Transpac Capital Pty Ltd v Central Highlands Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Transpac Capital Pty Ltd v Central Highlands Regional Council & Anor [2014] QPEC 12

PARTIES:

TRANSPAC CAPITAL PTY LTD
(ACN 135 577 598)

(Appellant)

v

CENTRAL HIGHLANDS REGIONAL COUNCIL

(Respondent)

and

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT AND MAIN ROADS ACT

(Co-respondent by election)

FILE NO/S:

902/2012

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

3 April 2014

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

30 September 2013 to 4 October 2013 and 18 February 2014 to 19 February 2014

JUDGE:

Searles DCJ

ORDER:

The appeal is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT – PLANNING -  Appeal against the decision of the Council of 6 February 2012  refusing a development application seeking development approval for the construction and operation of a workers accommodation village on land situated at 147 Yackam Road, Blackwater.

COUNSEL:

Appellant: A Skoien

Respondent: S Ure

SOLICITORS:

Appellant: Cooper Grace Ward

Respondent: King & Co

Table of Contents

Appeal
Council decision
The Proposal

Submitters
Planning Scheme
Legislative context
Issues in dispute

Consideration of issues

A(1) Increase in residential density
Impacts on character and amenity
Mr Powell’s opinion
Ms Elliot’s Opinion
Discussion re social consequences of increase in Residential Density
Conclusion re social consequences of increase in Residential Density

A(2) Increase in Traffic
Discussion re Increase in Traffic
Conclusion re Increase in Traffic

A(3) Noise
Joint Acoustic Reports
Points of disagreement – second joint acoustic report
Source of Noise Emissions
Road traffic noise criteria
Temperature inversion frequency
Acoustic amenity as a Reason for Council’s refusal
Ms Adams’ conclusion in individual report
Mr Savery’s individual report 19 September 2013
Temperature inversions
Outdoor recreation voice noise
Ms Adams’ supplementary acoustic report of 26 September 2013
Consideration of noise
Conclusion re noise

A(4) Light
Discussion re lighting
Conclusion re lighting

A(5) Interference with the Kelehers’ domestic water supply
Dr Johnson’s opinion
Cardno report
Conclusion re interfereance with the Kelehers’ domestic water supply
Visual Amenity
Conclusion re Visual Amenity

B – Conflict with Planning Scheme
Town Planning Evidence
Mr Schomburgk’s opinion
Mr Perkins’ opinion
Discussion re alleged conflict with Planning Scheme
Conclusion re conflicts with Planning Scheme

C – Need
Mr Brown’s opinion
Mr Coghlin’s opinion
Discussion re need
Conclusion re need

Are there sufficient grounds to justify approval?
Grounds relied upon by Transpac
Discussion and Conclusion re Sufficient Grounds

Order

Appeal

  1. This appeal is against the decision of the Central Highlands Regional Council (Council) of 6 February 2012[1] refusing a development application (Application)[2] seeking development approval for the construction and operation of a workers accommodation village (WAV) on land described as lot 6 on RP614154 situated at 147 Yackam Road, Blackwater (Site).

    [1]Exhibit 1B, pp 629-639.

    [2]Exhibit 1A, pp 25-313.

  1. The Site is presently occupied by a single dwelling and cattle yards with vegetation having been selectively cleared for grazing operations leaving scattered mature trees remaining throughout the Site.  It has the usual dams, fences, cattle yards and sheds associated with such an operation.  It is some…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Transpac Capital Pty Ltd v Central Highlands Regional Counci... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QPEC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Transpac Capital Pty Ltd appealed against the Central Highlands Regional Council's refusal to grant development approval for the construction and operation of a workers' accommodation village on land at 147 Yackam Road, Blackwater. The refusal was based on concerns raised by local residents, particularly those along Yackam Road, regarding the potential impacts of the development. The development proposal involved the construction of single-person quarters to accommodate temporary mining workers, a significant and growing demographic in the region.

