Tradesman Technologies Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

Tradesman Technologies Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2023] AATA 1618 (12 June 2023)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/3901, 2021/3902, 2021/4775

Re:Tradesman Technologies Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndComptroller-General of Customs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:12 June 2023  

Place:Perth

The decision of the Respondent made on 2 June 2021 to reject the Applicant’s application for a refund of the dumping duty paid on the drilled rectangular hollow sections, imposed pursuant to the Customs Tariff (Anti-Dumping) Act 1975 (Cth), is set aside and substituted with the decision that the dumping duty paid on the drilled rectangular hollow sections be refunded.

...[sgd].......................................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

CUSTOMS - decision to reject the Applicant’s application for a refund of dumping duty paid in respect of drilled rectangular hollow structures pursuant to the Customs Tariff (Anti-Dumping) Act 1975  – whether drilled rectangular hollow structures constitutes a structure for the purposes of Customs Act 1901 classifications –  whether dumping duty payable – rectangular hollow structures fall within classification 7308 9000 – reviewable decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL ACT 1975 (CTH) S 42(C)

CUSTOMS ACT 1901 (CTH) SS 163(1)(B); 269T; 269TG; 269TJ(2)

Customs Tariff (Anti-Dumping) Act 1975 (Cth) ss 8; 10;

Customs Tariff Act 1995 (Cth) Schedules 2 and 3

Customs Regulation 2015 (Cth) regs 102–112; schedule 6.

CASES

BLACKWOOD HODGE (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD V COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS (1980) 3 ALD 38

COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF CUSTOMS V PHARM-A-CARE LABORATORIES PTY LTD [2020] HCA 2

COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF CUSTOMS V SMOOTHFLOW PTY LTD [2021] FCA 144

CHINESE FOOD AND WINE SUPPLIES PTY LTD V COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS (VIC) (1987) 72 ALR 59

GM HOLDEN LTD V COMMISSIONER OF THE ANTI-DUMPING COMMISSION AND OTHERS [2014] FCA 708

MARINE POWER AUSTRALIA PTY LTD V COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF CUSTOMS (1989) 89 ALR 561

NISSHO-IWAI (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED AND COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS [1978] AATA 6; (1978) 1 ALD 125

PILKINGTON (AUSTRALIAN) LIMITED (ACN 006 904 052) V MINISTER OF STATE FOR JUSTICE & CUSTOMS & ANOR [2002] FCAFC 423

RE TRIDON AND COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS (1982) 4 ALD 615

Sanwa Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2019] AATA 5166

Smoothflow Australia Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2020] AATA 1890

Solar Juice Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2022] AATA 550

TIME CONSULTANTS V COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS (1987) 76 ALR 313

VERNON-CARUS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD AND THOMAS CREEVEY AND ASSOCIATES V COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS [1995] FCA 1283

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Report to the Minister No. 177: Certain Aluminium Extrusions Exported to Australia from the People’s Republic of China; 15 April 2010

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

12 June 2023

THE APPLICATIONS

  1. The following applications for review were lodged by the Applicant on 9 June 2021.

    A.Application 2021/3091: relating to a decision of the Respondent made on 2 June 2021 to reject the refund of dumping and/or countervailing duty paid in respect of pedestrian grab rails;

