binaural hearing impairment (BHI) and to derive Whole Person Impairment (WPI).The worker’s employment with the Respondent has been determined to have the tendencies, incidents and characteristics such as to pose a real risk of damaging hearing. I am in agreement with this.The history is of significant occupational noise exposure.Please also see below.1. REASONS FOR ASSESSMENTa. My opinion and assessment of whole person impairmentPlease see 9, above.There isIn making that assessment I have taken account of the following matters:-As stated above the history and examination are consistent with a diagnosis of occupational noise exposure but the audiogram is not consistent with this being the sole diagnosis. This is because in noise induced occupational hearing loss the lower frequencies are usually preserved and the hearing loss in the effected frequencies increases in severity with increase in frequency until at least 3000 cps. In this case the hearing loss at 1000 cps is much the same as at 1500 cps so the profile of the audiogram below 1500 cps is not consistent with that diagnosis. I have therefore apportioned the occupational hearing loss to the frequencies 1500 cps and above in which the profile of the audiogram is consistent with being due to occupational noise exposure. This apportionment gives 21.5% BHI before mandatory deduction for presbycusis and 19.6% after such mandatory deduction. The worker's tinnitus is severe and I have made an allowance of 2.0% that. The foregoing give a resultant total BHI of 21.6% which equals 11% WPI.b. An explanation of my calculations (if applicable)Calculations involved are included in the accompanying sheet.Mandatory presbyacusis has been deducted as prescribed in the 1988 NAL Tables.Worksheet /actual calculations attached? Yes.” The Medical Assessor made brief comment on the other medical opinions before him as follows:“My brief comments regarding the other medical opinions and findings submitted by the parties and, where applicable, the reasons why my opinion differs.As indicated in the referral, the report by Professor Fagan has errors with regard to the work history in it; obviously my history differs from his and accordance with the statement. He has accepted all frequencies as being due to occupational noise exposure; I have given my reasons for my differing opinion in this respect.I have no significant difference of opinion with the report of Dr Howison.” The Medical Assessor made a deduction for hearing loss which he considered to be unrelated to noise induced hearing loss and he did not make a deduction relevant to exposure to noise in employment outside of NSW as follows:“DEDUCTION (IF ANY) FOR THE PROPORTION OF THE IMPAIRMENT THAT IS DUE TO PREVIOUS INJURY OR PRE-EXISTING CONDITION OR ABNORMALITY a. In my opinion the worker suffers from the following relevant previous injuries, pre-existing conditions or abnormalities:Non-related hearing lossb. The previous injury, pre-existing condition or abnormality directly contributes to the following matters that were taken into account when assessing the whole person impairment that results from the injury, being the matters taken into account in 10a, and in the following ways:9.1% BHI of non-related hearingc. In my opinion the deductible proportion is 9.1% BHI for the following reasons:Because that is the extent of the non-related loss.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established