| ... | P |
3 .
| been raised to its admission. | The document purports to | be a |
record made by a witness, Mr Frewen, of a conversation which took
place at a meeting which he attended on 10 March 1976 between the
persons present at that meetlnu.
| Mr Frewen has qiven evldence, but has | not yet been |
| cross-examined. | He has refreshed his memory from the document |
| and | uiven |
| further refreshing his memory. Reliance is placed upon the provislons | evidence | of the | conversation | after | so |
| of |
| Part IIIA of the Evidence Act | 1905 and it is | submitted for the |
plalntlff that the statements in the document should be admltted
ln evldence.
| The document purports to | be a record of the conversatlon |
| ghich took | place | at | the | meetlna. | I | conslder | that | there | 1 s |
| therefore a statement ot fact | In the document | to the extent that |
| it 1 s a record of what was said | at the meetlng. The statement of |
| fact belnq what was sald in the conversatlon was made | by Mr |
| Frewen. who appears to | me to be a qualified person In that he was |
| enqaged | In | the | relevant | buslness | at the | tlme | he | made | the |
| statement. | I refer to the relevant sectlon | of the Act, s.7A(1). |
| I consider that the statement was made elther | In | the course of |
| the business | or | for the purposes of the buslness. s.7Bll)rb). |
| Although the document, so far | as the evidence goes, has not been |
| shown to form part | of | what mlght be called a record | of | a |
| continuous kind kept | In | the buslness. | I stlll thlnk it "forms |
| part of the record of the business" : 5.7B(l)(a). | I consider the |
4 .
| document falls | within the words of s.7A(2) In that It falls at |
| least within recognised by him | the | words | "otherwise | produced | by | him; or ... |
as hls statement".
| I | note the provisions | of | s.?H concerning the Court's |
| power to | draw | inferences. In my oplnlon, the document would |
ordinarlly be excluded because of the rule against hearsay, but s.7B(2)(a) neuates this ground of inadmisslbility. The record was made shortly after the conversation in March 1976 and It 1 s common ground that some civll proceedlngs were commenced by Tradestock Pty. Limited in December 1976.
Sectlon ? C t l ! excludes the statement from the provlsions
| of S .?B | If lt | was "made or obtained fcr the purpose of | c)r In |
| contemplatlon of any judlclal or | admlnlstrative proceeding". M y |
| attention was also drawn to | s.iD!3) and ! 4 ) . | The effect | ,:sf this |
sectlon 1s that the statement map not be used in proceedings such
as those now before me where It ;S made "In cmnexlon wlth. 3 r In
connexlon with any investlgatlon relatlng or leadinu to" the
proceedings at present before me.
| The proceedlngs before me were not commenced | 1mt11 1978. |
| and I | conslder SO | far as the evldence goes that the statement |
| made under conslderatlon does not fall vlthln | s.?D(3). | I have |
| some doubt whether the statement | may not |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Trade Practices Commission v T.N.T. Management Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1984] FCA 260
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.