Beaumont Gregory Lyons v Jonathon Charles Albert Noble
[2006] APO 40
Citation 1
(Para 14)
…In Transgene SA v Virax Holdings Ltd [2002] APO 14 (17 April 2002), the delegate considered that the relevance of evidence was a key factor that Sackville J in Goninan (supra) considered relevant in deciding whether evidence should be allowed: “In order for the Commissioner or his delegate to give proper, genuin…
Syngenta Participations AG v Monsanto Corporation
[2006] APO 16
Citation 2
(Para 33)
…In Transgene SA v Virax Holdings Ltd [2002] APO 14 (17 April 2002), the delegate considered that the relevance of evidence was a key factor that Sackville J in Goninan (supra) considered relevant in deciding whether evidence should be allowed: “In order for the Commissioner or his delegate to give proper, genuin…
Bundaberg Foundry Engineers Limited v the Track Shop Pty Ltd
[2005] APO 54
Citation 3
…onfers a broad discretion, which cannot be reduced to an imperative compliance with particular requirements. In Transgene S.A. v Virax Holdings Ltd , [2002] APO 14, the delegate of the Commissioner took the approach that Goninan is not only relevant to the issue of whether further evidence is allowed but it supe…
Boral Resources (NSW) Pty Limited v BST Holdings Pty Limited
[2005] APO 48
Citation 4
(Para 20)
…In Transgene SA v Virax Holdings Ltd [2002] APO 14 (17 April 2002), the delegate considered that the relevance of evidence was a key factor that Sackville J in Goninan (supra) considered relevant in deciding whether evidence should be allowed: “In order for the Commissioner or his delegate to give proper, genuin…
Midrex International B.V. Rotterdam, Zurich Branch v Iron Carbide Holdings Limited
[2002] APO 16
Citation 5
(Para 16)
…t the same/similar criteria have been found applicable in this matter. In a recently issued Office Decision ( Transgene S.A. v Virax Holdings Limited [2002] APO 14 (17 April 2002)), the principles outlined in the Federal Court decision in Goninan (supra) were found to be relevant to a determination of whether fu…