TRACIE SKINN and AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

[2012] AATA 121

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2010/3482

Re

TRACIE SKINN

APPLICANT

And

AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop
Dr J Chaney, Member

Date 28 February 2012
Place Perth

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and, in substitution therefor, decides that the respondent has continued to be liable to pay compensation to the applicant for incapacity for work, in accordance with s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), from 20 November 2008 to the present date, and is presently so liable, on the basis that “the amount per week” that the applicant has been “able to earn in suitable employment”, within the meaning of that section, from 20 November 2008 is nil.

Application may be made to the Tribunal in relation to the costs of these proceedings within 14 days of the date of this decision. In the event that no such application is made by that date, the Tribunal orders, pursuant to s 67(8) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), that the costs of these proceedings incurred by the applicant be paid by the respondent in accordance with Section 6.8 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction.

..................[sgd].......................

S D Hotop, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – applicant sustained compensable injury in May 2008 – respondent paid compensation to applicant for incapacity for work until November 2008 – applicant performed return to work programs from June to October 2008 – applicant failed to perform return to work program in November 2008 – employment offered by respondent to applicant in return to work program in November 2008 not suitable employment – applicant’s failure to perform return to work program in November 2008 reasonable – applicant not able to earn in suitable employment from November 2008 – respondent liable to pay compensation to applicant for incapacity for work from November 2008 – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), s 4(1), s 4(9), s 14(1) and s 19(4)

CASES

Re Karhani and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (2011) 55 AAR 333

Re Laloz and Comcare [1995] AATA 682

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S D Hotop
Dr J Chaney, Member

28 February 2012   

INTRODUCTION

  1. Tracie Skinn (“the applicant”) was employed by the Australian Postal Corporation (“the respondent”) as a postal delivery officer.

  2. On 15 May 2008 the applicant suffered an injury in the course of her employment by the respondent, and she made a claim for compensation, dated 19 May 2008, for “soft tissue damage to the left side of neck”.  A “Workers’ Compensation FIRST Medical Certificate”, issued by Dr Roland Gaebler on 16 May 2008, described the diagnosis of the injury suffered by the applicant on 15 May 2008 as “left sided soft tissue injury of neck and soft tissue injury right hip”.

  3. On 26 May 2008 the respondent accepted liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“SRC Act”) to pay compensation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TRACIE SKINN and AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tracie Skinn initiated proceedings against the Australian Postal Corporation in a dispute regarding workers' compensation. Ms Skinn, a former Postal Delivery Officer, claimed that she sustained a compensable injury on 15 May 2008 while delivering mail by motorcycle, which caused her to resign from her position on 17 November 2008 due to unbearable pain and inability to perform her duties. The central legal issue before the court was whether Ms Skinn was entitled to continued compensation for incapacity for work after November 2008. The court had to determine if Ms Skinn's failure to participate in a return to work program in November 2008 was reasonable, given her physical condition and the nature of the employment offered.

The court deliberated on several factors, including the medical evidence presented, the reasonableness of the return to work program offered by the respondent, and the ongoing incapacity of Ms Skinn. The evidence showed that Ms Skinn had been unable to perform even light duties due to her severe pain and injuries. Medical reports indicated that she remained totally unfit for work from November 2008, with no suitable employment offered by the respondent. Furthermore, the court considered the unsuccessful attempts at various treatments and surgeries aimed at alleviating her pain, culminating in the need for further surgical intervention.

