Tran and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 461

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No Q01/280

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )       
           Re      THANH NHA TRAN          
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS         
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Honourable RNJ Purvis, QC, Deputy President   

Date14 June 2002

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decision under review

[sgd]    The Hon. RNJ Purvis, QC
  DEPUTY PRESIDENT
CATCHWORDS – IMMIGRATION – Deportation – After Criminal Conviction – Possible Hardship Suffered by Applicant – Whether International Obligations Applicable - Prospect of Indeterminate Detention – Whether Affects Validity of Order

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Perez v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 94 FCR 287
Vo v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 803

REASONS FOR DECISION

14 June 2002           The Hon. RNJ Purvis, QC, Deputy President    

  1. This is a review of a decision made on 7 July 2000 by the respondent Minister to deport the applicant, Thanh Nha Tran, under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958.

  2. An application for extension of time was sought by the applicant and with the consent of the respondent a Direction was issued by the Tribunal on 18 April 2001 extending the time for lodging the application for review.

  3. This matter was heard on 30 and 31 August 2001 in Brisbane.  The applicant was represented by Ms Marion Lê, a Registered Migration Agent.  The respondent Minister was represented by Mr B Cramer, Solicitor of Messrs Blake Dawson Waldron.  The then Presiding Member being no longer able to determine the matter, the parties consented to the Tribunal being reconstituted and a decision reached on the basis of the transcript of proceedings being read together with the exhibits and the submissions made on behalf of the parties.

  4. The following documents were tendered in evidence before the Tribunal.

  • Exhibit 1            "T" Documents

  • Exhibit 2            Supplementary "T" Documents

  • Exhibit 3            Bundle of Certificates from Department of Corrective Services

  • Exhibit 4            Letter dated 16 August 2001 to Mr Tran from West Morton Regional Community Corrections Board

  • Exhibit 5 Case Notes from Applicant's Prison File

  • Exhibit 6            Various Course Documents

  • Exhibit 7 Letter from Amaco Australia – Employment Reference – Van Lun Tran

  • Exhibit 8 Statement of Guong Hong Doan dated 20 August 2001

  • Exhibit 9 Statement of Phuong Thanh Doan dated 22 August 2001

  • Exhibit 10          Statement of Tran Cong Lam dated 23 August 2001

  • Exhibit 11          Statement of Truc Cong Lam dated 23 August 2001

  • Exhibit 12          Statement of Ha Thu Thi Lam dated 20 August 2001

  • Exhibit 13          Statement of Tuoc Ba Lam dated 20 August 2001

  • Exhibit 14          Statement of Danh Huynh dated 20 August 2001

  • Exhibit 15          Statement of Dzung Lau dated 20 August 2001

  • Exhibit 16          Statement of Nghiep Cong Lam dated 23 August 2001

  • Exhibit 17          Letter dated 27 August 2001 from Nguyen Van Toi

  • Exhibit 18          Statutory Declarations from Ada Lam, Tien Thi Tran and Trinh Thi Nguyen

  1. Mr Tran was born on 10 May 1974 in Minh Hai, South Vietnam.  He is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tran and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 461
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tran and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involves the applicant, Thanh Nha Tran, a Vietnamese citizen, who was subject to a deportation order issued by the Minister under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. Tran, who arrived in Australia in 1991, was convicted of multiple drug-related offences and sentenced to a total of eleven years imprisonment. The primary issue before the court was whether the Minister's decision to deport Tran following his criminal convictions was lawful and whether any hardship resulting from the deportation, including the prospect of indeterminate detention, could affect the validity of the deportation order.

The court examined the legal framework governing deportation in the context of criminal convictions, referencing previous cases such as Perez v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and Vo v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. The court also considered the potential implications of international obligations on the validity of the deportation order. Specifically, the court assessed whether the prospect of Tran facing indefinite detention upon return to Vietnam could invalidate the Minister's decision.

In affirming the Minister's decision, the court held that the seriousness of Tran's criminal offences justified deportation. The court found that the potential hardship Tran may face upon return, including the risk of detention, did not override the Minister's discretion to deport him. The court emphasised that the Australian community expects non-citizens to abide by its laws, and given Tran's criminal record, deportation was the appropriate course of action. Consequently, the court determined that the Minister's decision was lawful and should be affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thanh Nha Tran, a Vietnamese citizen born on 10 May 1974, arrived in Australia on 23 May 1991 at the age of 17. His mother, an Australian citizen, resides in New South Wales. In 1994, Mr Tran married Ms Phuong Doan Lam, an Australian citizen. In August 1999, Mr Tran was convicted in the Queensland Supreme Court for three offences of "supplying a dangerous drug" and one offence of "possession of things used in connection with a crime." He was sentenced to five years imprisonment, with eligibility for parole after serving twenty months. In May 2000, he was convicted of further drug offences, resulting in a six-year imprisonment sentence with a recommendation for parole after eighteen months. On 7 July 2000, the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs made a decision to deport Mr Tran under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. An application for the extension of time to seek a review of this decision was subsequently filed.

