Townsend and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 843

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No Q2001/423

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE   DIVISION     )          
           Re      PHILLIP CORREY TOWNSEND
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon R N J Purvis, QC, Deputy President  

Date9 October 2001         

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The decision under review is set aside.  The matter is referred to the Respondent for further consideration and appropriate action.  Liberty to apply is reserved.          
  [Sgd] The Hon R N J Purvis Q.C.
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – citizen of New Zealand in Australia as exempt non-citizen – convicted of offences – deportation order – consideration of protection of the Australian community – best interests of children

Migration Act 1958, ss200, 201, 499

Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 90 FCR 583

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon R N J Purvis, QC, Deputy President  
the application   

  1. This is an application made on the 9 June 1999 by Mr Phillip Townsend ("the Applicant"), seeking review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural affairs ("the Respondent") made on 3 June 1999.

  2. The decision under review, the Deportation Order, was to the following effect:

    "Whereas Phillip Correy TOWNSEND is a non-citizen, who arrived in Australia on 30 December 1986.
    AND WHEREAS the said Phillip Correy TOWNSEND was convicted at the Brisbane District Court in the state of Queensland on 28 May 1993 of 'Receiving' (4 counts), 'Housebreaking' (4 counts) and 'Stealing' (5 counts) for which he was sentenced to imprisonment for a total of 3 years.
    AND WHEREAS at the time of commission of the said offences the said Phillip Correy TOWNSEND was not an Australian citizen and had been present in Australia as a permanent resident, or as a New Zealand citizen exempt non-citizen, or special category visa holder for less than ten years.
    NOW I (Vincent McMahon), a delegate of the Minister of State responsible for administering the Migration Act 1958, DO HEREBY ORDER, in pursuance of the power conferred upon me by section 200 of the Migration Act 1958, that the said Phillip Correy TOWNSEND be deported from Australia." (T1, p5)

  3. In his application for review of the decision the Applicant gave as his reasons for making the application:

    "I have fore [stet] children in this country fore [stet] beautiful reasons to stay and get my life together."  (T1, p4)

  4. On 27 September 2000 a Deputy President of the Tribunal after a hearing affirmed the decision under review.  On appeal to the Federal Court the decision of the Tribunal was set aside, the matter remitted for re-hearing by a differently constituted Tribunal.
    the hearing

  5. At the present hearing of the application, the Applicant was represented by Mr DC Rangiah of Counsel, the Respondent by Mr P O'Higgins, solicitor of Blake Dawson Waldron solicitors.

  6. The documents lodged by the Respondent pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 were admitted into evidence and marked  T1 to T33.  Written material…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Townsend and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 843
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Townsend versus Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved the Applicant, a New Zealand citizen in Australia, facing deportation following multiple convictions. The matter was brought before the court to challenge the decision to deport him, with the Applicant arguing that his deportation would cause significant hardship to his family and his children in particular. The court had to determine whether the factors supporting deportation, such as the seriousness of the Applicant's offenses, outweighed the factors against it, including the hardship his family would face.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the Minister's decision to deport the Applicant was justified under the Migration Act 1958, and whether the consideration of the best interests of the Applicant's children and the protection of the Australian community were adequately addressed. The Applicant argued that his deportation would result in substantial emotional distress for his family, particularly his children, and that he had rehabilitated himself while in custody. The Respondent contended that the seriousness of the Applicant's criminal history, including drug and property offenses, and the risk of recidivism justified the deportation order.

The court considered the various factors presented by both parties. It acknowledged that the Applicant's family would indeed experience hardship if he were deported, particularly his children who would lose a significant paternal figure in their lives. The court found that the Applicant's rehabilitation efforts and the positive impact he had on his children's lives were compelling arguments against deportation. While recognizing the severity of the Applicant's offenses, the court concluded that the risk of recidivism was not high and that the Applicant posed no significant threat to the community. The court ultimately determined that the Minister's decision did not adequately weigh the best interests of the children and the hardship to the family.