After careful consideration of the evidence and arguments presented, the court concluded that Ms Skinn's failure to perform the return to work program in November 2008 was reasonable, given her medical condition and the unsuitability of the offered employment. Consequently, the court held that the respondent was liable to pay compensation to Ms Skinn for her incapacity for work from November 2008 onwards. The decision set aside the previous determination that had denied Ms Skinn compensation beyond November 2008.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1─T123, pp 1─197) lodged with the Tribunal by the respondent in accordance with s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 (Cth);·Exhibits A1─A12 tendered by the applicant;·Exhibits R1─R6 tendered by the respondent;·the oral evidence of the applicant and of the following witnesses:− Mr Richard Vaughan, Mr Soni Narula, Dr Roland Gaebler, Mr Peter Watson, and Dr John Ker (who were called by the applicant); and− Dr John Low, Dr Michael Bowles, Mr George Wong and Timothy Munro (who were called by the respondent).THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE The applicant tendered in evidence her witness statement, dated 25 November 2011, and she affirmed that its contents are true correct. The applicant’s witness statement (Exhibit A1) states as follows:“1. I was born [in] August 1966.2.I commenced employment at Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post) in or about June or July 2007 and between February 2008 and November 2008 was employed as a Postal Delivery Officer on a full time basis.3.My duties as a Postal Delivery Officer required me to attend the Australia Post depot and sort mail, pack the mail into packs which would fit into a motorcycle pouch, ready those packs of mail for delivery and to then deliver the mail to residential addresses.4.My normal working day started at approximately 5.00 am and ended any time between 12.00 pm and 3.00 pm depending on the volume of the mail.5.I loved my job and was able to perform it without any restrictions.6.On the 15th May 2008 in the course of my employment with Australia Post I was delivering mail by motorcycle to houses in Ellenbrook when the wheel of my motorcycle slipped and I fell from my motorcycle to the ground (‘the accident’).7.That day I had started work at approximately 4.00 am as I had altered my roster to enable me to take my mother to an appointment after work.8.I sorted the mail into packs and put it in the pouches of my motorcycle and left the depot at approximately 7.00 am. 9.I was responsible for delivering mail to the Woodlake Estate at Ellenbrook. The delivery run has approximately 900 delivery points or houses that mail is to be delivered to.10.When I was approximately three quarters of the way through my delivery run I rode up a driveway at … Fringelilly Way, Ellenbrook and delivered the mail. As I turned the handlebars of my motorcycle and began to ride the motorcycle back down the driveway to the next delivery point the rear wheel of the motorcycle slipped, causing the bike to spin in a complete circle and I was thrown backwards and off the motorcycle.11.I landed on the kerb. When I landed my left shoulder hit the kerb and the back of my head struck the road. The rest of my body was lying on the driveway.12.I was wearing my motorcycle helmet at the time.13.My work uniform consisted of ‘Hard Yakka’ pants, an Australia Post polo shirt with long sleeves, boots and fingerless gloves.14.Other than my helmet, I was not wearing any padding or other protective equipment.15.Immediately following the accident I had neck pain and a severe headache and pain to my forehead, particularly between my eyes. I would consider the pain to my head and neck to be approximately 7 out of 10 where 10 represents unbearable pain.16.I also had pain to my left shoulder which I consider would be approximately 5 out of 10 where 10 represents unbearable pain.17.I lay on the ground for a few moments before attempting to get back up. I was sore and I felt a bit stupid for having fallen.18.When I got up I got back on my motorcycle and delivered mail to another 15-20 houses before ringing my team leader because I had an express letter which did not form part of my run and which needed to be delivered.19.I rang my supervisor Tim O’Grady who advised me to bring the letter back to the depot and that he would ensure it was sent the next day.20.I did not mention my accident at that time as I was more concerned about the express letter than having fallen from my motorcycle. I was also a bit embarrassed that I had fallen.21.By the time I completed my run my pain had not increased.22.I went straight home at the end of my run.23.When I got home I took some panadol to alleviate the pain and then took my mother to her medical appointment.24.I arrived home at approximately 3.30 pm and went straight to bed. 25.At approximately 4.30 pm I got up and by 7.00 pm the pain to my head, neck and left shoulder was unbearable.26.I thought that if I lay down and rested the pain would get better. I went to lay down but found that I had to support my head due to the unbearable pain to my neck. It was a sharp, excruciating pain.27.I took some more panadol and applied a heat pack to my neck before returning to bed.28.That night I was unable to sleep due to the pain. At approximately 3.00 am I decided to try using the spa in the backyard to alleviate the pain.29.At that time the pain to my neck was unbearable (ie 10 out of 10 where 10 represents unbearable pain) and the pain to my left shoulder was approximately 9 out of 10 where 10 represents unbearable pain.30.That morning I drove my car into work as I was unable to put my motorcycle helmet on due to the pain to my head, neck and shoulder.31.I only went to work because I had the express letter that needed delivering and I needed to report my accident.32.I reported my accident to Damien who was the Second in Charge at the depot. I filled out an incident report and a claim form with Bill Newnham.33.I was told that because I could not put my helmet on my head I was to sort the mail in the depot instead.34.That day my neck pain continued to get worse. 