CITATION: Towry Law v Chubb Insurance [2009] NSWSC 434 HEARING DATE(S): 18/02/09 JURISDICTION: Equity
Commercial ListJUDGMENT OF: McDougall J at 1 EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 18 February 2009 DECISION: See paragraphs [37] to [41] of the judgment. CATCHWORDS: COSTS - whether costs should follow the event or follow specific issues. - COSTS - indemnity costs - whether reasonable not to accept offer of compromise - whether offer considered properly on its merits. LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act 2005 CATEGORY: Consequential orders CASES CITED: County Securities Pty Ltd v Challenger Group Holdings Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2008] NSWCA 273 PARTIES: Towry Law PLC (Plaintiff)
UKFP (Asia) HK Limited (Second Plaintiff)
Henderson Group PLC (Third Plaintiff)
Chubb Insurance Company of Europe SA (First Defendant)
CNA Insurance Company Ltd (Second Defendant)
ACE European Group Ltd (Third Defendant)
Zurich Specialties London Ltd (Fourth Defendant)
Great Lakes Reinsurance (UK) PLC (Fifth Defendant)
St Paul Travelers Casualty & Surety Company of Europe Ltd (Sixth Defendant)
New Hampshire Insurance Company (Seventh Defendant)
Bestpark International Ltd (Eighth Defendant)
The Underwriter Insurance Company Ltd (Ninth Defendant)
Wurttembergische Versicherung AG (Tenth Defendant)
Assicurazioni Generali Spa (Eleventh Defendant)
Newline Corporate Name Ltd (Twelfth Defendant)
Oak Dedicated Ltd (Thirteen Defendant) Jago Capital Ltd
(Fourteenth Defendant)
Catlin Syndicate Ltd (on its own behalf and representing all members of Lloyd's syndicate 1003) (Fifteenth Defendant)
Catlin Syndicate Ltd (on its own behalf and representing all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 2003) (Sixteenth Defendant)
RG Wasey (on his own behalf and in a representative capacity on behalf of Lloyd's Syndicate 1047)(Seventeenth Defendant)
Camperdown UK Ltd (Eighteenth Defendant) Limit (No.3) Ltd (Nineteenth Defendant)
Amlin Corporate Member Ltd (on its own behalf and representing all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 2001) (Twentieth Defendant)
SVB Syndicates Ltd (in a representative capacity on behalf of all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 1241) (Twenty First Defendant)
SVB Syndicate Ltd (in a representative capacity on behalf of all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 1007) (Twenty-Second Defendant)
ACE Underwriting Agencies Ltd (in a representative capacity on behalf of all members of Lloyds Syndicate 2488) (Twenty-Third Defendant)
Mark John Harrington (on his own and representing all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 0079) (Twenty-Fourth Defendant)
Liberty Syndicate Management Ltd (on behalf of all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 0190) (Twenty-Fifth Defendant) Dornoch Ltd (on its own and in a representative capacity of all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 1209) (Twenty-Sixth Defendant)
Old Faithful Underwriting (on its own behalf and representing all members of Lloyd's Syndicate 861) (Twenty-Seventh Defendant)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 50183/05 COUNSEL: T M Mehigan (Plaintiff)
G K J Rich (Defendants)SOLICITORS: Allens Arthur Robinson (Plaintiffs)
Deacons Lawyers (Defendants)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
COMMERCIAL LIST
McDOUGALL J
18 February 2009 (ex tempore – revised 18 February 2009)
50183/05 TOWRY LAW PLC & ORS v CHUBB INSURANCE COMPANY OF EUROPE SA & ORS
JUDGMENT (ON COSTS)
1 HIS HONOUR: On 19 October 2007, the Court ordered that certain issues (the separate questions) be decided separately and in advance of all other issues in the proceedings.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Towry Law v Chubb Insurance and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 434
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was determining the appropriate costs order in light of the settlement offer that was made and subsequently rejected. The court had to decide whether the defendant had acted unreasonably in rejecting the offer and whether the defendant had properly assessed the offer on its merits. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the costs should be allocated based on the event or apportioned according to the specific issues that were contested.
The court held that the defendant had not acted unreasonably in rejecting the settlement offer, as there were legitimate reasons for doing so. The court found that the defendant had considered the offer on its merits and had not merely refused it without proper evaluation. Consequently, the court ruled that the costs should not follow the event but should instead be apportioned according to the specific issues contested in the litigation. The court further concluded that there were no grounds to order indemnity costs, as the defendant's actions in rejecting the offer were not unreasonable.
The final orders of the court directed that the costs of the litigation be apportioned based on the specific issues contested rather than following the event. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for indemnity costs and any order that costs should follow the event. The decision underscored the importance of evaluating settlement offers on their merits and the need for careful consideration before rejecting such offers in litigation.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi