Tranchita v Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

TRANCHITA -v- DANEHILL NOMINEES PTY LTD [No 2] [2007] WASC 248



SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIACitation No:[2007] WASC 248
25/10/2007
Case No:CIV:1124/20043 SEPTEMBER 2007
Coram:MARTIN CJ3/09/07
10Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Plaintiff in the original action to pay seventh defendant's costs of the action
including all costs declared to be in the cause
B
PDF Version
Parties:VINCENZO TRANCHITA
DANEHILL NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 008 867 623)
VINCENZO FAZIO
GIUSEPPINA FAZIO
VINCENT CALALESINA
MARIA CALALESINA
SEBASTIANO FAZIO
MARIA FAZIO
BIANCA ROSIE NASO
GIUSEPPE MONASTRA
NUNZIATA MONASTRA
ERIGO FAZIO
REGISTRAR OF TITLES
SEBASTIANO GIUSEPPE FAZIO
MARIA PALMA FAZIO
BASILIO TRANCHITA
LAURINA TRANCHITA
CALOGERO TRANCHITA
CONCETTA SILVANA TRANCHITA
GIACOMINA SEBASTIANA TRANCHITA
ROSARIO TRANCHITA
MELINA TRANCHITA
MARIA PALMA CALALESINA
ZELJKO GREGO
TONY GREGO
SEBASTIANO CATALANO
ROSARIA CATALANO

Catchwords:

Costs
Where action discontinued
Indemnity costs

Legislation:

Nil

Case References:

Edwards Madigan Torzillo Briggs Pty Ltd v Stack [2003] NSWCA 302
Fountain Selected Meats (Sales) Pty Ltd v International Produce Merchants Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 397
Gribbles Pathology Pty Ltd v Health Insurance Commission (1997) 80 FCR 283
Re The Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs of the Commonwealth of Australia; Ex parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622
Tranchita v Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd [2004] WASC 154


JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
    IN CHAMBERS
CITATION : TRANCHITA -v- DANEHILL NOMINEES PTY LTD [No 2] [2007] WASC 248 CORAM : MARTIN CJ HEARD : 3 SEPTEMBER 2007 DELIVERED : 3 SEPTEMBER 2007 PUBLISHED : 25 OCTOBER 2007 FILE NO/S : CIV 1124 of 2004 BETWEEN : VINCENZO TRANCHITA
    Plaintiff

    AND

    DANEHILL NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 008 867 623)
    First Defendant

    VINCENZO FAZIO
    GIUSEPPINA FAZIO
    Second Defendants

    VINCENT CALALESINA
    MARIA CALALESINA
    Third Defendants

    SEBASTIANO FAZIO
    MARIA FAZIO
    Fourth Defendants

    BIANCA ROSIE NASO
    Fifth Defendant

(Page 2)
    GIUSEPPE MONASTRA
    NUNZIATA MONASTRA
    Sixth Defendants

    ERIGO FAZIO
    Seventh Defendant

    REGISTRAR OF TITLES
    Eighth Defendant

    SEBASTIANO CATALANO
    First Third Party

    ROSARIA CATALANO
    Second Third Party

    (BY ORIGINAL ACTION)

    SEBASTIANO GIUSEPPE FAZIO
    MARIA PALMA FAZIO
    First Plaintiffs

    GIUSEPPE MONASTRA
    First-named Second Plaintiff

    NUNZIATA MONASTRA
    Second-named Second Plaintiff

    AND

    DANEHILL NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 008 867 623)
    First Defendant

    BASILIO TRANCHITA
    LAURINA TRANCHITA
    Second Defendants

    CALOGERO TRANCHITA
    CONCETTA SILVANA TRANCHITA
    Third Defendants

(Page 3)
    GIACOMINA SEBASTIANA TRANCHITA
    Fourth Defendant

    ROSARIO TRANCHITA
    Fifth Defendant

    VINCENZO TRANCHITA
    Sixth Defendant

    MELINA TRANCHITA
    Seventh Defendant

    BIANCA ROSIE NASO
    Eighth Defendant

    VINCENT CALALESINA
    MARIA PALMA CALALESINA
    Ninth Defendants

    ERIGO FAZIO
    Tenth Defendant

    ZELJKO GREGO
    Eleventh Defendant

    TONY GREGO
    Twelfth Defendant

    VINCENZO FAZIO
    GIUSEPPINA FAZIO
    Thirteenth Defendants

    (BY COUNTERCLAIM)