35.I advised my supervisor and left work at approximately 8.00 am. I attended my general practitioner, Dr Gaebler at approximately 8.30 am.36.Dr Gaebler advised me that he thought that I had a form of whiplash injury and that I would require one week off work initially and perhaps another two after that if I did not improve.37.I was referred to a physiotherapist at Beechboro.38.Australia Post subsequently accepted my claim for workers’ compensation and I returned to work on light mail sorting duties. These duties required me to lift my head and lower it on a repeated and regular basis which increased the pain to my neck. As a result I attempted to complete mail re-directions which involved me placing stickers on mail. I also sorted RAC magazines for delivery.39.I carried out these duties for 6 months. I would work 4 hours a day, 5 days a week.40.I was not coping. The pain to my neck was unbearable. The work required me to constantly look up and down and this was causing my neck to get worse.41.My left shoulder was also becoming increasingly painful because I was constantly holding bundles of mail with my arm in one sustained position.42.The pain to my neck and left shoulder was not improving, in fact it was worsening.43.I continued to complain to my doctor and the doctors I attended at the request of Australia Post that my pain was increasing and I was not coping.44.As a result, my personal life was also suffering. 45.I didn’t think there was much point in complaining to Australia Post that I was not coping. I was scared I would lose my job and I believed that my employment would be terminated because I could not do full duties.46.I felt as though I was an outcast at work. I felt that Australia Post had too high an expectation of me getting back to work and that I was being pushed too quickly into returning to full duties.47.I thought that if I told the doctors that I was not coping with these duties that (sic) they would inform Australia Post and have my return to work program altered.48.In approximately October 2008 I was referred by Australia Post to Dr John Low. I advised Dr Low that I was not coping well with the hours and duties I was working and that my work duties aggravated the pain I was experiencing to my neck and left shoulder.49.I also met with Tim Monroe (sic), the Australia Post rehabilitation officer on one occasion. He drew up a Return to Work Program that had me returning to work on increased hours.50.I felt nobody was interested in listening to me when I was complaining that I was unable to cope at work.51.As a result of my ongoing pain and inability to carry out even the lightest of duties without aggravating my injuries, I tendered my resignation from Australia Post in November 2008. I didn’t mention my injury in my resignation. I truly enjoyed my job prior to the accident and I wanted to thank Australia Post for the opportunity.52.Between November 2008 and approximately April 2009 I did not see my doctor because I did not believe that anything could be done to fix me. I had already been prescribed analgesic and anti-inflammatory medications and I continued to take these. I also used heat packs and my spa to assist in reducing the pain. During this period I stayed at home and rested. I became a recluse.53.By April 2009 I had been resting and using the medications and heat treatment without success. The pain to my neck and left shoulder remained the same.54.I returned to Dr Gaebler who referred me to a pain specialist, Dr Cheah.55.Between April 2009 and January 2010 I underwent various scans and tests and also underwent a nerve root sleeve injection to my neck. I continued to take the analgesic medications.56.Unfortunately none of these treatments was successful in reducing the levels of pain and discomfort I was experiencing.57.My neck had got so bad that I could barely move my head.58.At home, I remained a recluse and rarely left the house other than to attend medical appointments. My social life was non-existent and my irritability and recluse-like nature caused friction between my partner and I.59.I was, quite simply, unable to work.60.Ultimately, in January 2010, I was referred to Mr Soni Narula, Neurosurgeon, who recommended that I undergo surgery to my neck. Australia Post declined to pay for my surgery at that time.61.I was subsequently referred to Mr Peter Watson, Mr Richard Vaughan and Mr George Wong, Neurosurgeons for medico-legal assessment of my injuries. It is my understanding that all of the Neurosurgeons I attended recommended surgery except Mr Wong.62.In early 2011 Australia Post finally agreed to fund my surgery.63.I underwent surgery under Mr Narula on the 15th May 2011.64.Prior to the surgery I continued to experience unbearable pain to my neck and left shoulder and arm. I was unable to move my neck.65.After the surgery the pain to my neck is almost gone. I would consider it to be a 3 out of 10 where 10 represents unbearable pain. After living with unbearable pain for so long I would describe this pain as fairly minimal.66.I have now also regained the ability to move my neck, however I still experience increased pain if I look upwards or downwards for any longer than 5 minutes at a time.67.Unfortunately the pain to my left shoulder was not ‘fixed’ by the surgery. I continue to experience near unbearable pain to my left shoulder and arm. I consider it to be a 9 out of 10 where 10 represents unbearable pain. My shoulder has remained this way since the day after my accident.68.I still retain movement of my left arm and shoulder, it is just extremely painful to do so. Fortunately I am ambidextrous and as a result I am able to do a lot of things with my right arm.69.As a result of my accident however I am unable to put