The court's decision was to overturn the Minister's deportation order, finding that the best interests of the children and the emotional hardship to the family outweighed the seriousness of the Applicant's criminal offenses. The court emphasized the importance of considering the familial ties and the role the Applicant played in the lives of his children in reaching its decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant, his sister Mrs Faye Noonan, another sister, Ms Marion Townsend, and the Applicants' former de facto wife and mother of his four children, Ms Hurst, gave oral evidence upon which they were each cross examined.the respondent's decision In a Statement of Reasons of the 12 July 1999 the then acting Deputy Secretary of the Respondent stated inter alia as the reasons for the decision to order deportation of the Applicant: "5. …Mr McMahon found the following factors weighing against the deportation:· Mr Townsend has four children living in Australia, as well as his mother and sisters;· it is in the best interests of Mr Townsend's children that their father be allowed to remain in Australia;· whilst in prison Mr Townsend has behaved himself; and· under Australia's Criminal Deportation Policy, the deportable offences committed by Mr Townsend are not considered very serious.6. Mr McMahon found that the following factors weighed in favour of deportation:· Subsequent offences committed by Mr Townsend such as the most recent of 'produce dangerous drugs' are considered to be very serious under Australia's Criminal Deportation Policy;· most of Mr Townsend's childhood was spent in New Zealand;· at the time of commission of the deportable offence, Mr Townsend had only five years, one month and twenty seven days lawful permanent residence in Australia; Relevant provisions of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act") are:"200 Deportation of certain non-citizens The Minister may order the deportation of a non-citizen to whom this Division applies.201 Deportation of non-citizens in Australia for less then ten years who are convicted of crimesWhere: (a) a person who is a non-citizen has, either before or after the commencement of this section, been convicted in Australia of an offence; (b) when the offence was committed the person was a non-citizen who: (i) had been in Australia as a permanent resident: (A) for a period of less than 10 years; or (B) for periods that, when added together, total less than 10 years; or (ii) was a citizen of New Zealand who had been in Australia as an exempt non-citizen or a special category visa holder: (A) for a period of less than 10 years as an exempt non-citizen or a special category visa holder; or (B) for periods that, when added together, total less than 10 years, as an exempt non-citizen or a special category visa holder or in any combination of those capacities; and (c) the offence is an offence for which the person was sentenced to death or to imprisonment for life or for a period of not less than one year; section 200 applies to the person." Section 499 of the Act enables the Minister to give written Directions to a person or body having functions or powers under the Act, provided that the Directions are about the performance of those functions or the exercise of those powers. The Directions are not to be inconsistent with the Act or Regulations under which they are made and a person or body to whom the Directions are directed is required to comply with them.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal is satisfied that the children would experience considerable hardship in the event of their father being deported and that it is in their best interests for him to remain in Australia and increasingly become significant as a meaningful factor in their lives.other relevant considerationshardship to the applicant On behalf of the Respondent it is said, that he would be unlikely to suffer any significant hardship if he were to be deported to New Zealand. He does not have an ongoing marital or de facto relationship, his formative years were spent in New Zealand, he was only resident in Australia for just over five years at the time of the commission of his deportable offences and he has few non-family ties with Australia. It is acknowledged that he does however have strong ties to his family in Australia. On the other hand he has no contact with relatives or friends in New Zealand and the prospect of his abstaining from the use of drugs is significantly higher if he remains in Australia. He has resided in this country since the age of 14. He has a significant meaningful relationship with his four children.hardship to others Mention has already been made of the close family ties existing between the Applicant, his mother and at least two of his sisters, Mrs Noonan and Ms Townsend. Each of them in their evidence before the Tribunal has acknowledged the noticeable improvement in the Applicant of recent years and the bonding between members of the family. On behalf of the Respondent it was said and recognised that the Applicant's family will undoubtedly suffer emotional distress if the deportation order is affirmed. It was submitted however that emotional distress does not amount to hardship. There will not been an adverse financial effect upon them. The Tribunal is not satisfied that the Direction is aimed solely at non-emotive hardship. Depravation of family bonding can well constitute hardship. The Tribunal is satisfied that in the event of the Applicant being deported, members of his family would experience measurable emotional distress, the same impacting on their lives. submissions and decision The Respondent maintains that the seriousness of the deportable offences and the other offences of which the Applicant has been convicted, the same including drug and property offences, with an alleged significant risk of recidivism and a lack of contribution to the Australian community, should be given significant weight in favour of deportation. On the other hand it is suggested that the Tribunal "treat cautiously" other considerations instancing the limited nature and extent of the relationship between the Applicant and the children, the negative role model he provided with Ms Hurst, his separation from Ms Hurst and his lack of financial means. The Tribunal notes the submissions made, but is of the opinion that there is not a high risk of recidivism in the Applicant. The Tribunal finds that the Applicant has been rehabilitated so far as is possible in a correctional/detention environment and acknowledges the frustration that lead him to behave in the manner earlier indicated. He may well be a desperate man, but desperate in the sense of seeking to play a significant part in the lives of his children and redirect his own manner of living and working. The Tribunal does not see the community being at risk from the Applicant.