TQMT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

TQMT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 3052 (27 August 2021)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No: 2020/6049
GENERAL DIVISION )

Re: TQMT
Applicant

And: Child Support Registrar
Respondent

And: BJJL
Other Party

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:  Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

DATE OF CORRIGENDUM:            30 August 2021

PLACE:           Melbourne

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this application as follows:

1.The references to “TMQT” in the decision are replaced with “TQMT”.

...[sgd]..............................................................

Senior Member

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2020/6049

Re:TMQT

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndBJJL

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Date:27 August 2021

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Tribunal dated 25 August 2020 and substitutes it with a decision that the percentage of care of the child between 25 October 2019 and 5 October 2020 is 51% to BJJL and 49% to TMQT.

...[sgd].................. ..................................................

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – separation under the one roof – pattern of care –decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989

Cases

P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312

Secondary Materials

Department of Social Services, Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide (Version 4.57, Released 1 July 2021) < FOR DECISION

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

27 August 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. TMQT applied on 2 October 2020 for review of a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division dated 25 August 2020 (AAT1).

  2. AAT1 set aside an earlier decision by an officer of the Registrar dated 17 June 2020, deciding that TMQT had a percentage of care of 30% of their  child ‘M’, and BJJL had a percentage of care of 70% from 21 February 2020.

  3. M was born in 2002 and lives under the same roof as the separated parents, with TMQT occupying the lower floor of the family property. BJJL applied on 21 February 2020 for an assessment of child support, asserting 100% care of M from the separation date, said to be 25 October 2019.

  4. The Registrar made a decision on 17 March 2020 that from 25 October 2019 the percentages of care, effective 21 February 2020, were: TMQT, 49%; and BJJL, 51%. BJJL lodged an objection to this decision, which was disallowed on 17 June 2020; and subsequently applied to the Tribunal for review of that decision. TMQT was not contacted to participate in the first review at AAT1.

  5. The Registrar lodged a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TQMT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3052
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support assessment between TQMT and BJJL, with the Child Support Registrar as the respondent. The dispute centred on the correct percentage of care attributed to each parent for their child, M, during a specific period following the parents' separation. The review was heard by Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member.

The court was required to determine the relevant care period for the child, whether a pattern of care existed between the parents, and if so, what percentage of care accurately reflected the actual care provided by each parent. The court also needed to consider the implications of the parents living separately under the one roof and the respective financial contributions made by each parent towards the child's welfare and household expenses.

The Senior Member reasoned that a pattern of care existed and that the relevant period commenced on 25 October 2019, the date of separation, and concluded on 5 October 2020, the day before the child turned 18 and was no longer in full-time study. While acknowledging that primary and direct personal care of the child lay with BJJL, and that an intervention order prevented TMQT from exercising decision-making authority, the Senior Member considered the varying financial contributions to the household. The court found that despite the physical separation within the shared residence, the parents shared the kitchen and laundry facilities, and that TMQT was the sole contributor to the joint bank account from which household expenses were paid, making a significant financial contribution to the child's welfare. Although BJJL had a period of employment and made some payments towards household outgoings, this was not considered a significant enough change to alter the pattern of care.

The Tribunal decided to set aside the previous decision and substituted it with a determination that BJJL had 51% of the care for M, and TMQT had 49% of the care, for the period between 25 October 2019 and 5 October 2020.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the percentage of care and financial contributions for a child, M, following the separation of M's parents, BJJL and TMQT, on 25 October 2019. BJJL and M have lived on the top floor of the property since the separation, with limited interaction between BJJL, M and TMQT. BJJL claimed sole responsibility for decision-making regarding M, and that she provided for M's accommodation, food, clothing, health care, emotional support and education, while TMQT contributed to the mortgage and other household expenses. The evidence presented at the hearing suggested that while the parties lived under the same roof, they had little interaction, and the care of M was primarily managed by BJJL. TMQT contributed financially to the household, paying for the mortgage, electricity, water, internet and car registration for M. However, BJJL also contributed financially by paying for rates, a Wi-Fi connection, house insurance, shopping and food, as well as providing specialist medical treatment for M’s mental health and paying for a 6-month course of study between February and July 2020. The issue before the court was the determination of the care period and the percentage of care for M. The court determined that the relevant care period was from 25 October 2019 until 5 October 2020, and that there was a pattern of care for M with BJJL providing 51% of the care and TMQT providing 49% of the care. The decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Tribunal dated 25 August 2020 was set aside, and a new decision was substituted.

This matter came before the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) on a second review application, pursuant to section 50 of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth). The applicant, BJJL, sought to challenge the original decision made by the Child Support Registrar on 25 August 2020, which determined the percentage of care provided to M during the relevant period. The decision was set aside and substituted with a new determination of 51% care to BJJL and 49% care to TMQT. Prior to the Tribunal's decision, the matter had been reviewed by the Child Support Registrar, who assessed the evidence and made the initial decision on the percentage of care. Key procedural steps included the filing of the second review application by the applicant, the submission of evidence by both parties, and the hearing of the matter by the Tribunal on 27 July 2021.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Child Support Guide (the Guide)[1] (section 2.2.1) observes that where there is doubt as to the extent to which a person is providing care, in making a child support assessment the Registrar will ‘consider whichever of the following are relevant to the particular case’:[1] The Guide is found at what extent the person has control of the child, including having overall responsibility for the child and making:omajor decisions relating to who the child spends time with and the child’s health, education, discipline, recreational and/or social activities, andoarrangements for others to meet the needs of the child (delegated care).·To what extent the person meets the needs of the child by providing the child with accommodation, clothing, food, child care, education, health care, emotional support, supervision, transport and extra-curricular activities.·To what extent the person pays for the costs of meeting the needs of the child.·To what extent the person otherwise provides financial support for the child.·To what extent the child provides for his or her own needs or has those needs met from another source.·To what extent the child is financially independent or financially supported from another source.The same section of the Guide observes that a care period is ‘generally a 12-month period from the day on which the actual care of a child began or changed’; but recognises that a shorter or longer period may be appropriate, depending upon the circumstances.EVIDENCEAt the hearing, BJJL stated that she was a ‘sole parent in terms of decision-making’ in respect of M. She explained that she and M have lived on the top floor of the property since her separation from TMQT, with whom they have little interaction. BJJL stated that contact with M was controlled in accordance with an intervention order, until M turned 18.BJJL stated that she has a joint bank account with TMQT, and accepted that the primary source of funds was TMQT’s wages. BJJL stated that she gained employment in January 2020, and her wages went into a separate account. She was stood down from her position in March 2020 and made redundant in July, moving onto JobSeeker. BJJL acknowledged the receipt of child support payments from TMQT.BJJL stated that she paid for a number of household outgoings: rates and water ‘in full’; a Wi-Fi connection; house insurance, paid in July 2021; and shopping and food.BJJL also stated that she had care of M and paid for her necessities, particularly specialist medical treatment for M’s mental health, and accompanied M to these appointments. She stated that she provided emotional and financial support for M, and also paid for a 6-month course of study between February and July 2020. M left school at a point in 2019.TMQT stated that he was in work and paid to keep a roof over the family’s head. He stated that he kept up the mortgage payments, and paid for electricity and water. TMQT stated that the rates were split between them, acknowledging that BJJL had paid for one quarter.TMQT stated that he also paid for internet service at the house, and that he paid for registration of M’s car. He described his relationship with M as ‘tricky’ due the presence of BJJL. TMQT stated that the intervention order commenced in September or October 2021, and is in place until September 2022.TMQT acknowledged that BJJL undertook food shopping, but stated that he also provided ‘refills’ on a weekly basis. I asked for clarification of the living arrangements and TMQT stated that the parties share the single kitchen in the property, as well as a single laundry. There is a single fridge, pantry and set of cupboards, and he makes his contribution when he accesses the upper floor.TMQT also stated in evidence that he had provided payments of child support during the separation, and that BJJL’s solicitors had proposed that she contribute toward the rates. At the hearing, the representative of the Registrar referred to the summary of facts contained in the Respondent’s SFIC at [4]–[13]. This material includes summaries of information provided to the Registrar by the parties on various instances between May 2020 and June 2020. The key issues raised in evidence at the hearing appear to be consistent with the summary of information provided to the Registrar. CONSIDERATIONThe Respondent’s SFIC submits that the following matters require determination: the care period; whether either or both parents had a pattern of care; and, if so, what percentage of care corresponds with the actual care.I consider that it is appropriate to determine the percentage of care in this matter on the basis that there has been a pattern of care in respect of the parties, under s 50 of the Act. I consider the relevant care period in this case commenced upon the separation, which is accepted as 25 October 2019. I note that M turned 18 on 6 October 2020, and was not in full time study, and I consider it appropriate to determine the care period ceased on 5 October 2020.There is no dispute in this matter that primary and direct personal care of M lay with BJJL. The existence of an intervention order (about which I had no documentary evidence) reinforces the fact that TMQT did not exercise decision-making authority even, as I understand the evidence, through consultation with BJJL.The critical issue is the balancing of this fact with the varying financial contributions to the household. The evidence at hearing appears to have added some important context, being that the physical separation under the one roof is perhaps not as stark as might have been presumed. That is, while interpersonal encounters are infrequent, or perhaps, non-existent, the house is a shared space.The evidence also indicates that the contribution to daily necessities, specifically food, is shared, albeit that the respective contributions are somewhat unclear. I accept that the material lodged with, and oral evidence given to, the Tribunal point to payments for the household coming from the joint account; and the evidence also demonstrates that the sole contributor to that account was TMQT. The evidence demonstrates, to my satisfaction, that a significant financial contribution to M’s welfare was made throughout by TMQT.I also accept that BJJL was in employment for some months, and accordingly her personal financial contribution to M’s welfare should be understood as having increased as a consequence. There is no significant dispute here, either, that there were certain payments made toward the household by BJJL. However, I do not consider this period of employment to be a significant enough change in the affairs of the household to represent a change in the pattern of care. Accordingly, taking into account the evidence overall, I consider that the appropriate percentage of care determinations are as follows: BJJL, 51%; TMQT, 49%.DECISIONFor the reasons given, the Tribunal decides to set aside the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Tribunal dated 25 August 2020, and substitutes it with a decision that the percentage of care for M between 25 October 2019 and 5 October 2020 is 51% to BJJL and 49% to TMQT. I certify that the preceding 28 (twenty -eight) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member ...[sgd]....................................................................AssociateDated: 27 August 2021 Date of hearing: 27 July 2021 Applicant: By telephone Advocate for the Respondent: Tim Noonan Solicitors for the Respondent: Services Australia Other Party: By telephone

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate care period for the purposes of determining the percentage of care under the Child Support Act?
2. Whether either or both parents had a pattern of care?
3. If a pattern of care exists, what percentage of care corresponds with the actual care?
4. To what extent does the intervention order impact the determination of the percentage of care?
5. How should the shared financial contributions to the household be factored into the percentage of care determination?
6. Whether the period of employment by BJJL was significant enough to represent a change in the pattern of care?
7. What is the appropriate percentage of care determination for BJJL and TMQT based on the evidence presented?

Held
1. The appropriate care period for determining the percentage of care under the Child Support Act is from 25 October 2019 to 5 October 2020.
2. Both parents had a pattern of care, with BJJL providing primary and direct personal care of M.
3. The percentage of care that corresponds with the actual care is 51% for BJJL and 49% for TMQT.
4. The intervention order did not impact the determination of the percentage of care.
5. The shared financial contributions to the household were factored into the percentage of care determination.
6. The period of employment by BJJL was not significant enough to represent a change in the pattern of care.
7. The appropriate percentage of care determination for BJJL and TMQT based on the evidence presented is 51% for BJJL and 49% for TMQT.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court was tasked with determining the percentage of care under the Child Support Act in a case involving parents who remained under one roof post-separation but had little interaction. The appropriate care period was established as starting on the date of separation, 25 October 2019, and ending on 5 October 2020 when the child turned 18. The Court applied the principle from the Child Support Guide that the care period could be shorter or longer than 12 months depending on the circumstances, and in this case, the period until the child turned 18 was deemed appropriate.

In assessing whether there was a pattern of care, the Court considered the extent of each parent's involvement in decision-making and provision of care. The Court found that despite the parents living under one roof, there was a clear distinction in their roles. BJJL was identified as having primary and direct personal care of the child, which was supported by the existence of an intervention order limiting TMQT's interactions with the child. The Court gave weight to the fact that TMQT did not exercise decision-making authority even through consultation with BJJL. This finding aligns with the legal principle that the person with primary responsibility for the child's care and major decisions has a significant pattern of care.

When determining the percentage of care, the Court balanced the fact that BJJL had primary personal care of the child with the financial contributions made by TMQT. The Court recognized that TMQT made significant financial contributions to the household, including mortgage payments, electricity, water, and car registration for the child. While BJJL also made some financial contributions, particularly during her period of employment, the Court did not consider this period long or significant enough to change the established pattern of care.

The intervention order was a critical factor in the Court's assessment. It reinforced the limited role of TMQT in the child's day-to-day care and decision-making, thereby supporting the conclusion that BJJL had a predominant pattern of care. The Court also noted that despite the physical separation under one roof, the parents shared certain household responsibilities, such as food shopping, indicating a partial overlap in their care responsibilities.

The shared financial contributions to the household were another aspect the Court considered. TMQT's contributions were deemed significant, especially given that he was the primary source of income. However, the Court found that BJJL's brief period of employment did not alter the overall pattern of care, as TMQT's financial support remained the cornerstone of the household's financial stability.

Regarding the period of employment by BJJL, the Court determined that it was not significant enough to represent a change in the pattern of care. Although BJJL contributed to the household expenses during her employment, the overall financial and care responsibilities remained predominantly with TMQT.

Finally, the Court determined the appropriate percentage of care for BJJL and TMQT based on the evidence. BJJL was awarded 51% of the care, reflecting her primary role in the child's care and decision-making, while TMQT received 49%, acknowledging his significant financial contributions and shared responsibilities in the household. The Court's decision to set aside the previous determination and substitute it with this new percentage reflects a balanced consideration of both personal care and financial contributions in accordance with the Child Support Act.