The legal issues before the court included whether the proposal would negatively impact the character of the area, contribute to anti-social behaviour, and affect local housing availability and prices. Additionally, the court considered the extent of road upgrades required if the proposal were to proceed. The proponents argued that the proposal would positively impact the community by providing necessary accommodation for mining workers, thereby reducing housing pressure and benefiting the local economy.

The court examined the proposal's consistency with the broader lifestyle in the mining community and noted that the temporary nature of the workers' employment would likely limit their integration into the local community. The court also considered evidence from social planning experts who provided differing views on the proposal's social impacts. Ultimately, the court found that the proposal was not aligned with the character of the area and upheld the Council's decision to refuse the development application.

ORDERS:
The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Council to refuse the development application was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeal is dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By a Decision Notice dated 6 February 2012[6] the Council conveyed to Transpac its decision of refusal (Decision Notice). It identified the following reasons for refusal:-[6]Ibid, pp 629-638. Transpac tendered[7] a statement summarising the Proposal. Without setting it out in full the following are its salient features:-[7]Exhibit 3, p 1. Nine submissions were received, seven of which came from owners of properties along Yackam Road. All opposed the Proposal identifying the following concerns[8]:-[8]Exhibit 1B, p 407. See also joint social planning report 2(2), p 10. The relevant Planning Scheme is the Duaringa Shire Planning Scheme (Scheme). The Site and its locality are located in the Rural Zone one of the three zones in the Scheme, the others being the Town Zone and Village Zone.[9][9]Exhibit 5 Scheme Zoning Map 1. The application, having been made on 26 July 2011, its assessment was and this appeal is governed by the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (SPA). Under s 493(1) Transpac bears the onus of establishing that the appeal should be upheld. The Proposal is impact assessable given that it is a Residential Use Class not specifically referred to in Table 4.1.1(1) “Assessable Categories and Relevant Assessment Criteria for the Rural Zone – Making a material change of use”.[10] As such it is to be assessed under s 314 of SPA and decided in accordance with s 326.[10]Ibid, p 35. Section 326 relevantly provides:- The disputed issues are:- Apart from the above issues, Transpac raises the issue of appropriate extent of upgrade works which would be required for Yackam Road from the land to the intersection of the Capricorn Highway in the event the appeal is allowed. Evidence was given by social planning experts Mr Powell (Transpac) and Ms Elliott (Council). They provided a Joint Report and individual reports.[11] Mr Powell, as does Ms Eliot, bases his opinion on what they both see as an accepted way of life in mining communities for temporary workers whose main residences are elsewhere and who require accommodation during their work shifts. This phenomena is, in Mr Powell’s view, a recent response to the changes in the mining sector labour market. The potential impacts from fly in/fly out/drive in/drive out (FIFO/DIDO) workers will be present regardless of the locality or type of accommodation. If single persons quarters (SPQs) were not available to accommodate these workers who, generally speaking, are on substantially higher salaries, they would crowd out the lower income groups in the community in competing for existing accommodation. Mr Powell says of the Proposal that it is fundamentally consistent with the broad patterns of the way of life in Blackwater which is inextricably linked with the mining industry. For at least 10 years it has had a culture of temporary mining personnel. He thinks that on balance, the Proposal will deliver a positive outcome to the community by way of direct and indirect employment, increased spending patterns, and reduction of housing price pressures. As to social cohesion, he accepts the reality that temporary workers can not integrate too strongly with the community regardless of where they live. That is a function of their working conditions, long shifts and limited duration of employment in the locality. But, he says, evidence from other mining communities suggests that any impact from the mining sector employees and their accommodation on the town’s stability has not been disproportionate. Anti-social or illegal activity has not risen above what would be expected from general population growth. Further, stringent alcohol and drug testing regimes imposed by mining companies strongly mitigates against these workers being involved in crime against the person including sexual assault. In short, this Proposal will not adversely affect the character of Blackwater.