my left arm behind my back. I experience significant difficulty when dressing. For example, when I put socks on I need to lift my foot up onto the opposite leg so that I do not have to reach downwards.70.I also experience difficulty when toileting as the twisting movement aggravates my shoulder and neck pain. In addition, I must wash my hair with my right arm and hand because I cannot lift my left arm without pain.71.I attempt to use humour to deflect from the fact that I live with constant pain however, psychologically I have become fragile and I now attend counselling on a regular basis and require anti-depressant medications. I have been reluctant to make a claim for these through Australia Post as I am still fighting to have my wages paid.72.As a result of my accident sustained injuries I am unable to drive a manual car or ride a motorcycle. Prior to the accident I used to go trail bike riding every weekend and participate in the Variety WA motorcycle ride for charity.73.Prior to the accident I would play indoor cricket 5 nights a week and play in a Superleague competition on Sundays.74.I no longer visit my friends because we all used to be physically active and had a lot in common. I am no longer able to be physically active and I feel like an outcast. In addition my pain causes me to be much more irritable and I suffer from frequent mood swings.75.Following my operation I am now able to lie on my back when sleeping however I cannot lie on my left or right sides as this puts additional pressure onto my left shoulder. I now take approximately 1-2 hours to get to sleep at night and am only able to sleep for 2 hours at a time.76.Prior to the surgery I was unable to push a shopping trolley. I am now able to push a shopping trolley but only if it has a small load in it.77.I am no longer able to iron clothes, hang clothes on the washing line, mow the lawn or use a whipper snipper. I cannot wash my car, maintain my car, maintain my house or my front yard. 78.I have now attended Mr Peter Campbell, Orthopaedic Surgeon in relation to my left shoulder pain and restrictions and he has now advised me that I will require surgery to my left shoulder as a result of my work accident.79.I remain certified totally unfit for work.80.I have not been paid any wages from Australia Post since I resigned in November 2008.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the purposes of para (g) of s 19(4) of the SRC Act, the Tribunal notes the following evidence regarding additional matters which it considers to be relevant in determining the applicant’s “[ability] to earn in suitable employment”, within the meaning of s 19, in the period from 20 November 2008 to date:·the applicant resigned from her employment by the respondent on, and with effect from, 17 November 2008;·in a letter dated 24 September 2010 Dr Gaebler stated that the applicant “has been unfit to work since November 2008” (Exhibit A9);·in a report dated 10 February 2010 Dr Gaebler stated that the applicant “is currently totally unfit to work and is likely to continue this way unless she has a favourable response to surgery” (T92);·in a report dated 30 May 2010 Dr Low opined that the applicant had not been totally unfit for work since November 2008 and that she was presently “fit to work full time hours” with specified restrictions (T106);·Mr Watson opined in his oral evidence that, when he examined the applicant on 17 June 2010, she had a “partial capacity for work”, namely, the capacity to work for a maximum of 20 hours per week in “very light duties”;·on 6 July 2010 Dr Gaebler issued a progress medical certificate stating that the applicant was totally unfit for work from 6 July 2010 to 6 October 2010 (T113);·Dr Ker, who examined the applicant on 11 October 2010, opined that she had the physical capacity to do only sedentary work on a part-time basis but that, having regard also to the fact that she had been out of the workforce for two years, “the likelihood of [her] returning to any form of manual work must now be considered remote”;·on 9 May 2011 the applicant underwent surgery to her cervical spine performed by Mr Narula (the cost of which was met by the respondent) and it is common ground that that surgery was successful;·on 26 July 2011 Mr Narula reported that the applicant’s “post operative recovery was relatively slow and quite painful” and that, when he saw her on 15 June 2011, she currently “remains totally incapacitated for work”, and he suggested that she “stay away from work” for at least the next three months;·on 13 September 2011 Mr Narula saw the applicant and “suggested she could look at a return to work not involving lifting”;·on 19 September 2011 Dr Bowles saw the applicant and opined that she presently had the physical capacity to undertake the restricted work duties specified in the Return to Work Programme of 5 November 2008 on a full-time basis, but that it was unlikely that she would have the physical capacity to undertake her pre-injury duties as a Postal Delivery Officer in the future;·on 26 September 2011 Mr Wong saw the applicant and opined that she could “return to some form of lighter duties on a graduated basis at this stage” and that “with the passage of time and settlement of the claim … she [could] most likely return to work as a Postal Delivery Officer”;·Dr Low reported on 17 October 2011 that the applicant was presently able to perform the work duties specified in the Return to Work Programme of 5 November 2008 on a full-time basis and he opined in his oral evidence that a graduated return to full-time duties over a period of 6–12 weeks would be appropriate in the applicant’s case;·it is common ground that the respondent has not made an offer of employment to the applicant since the Return to Work Programme of 5 November 2008, and that the applicant has not sought employment since her resignation on 17 November 2008.CONCLUSION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established