    B.Applications 2021/3092 and 2021/4775: relating to a decision of the Respondent made on 2 June 2021 to reject the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tradesman Technologies Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Cu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tradesman Technologies Pty Ltd (the Applicant) sought review of decisions by the Comptroller-General of Customs (the Respondent) to reject its applications for a refund of dumping duty paid on drilled rectangular hollow structures. The dispute centred on whether these imported structures, which were pre-drilled with specific hole patterns according to customer specifications, constituted "structures" for the purposes of classification under the Customs Act 1901 and the Customs Tariff (Anti-Dumping) Act 1975, and consequently, whether dumping duty was payable. The matter was heard by Deputy President Boyle of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the drilled rectangular hollow structures fell within the scope of the dumping notice, either as the goods under consideration or as "like goods" to them. Secondly, the Tribunal had to consider whether the drilled rectangular hollow structures, having been prepared for a particular purpose, were correctly classified under tariff heading 7308, which pertains to structures of iron or steel. The Applicant contended that the structures were either outside the dumping notice due to their preparation or should be classified under heading 7308, thereby exempting them from dumping duty. The Respondent argued that the drilled structures were within the scope of the dumping notice.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal accepted the Applicant's submission that the drilled rectangular hollow structures were intended for use in traffic management infrastructure, specifically as sign posts and grab rails, which are considered structures for the purposes of tariff heading 7308. The evidence demonstrated that these structures were manufactured to precise specifications, including pre-drilled holes, to meet customer requirements for installation and safety. The Tribunal concluded that because the drilled rectangular hollow structures were found to fall within the scope of heading 7308, they were not subject to dumping duty.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the Respondent's decisions to reject the Applicant's applications for refunds of dumping duty and substituted them with decisions to allow the refunds.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the above reasons, I am satisfied that installed traffic signs incorporating the drilled RHS are structures for the purposes of heading 7308. I therefore find that the drilled RHS are within the scope of heading 7308 and that, as a result, they are not subject to Dumping Duty.FORMULATION OF THE DECISION The Applicant identifies the Respondent’s decisions review of which is sought in these applications, as being made on 2 June 2021.[33] The Applicant does not identify the document or documents that comprised that decision. At para 16 of its SFC the Applicant said that the reasons given by the Respondent for its decisions were “FID DOES NOT MEET TARIFF CLASS OF 73089000. REFUND REJECTED.” The Applicant does not identify in which document or documents those reasons were contained. The Respondent similarly does not identify the document or documents which comprise its decision or decisions review of which is sought. [33] (Applicant’s SFC para 16) The only document that I can find dated 2 June 2021 is an email from Leanne Feuerherdt addressed to “Jez” which stated:[34]Hi Jez,Refunds have been rejected. If you can please advise the Importer, thanks.Regards[34] T13/238. The signature block identifies Ms Feuerherdt as being a Senior Border Force Officer within National Refunds Intervention/Trade Compliance, Trusted Trader and Trade Compliance Branch. Appearing at T12/220-237 is a series of three documents headed “Refunds Approve/Reject”, which state, respectively:[35]·LINE 1 DOES NOT MEET TARIFF CALSS 73089000. REFUND REJECTED · LINE 1 and 2 DOES NOT MEET TARIFF CALSS 73089000. REFUND REJECTED ·FID DOES NOT MEET TARIFF CLASS 73099000. REFUND REJECTED [35] T12/220; T12/226; T12/232 Although it is not stated, I assume that the email of 2 June 2021 referred to in [67] above and the documents appearing at T12/220-237 is/are the document(s) which the parties have treated as the decision to reject the Applicant’s applications for refunds of Dumping Duty and the reasons for that rejection. Again, although it is not identified in those documents, I assume that the Respondent, or the Respondent’s authorised delegate, was making the decisions to reject the applications for refunds of Dumping Duty under s 163 of the Customs Act. That is suggested by para 23 of the Applicant’s SFC. On that assumption, and as pointed out by the Applicant at para 24 of its SFC, the Tribunal has the power under s 273GA(1)(haaa) of the Customs Act to review a decision of a collector of customs under s 163 in relation to an application for a refund, rebate or remission of duty. As was the case in Paracella Pty Ltd ATF The Kelvin Flintoff Family Trust and Comptroller-General of Customs,[36] there was no evidence in the present case that Ms Feuerherdt was delegated to make a decision under s 163 of the Customs Act on behalf of the Respondent (or at least no evidence to which the I was taken). On the same basis that I made the findings in [18]-[21] of Paracella, I find that in this matter I have jurisdiction to review the decisions to refuse the refunds, that the decisions to refuse the refunds were made under s 163 of the Customs Act, and that the review of the decisions is undertaken pursuant to the power to review in s 273GA(1)(haaa) of the Customs Act.[36] [2021] AATA 1988

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Anscombe’s witness statement was to the following effect:(a)The Applicant’s business is, relevantly, divided into the two divisions described in [21(g)] above.(b)The customers of the traffic management business are either companies that supply goods to MRWA or wholesalers from whom those companies purchase goods for supply to MRWA.(c)MRWA has precise specifications and standards for traffic infrastructure, such as traffic signs and barriers, which include:(i)The shape of the pole or tube (circular or rectangle) and whether the pole or tube is straight or curved;(ii)The material from which the pole or tube is to be made;(iii)The length, width and thickness of the pole or tube;(iv)The coating of the pole or tube;(v)If the pole or tube is to be powder coated, the colour of the coating;(vi)How the pole or tube is to be cut (saw cut versus sheared);(vii)If the pole or tube is to be drilled;(viii)If the pole of tube is to be drilled, the drill pattern.(d)The Applicant only supplies sign posts and grab rails that precisely meet the MRWA specifications.(e)Rectangular poles are pre-drilled to provide a safe working environment in Australia and for ease of installation of the traffic signs. At the time of importing the sign post it is not known exactly what signs will be attached to the pole. Additional signs may be attached after installation. For this reason sign posts can have up to 17 predrilled holes. This number of holes can accommodate the various combinations of signs that could be attached.(f)MRWA document 8720-0675-8 sets out the hole spacing for rectangular posts. This spacing is specifically designed to accommodate signs used by MRWA.(g)Based on these specifications, the Applicant provides a hole spacing diagram to its suppliers. This document sets out to the exact millimetre, the required location of drill holes. Mr Anscombe’s understanding is that the poles imported by the Applicant for use by MRWA are unique to Western Australian traffic management sign posts.(h)MRWA suppliers must supply goods that precisely meet these specifications. When goods are imported, the Applicant will review the specifications of the delivered product to ensure that the products meet the relevant specifications.(i)He is not aware of any generic tubes or posts that are supplied powder coated yellow, with pre-drilled holes or cut to specific lengths such as 3.2m or 3.6m.CONSIDERATION The parties’ respective outlines of submissions and closing submissions helpfully reduced the argument in this matter to the following competing contentions:The Applicant1.The issue is whether the drilled RHS fit within the scope of the dumping notice made by the Minister following investigation 177.[13] 2.In interpreting and applying the dumping notice, there are two different avenues the Tribunal can take that result in the refund being payable:[14](a) Find that the dumping notice does not apply to tubes that have been further prepared for a particular purpose, regardless of the tariff classification of the goods; or(b) Find that the drilled RHS were tubes prepared for use in a structure and are classified to tariff heading 7308.[13] Applicant’s outline of submissions para 2.[14] Applicant’s outline of submissions para 3 and closing submissions Transcript at 44.The RespondentThe drilled RHS are within the terms of the dumping notice because:[15](a) they are within the GUC the subject of the dumping notices and as described in Report 177; or(b) they are “like goods” to the GUC.[15] Respondent’s outline of submissions para 6.