Tran and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Tran and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2016] AATA 413 (22 June 2016)

Division:  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:  2016/1670

Re:  THI HONG TRAN

APPLICANT

And:MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal  Deputy President S A Forgie

Date  22 June 2016

Place  Melbourne

The Tribunal decides to:

1.set aside the decision made by a delegate of the respondent on 17 March 2016 to refuse to grant a Student (Subclass 573) visa to the applicant; and

2.substitute a decision that the applicant not be refused a Student (Subclass 573) visa under s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958.

[sgd]

S A Forgie
Deputy President

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958: ss 5(1), 29, 31(1), 32-38, 500(6A)-500(6L), 501, 501(1), 501(6), 501(6)(c), 501(7), 501(12), 501G
Migration Regulations 1994

CASES

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT [1999] FCA 1197; (1999) 91 FCR 234; 56 ALD 349

OTHER MATERIAL

Direction No. 65: pars 6.1(1), 6.2(1), 6.3(1), 7(1), 8(1), 8(2), 8(3), 8(4), 8(5), 11.1(1), 11.1.1, 11.1.1(1)(d), 11.1.2, 11.3, 12(1), 12.2, 12.3(1), 12.4(1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 17 October 2012, Ms Thi Hong Tran was granted a Student (Subclass 573) visa (student visa) to enter and remain in Australia until 15 August 2015.  She arrived in Australia soon after in order to undertake a Master’s degree in Accounting and Financial Management degree at La Trobe University (La Trobe).  Before commencing that course she was required to undertake prescribed levels of an English Language Intensive Course for Overseas Students (ELICOS).  She undertook ELICOS at La Trobe Melbourne.  Ms Tran completed Level 3 on 8 February 2013 and Level 4 on 3 May 2013.  She was halfway through Level 5 when she agreed to care for a house and water and feed the plants.  That decision led to her being convicted of Cultivate Narcotic Plant Commercial Quantity on 26 November 2014.  She was sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 18 months but that term was fully suspended on condition that she entered a bond to be of good behaviour for two years.

  1. Except for a short period when she was on remand and following, Ms Tran continued to attend classes first at La Trobe Melbourne, then the Australian Catholic University (ACU) and finally at La Trobe where she transferred from a Master’s degree in Accounting and Financial Management to a Master’s degree in Human Resources Management. On 12 August 2015 and three days before her student visa expired, Ms Tran applied for a further student visa. In a letter dated 16 November 2015, an officer of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Department) advised Ms Tran that the Minister may refuse her application on the basis that she did not pass the character test. She was invited to comment or provide further information directed to whether or not the Minister should exercise his discretion in that way. Ms Tran provided further information. On 17 March 2016, a delegate of the Minister of Immigration and Border Protection (Minister) found that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tran and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Mig... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 413
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerns an application for a student visa by Ms Tran, which was refused by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection. The dispute centred on whether the Minister's discretion to refuse to grant a visa should be exercised due to Ms Tran failing to pass the character test. The matter was heard by the Migration and Refugee Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether, in light of Ms Tran's past contravention of Australian law, the discretion to refuse her visa application should be exercised. This involved assessing the seriousness of her conduct, the likelihood of her re-offending, and the potential impact of a refusal on her life, weighed against the risk to the Australian community.

The Tribunal found that Ms Tran had engaged in a serious contravention of Australian law, but attributed this to her naivety and a misguided belief that she should not seek further financial assistance from her parents. The Tribunal accepted expert opinion that while she has difficulties with planning and strategy, she is capable of learning from her mistakes, as demonstrated by her behaviour since her release on bail and subsequent good behaviour bond. The Tribunal noted her diligent efforts to reorder her life, her academic progress despite significant anxiety, her part-time employment, and the trust she has earned from various individuals. Considering her exceptional efforts to get back on track while facing sentencing for a serious offence, and the additional support of her husband, the Tribunal concluded that she is extremely unlikely to offend again, and the risk to the Australian community is very small. The Tribunal also considered the significant impact on Ms Tran of not completing her Master's degree, for which she has paid most of the tuition fees.

The Tribunal set aside the decision to refuse the visa, finding that the risk of re-offending was so small that Ms Tran should be given an opportunity to complete her studies in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Tran has applied for a student visa to study. Refusal to grant her a visa has no impact on Australian business interests.Conclusion There is no doubt that Ms Tran engaged in a serious contravention of Australian law when she agreed to care for a house and for plants. I find that her naivety and her misplaced understanding that she should not ask her parents for further finances led her to placing herself in that position. It was a position from which she could not extricate herself once she knew the address of the house and the nature of the undertaking. Were she to repeat her behaviour the consequences for the Australian community would be serious. I find, however, that she is very unlikely to do that. Although Dr King’s opinion is that she suffers from major difficulties in planning and in strategy formation under complex systems and she is prone to making decisions and taking actions which would place her among the poorest few percent of the population, I accept his further opinion that she is capable of learning from her mistakes. She has demonstrated this in her behaviour since she was released on bail. It could be said that her being on bail and, since 28 November 2014, being on a good behaviour bond have been incentives for her to not to repeat her former behaviour. I do not think that would be fair, though. She has worked hard and diligently on getting her life into order and has worked with Ms Grant, Ms Pavlou and Mr Manteit. All write well of her and Mr Manteit speaks highly of the effort she has put in to maintaining her studies despite the extreme anxiety and stress she has experienced. That effort has led to her continuing to undertake and pass subjects in the period up to her sentencing and, following that, until she was taken into immigration detention in March of this year. She has found part-time work to assist herself financially and has won the trust of Ms Eagles. I agree with Judge Sexton’s remark that the fact that she had “… managed to get back on track while facing a sentence for a serious offence is … quite exceptional.”[36] Until August 2015, Ms Tran achieved that with the help of, as I have said, Ms Grant, Ms Pavlou and Mr Manteit and her friends but she now has the additional support of her husband, Mr Wiboonthananan. Even without that additional support, Judge Sexton thought that Ms Tran was “extremely unlikely to offend again”.[37] That remains the case, I find, and the risk to the Australian community, should Ms Tran be permitted to remain in Australia, is correspondingly very, very small indeed. She has only three subjects to study and has paid the tuition fees for all but two. The impact upon her of not having completed her Master’s degree will be significant. If it were the case that the risk of her re-offending were moderate or high, the impact upon her would be of little weight. Given that the facts are otherwise, this is a situation in which the risk is so small that the Australian community would expect that Ms Tran be given an opportunity to complete the degree for which she came to Australia. It would not want to see a young person’s life be changed by one bad decision when she was a long way from home and has since done so much to rehabilitate herself and earned the respect of her counsellors as well as of her husband and friends.[37] G documents at 33

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established