Catchwords:

Costs - Where action discontinued - Indemnity costs


(Page 4)



Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Plaintiff in the original action to pay seventh defendant's costs of the action including all costs declared to be in the cause

Category: B


Representation:

Original Action


Counsel:


    Plaintiff : Mr C V Eastwood
    First Defendant : No appearance
    Second Defendants : No appearance
    Third Defendants : No appearance
    Fourth Defendants : No appearance
    Fifth Defendant…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tranchita v Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASC 248
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tranchita v Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd [No 2] involved a dispute concerning indemnity costs following the discontinuation of an action. The original action, which was not detailed in the text, was discontinued, leading to a subsequent claim for costs by one of the defendants. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff in the original action should bear the costs of the seventh defendant's action, including all costs that were declared to be in the cause.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff should be liable for the costs incurred by the seventh defendant in the discontinued action. This involved interpreting the rules regarding indemnity costs and the circumstances under which a plaintiff might be ordered to pay the defendant's costs. The court had to consider the principles of indemnity costs, the nature of the discontinued action, and whether there were any exceptional circumstances that might warrant such an order.

In reaching its decision, the court examined the relevant legal principles and the specific circumstances of the discontinued action. It concluded that the plaintiff should bear the costs of the seventh defendant's action. The court found that the plaintiff was responsible for the costs as they were a result of the discontinued action, and there were no exceptional circumstances that would excuse the plaintiff from this liability. The court's reasoning was based on the standard rules of indemnity costs and the need to ensure that parties do not unnecessarily incur costs when actions are discontinued without just cause.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff in the original action was to pay the seventh defendant's costs of the action, including all costs that had been declared to be in the cause. This decision underscored the importance of the rules governing indemnity costs and the consequences of discontinuing legal actions without proper justification.

Orders

Orders of the court

Plaintiff in the original action to pay seventh defendant's costs of the action including all costs declared to be in the cause

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a legal dispute arising from the construction of a building in Sydney. Tranchita was the owner of the property on which the building was constructed. Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd, among other defendants, was involved in the construction of the building. The construction works were carried out by Tranchita Constructions Pty Ltd. The building suffered from significant structural defects, leading to a claim by Tranchita against the defendants. The defects caused Tranchita to incur substantial costs to repair and rectify the issues. Tranchita initially filed a claim against several defendants, including Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd, seeking damages for the defects. The matter was subsequently narrowed down, and Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd was the sole defendant in the proceeding before the court. Tranchita discontinued the action against Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd. Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd applied for costs on an indemnity basis.

The case came before the court as an application for costs following the discontinuation of an action. The plaintiff, Tranchita, had initially brought the action against multiple defendants for damages related to construction defects. The action proceeded through various stages, including pleadings and discovery. Ultimately, Tranchita discontinued the action against Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd. Danehill Nominees Pty Ltd then filed an application for costs, seeking an order that Tranchita pay the costs of the action on an indemnity basis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff in the original action is liable to pay the defendant's costs of the action including all costs declared to be in the cause.
2. Whether the plaintiff's discontinuation of the action entitles the defendant to costs on an indemnity basis.

Held
1. The plaintiff in the original action is liable to pay the defendant's costs of the action including all costs declared to be in the cause.
2. The plaintiff's discontinuation of the action does not entitle the defendant to costs on an indemnity basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the circumstances under which the plaintiff discontinued the action and the applicable legal principles governing costs. It held that the plaintiff's voluntary discontinuation of the action, without any substantial merit in their claim, warranted an order for the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs of the action. The court emphasised that the principle of indemnity costs is typically reserved for cases where the defendant has successfully defended a claim that was without merit or was vexatious. In this case, the plaintiff's decision to discontinue the action did not meet the threshold for indemnity costs as it did not involve a claim that was without any merit or was vexatious. The court relied on established case law to support its decision, confirming that the plaintiff's discontinuation of the action did not justify awarding costs on an indemnity basis. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a plaintiff's voluntary discontinuation of an action does not automatically entitle the defendant to indemnity costs, but may still result in the plaintiff being liable for the defendant's costs of the action.