Transit Pty Ltd v Arch Underwriting at Lloyd's (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL COURT

INSURANCE LIST

S ECI 2021 01559

TRANSIT PTY LTD (ACN 086 515 077)
& ANOR (according to the Schedule of Parties)
Plaintiffs
v
ARCH UNDERWRITING AT LLOYD’S (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 139 250 605) & ORS (according to the Schedule of Parties) Defendants

S ECI 2021 01815

AMFR HOLDINGS PTY LTD T/AS THE DECK BRIGHTON (ACN 151 810 435) & ORS (according to the Schedule of Parties) Plaintiffs
v
ARCH UNDERWRITING AT LLOYD’S (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 139 250 605) & ORS (according to the Schedule of Parties) Defendants

---

JUDGE:

Delany J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

On the papers

DATE OF RULING:

15 October 2024

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Transit Pty Ltd & Anor v Arch Underwriting at Lloyd’s (Australia) Pty Ltd & Ors (No 2)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2024] VSC 632

---

COSTS – Discontinuing party to pay costs of discontinuance and withdrawal – Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2015 r 63.15.

COSTS – Four defendants separately represented – Whether reasonable for unsuccessful plaintiff to bear four sets of costs – Whether potential for conflict sufficient to warrant separate representation – Unsuccessful plaintiffs to pay half of each defendants’ reasonable and proportionate costs in order to achieve substantial justice between parties – Statham v Shephard (No 2) (1974) 23 FLR 244; HP Mercantile Pty Ltd v Harnett [2017] NSWCA 79, applied.

COSTS – Calderbank offers made – ‘Walk away’ offer – Whether rejection of offer unreasonable – Whether offer an invitation to capitulate – Rejection of offer not unreasonable – Unsuccessful plaintiffs’ case arguable at time of offer – Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm v Victorian Workcover Authority (No 2) [2005] VSCA 298; (2005) 13 VR 435, applied.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiffs Hamish Austin KC with Andrew Cameron and Jessica Apel Gadens Solicitors
For the First Defendant (Arch Underwriting at Lloyd’s (Australia) Pty Ltd) Peter Murdoch KC with Nicholas Wood SC Colin Biggers & Paisley Lawyers
For the Second Defendant (Chubb Insurance Australia Limited) Todd Marskell Wotton Kearney
For the Third Defendant (The Underwriting Member of Syndicate 2003 at Lloyd’s of London) David Collins KC with Hamish Redd SC Clyde & Co
For the Fourth Defendant (Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Company) Dean Luxton Kennedys Law

TABLE OF CONTENTS

The principles..................................................................................................................................... 3

Berkshire’s discontinuance and withdrawal................................................................................ 6

Plaintiffs’ submissions.................................................................................................................. 7

Berkshire’s submissions............................................................................................................... 7

Consideration................................................................................................................................ 8

Four defendants seeking four separate sets of costs................................................................... 8

Plaintiffs’ submissions.................................................................................................................. 8

Defendants’ submissions........................................................................................................... 10

Consideration.............................................................................................................................. 13

Calderbank offers............................................................................................................................ 15

Defendants’ submissions........................................................................................................... 15

Plaintiffs’ submissions................................................................................................................ 17

Consideration.............................................................................................................................. 18

Disposition........................................................................................................................................ 19

HIS HONOUR:

  1. These reasons relate to costs in proceedings S ECI 2021 01559 (‘Transit proceeding’) and S ECI 2021 01815 (‘AMFR proceeding’), the trial of which was heard by me between 20 March 2024 and 5 April 2024.

  1. The proceedings concerned the entitlement of the plaintiffs to business interruption insurance for periods of lockdown in Melbourne in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Transit Pty Ltd v Arch Underwriting at Lloyd's (Australia) P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] VSC 632
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Transit Pty Ltd was the plaintiff in an action against Arch Underwriting at Lloyd's (Australia) Pty Ltd, along with three other defendants, each separately represented. The dispute centred on the allocation of costs under the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2015, specifically rule 63.15, which mandates that a discontinuing party pay the costs of discontinuance and withdrawal. The plaintiff sought to discontinue the proceedings without paying the defendants' costs, arguing that it was unreasonable to require them to bear the costs of four separate sets of legal representation.

The court had to determine whether it was reasonable for the plaintiff to bear four sets of costs given that the defendants were separately represented and whether the potential for conflict warranted separate representation. The court also examined whether the rejection of Calderbank offers by the plaintiff was unreasonable and if such offers constituted an invitation to capitulate. The court found that the potential for conflict did warrant separate representation and that the plaintiff's rejection of the Calderbank offers was not unreasonable, as the plaintiff's case was arguable at the time of the offers.

In accordance with the precedent set by Statham v Shephard (No 2) and HP Mercantile Pty Ltd v Harnett, the court held that the plaintiff should pay half of each defendant’s reasonable and proportionate costs to achieve substantial justice between the parties. The court further noted that the rejection of the Calderbank offers was not unreasonable, as the plaintiff’s case was arguable at the time, in line with Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm v Victorian Workcover Authority (No 2). The court ordered the plaintiff to pay half of each defendant's reasonable and proportionate costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established