This case represents a review of the decision made by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs on 7 July 2000 to deport the applicant, Thanh Nha Tran. An application for the extension of time to seek a review was granted by the Tribunal on 18 April 2001. The matter was heard on 30 and 31 August 2001 in Brisbane. The applicant was represented by Ms Marion Lê, a Registered Migration Agent, while the respondent Minister was represented by Mr B Cramer, Solicitor of Messrs Blake Dawson Waldron. The Tribunal was reconstituted due to the inability of the then Presiding Member to determine the matter. The decision was reached based on the transcript of proceedings, exhibits, and submissions made by the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is the expectation of the Australian community that those from overseas who are enabled to reside in Australia will comply with the community standards and obey the laws of the country. For serious offences of the kind committed by the applicant and reflected in his conviction, the expectation of the Australian community would be, and is, that the exercise of the Minister's relevant power now vested in the Tribunal be in favour of the making of a deportation order.Conclusion Having regard to all the above matters, The Tribunal is of the view that the decision under review should be affirmed. The decision under review is affirmed.I certify that the forty-three (43) preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of The Hon. RNJ Purvis, QC, Deputy President.Signed: AssociateDate/s of Hearing 30-31 August 2001 Date of Decision 14 June 2002Counsel for the Applicant Ms M LeeSolicitor for the Respondent Mr B Cramer Blake Dawson Waldron

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This is a review of a decision made on 7 July 2000 by the respondent Minister to deport the applicant, Thanh Nha Tran, under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. An application for extension of time was sought by the applicant and with the consent of the respondent a Direction was issued by the Tribunal on 18 April 2001 extending the time for lodging the application for review. This matter was heard on 30 and 31 August 2001 in Brisbane. The applicant was represented by Ms Marion Lê, a Registered Migration Agent. The respondent Minister was represented by Mr B Cramer, Solicitor of Messrs Blake Dawson Waldron. The then Presiding Member being no longer able to determine the matter, the parties consented to the Tribunal being reconstituted and a decision reached on the basis of the transcript of proceedings being read together with the exhibits and the submissions made on behalf of the parties. The following documents were tendered in evidence before the Tribunal. Mr Tran was born on 10 May 1974 in Minh Hai, South Vietnam. He is a Vietnamese citizen. He arrived in Australia on 23 May 1991 at the age of 17 years. Mr Tran's father died when he was two months old. His mother is an Australian citizen, who resides in Cabramatta in New South Wales, with the applicant's half-sister, and her current de-facto partner, Mr Van Luan Tran. In 1994, Mr Tran met Ms Phuong Doan Lam, his current wife. The couple married in March 1999. Ms Lam is an Australian citizen. The Deportation Offences On 20 August 1999, following a plea of guilty, the applicant was convicted in the Queensland Supreme Court for three offences of "supplying a dangerous drug" (committed on 3, 6 and 25 May 1998) and one offence of "possession of things used in connection with a crime" (committed between 2 May and 6 June 1998). These charges followed an undercover surveillance operation conducted by the Queensland Police Service between 15 December 1997 and 20 November 1998 in the Brisbane and Gold Coast areas. The applicant's wife and Minh Ngoc Vo, an Australian citizen, were also convicted of offences arising out of the same surveillance operation. On all charges the applicant was sentenced to a period of five years imprisonment with a recommendation that he be considered eligible for release on parole after serving a period of twenty months imprisonment. Time that the applicant had already spent in custody was deemed time already served. In sentencing the applicant, her Honour Justice Atkinson raised the possibility that the applicant may be deported at the conclusion of his sentence, and remarked that she considered him to be "a person of bad character" (T17, p99). On 4 May 2000, the applicant was convicted of further drug offences in the Queensland Supreme Court. The applicant was convicted of one count of "trafficking dangerous drugs" (committed between 5 March and 26 May 1999), two charges of "supplying dangerous drugs" (committed on 14 and 21 May 1999), and two charges of "possessing anything used in the commission of a crime" (committed on 14 and 25 May 1999). The applicant was sentenced to imprisonment for six years with a recommendation for parol after serving eighteen months. Time that the applicant had already spent in custody was deemed time already service.