Administrative Appeals Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2011] AATA 832
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No 2010/4903
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re Roderick Towers Applicant
And
Optus Administration Pty Ltd
Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No 2010/4825;
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) 2010/5109 Re John Phillips Applicant
And
Thales Australia Limited
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Senior Member A K Britton Date24 November 2011
PlaceSydney
Decision 1. The application made by each respondent for orders under s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) that they not be required to provide to the applicant a copy of the “surveillance material” until such time as it has had an opportunity to cross-examine the applicant, or until further order of the Tribunal, is granted.
2. The application made by each respondent for an order under s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) that it not be required to disclose to the applicant the existence of the “surveillance material” until such time as it has had an opportunity to cross-examine the applicant is refused.
3. Order 2 does not take effect until 29 November 2011 in the matter of Towers and Optus Administration Pty Ltd (2010/4903) and, 8 December 2011 in the matter of Phillips and Thales Australia Limited (2010/4825; 2010/ 5109).
4. This decision is not to be provided to the applicant in Towers and Optus Administration Pty Ltd (2010/4903) before 29 November 2011 and the applicant in Phillips and Thales Australia Limited (2010/4825; 2010/ 5109) before 8 December 2011. Further publication of this decision is prohibited until 8 December 2011.
........................[sgd]......................
Senior Member A K Britton
7. Section 37 requires the decision-maker to lodge with the Tribunal and provide to each other party to proceedings every document in their possession or control that is relevant to the review of the decision before the Tribunal, within 28 days after receiving notice of an application for review to the Tribunal, or such other period as determined by the Tribunal (s 37(1)). The surveillance material is apparently relevant to each reviewable decision and therefore falls within the scope of s 37(1).
8. Section 37(1AF) provides that a document that falls within the scope of s 37(1) need not be lodged with the Tribunal in certain circumstances:
When document not required to be lodged
(1AF) If:
(a) a person who has made a decision that is the subject of an application for a review by the Tribunal would, apart from this subsection, be required under paragraph (1)(b) to lodge 2 copies of a document or a part of a document with the Tribunal in respect of the application; and
(b) within the period applicable under subsection (1) the person:
(i) applies to the Tribunal for a direction under subsection 35(2) in relation to the document or part of the document and lodges with the Tribunal, together with the application for the direction, 2 copies of the document or part of the document; and
(ii) gives a copy of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Towers and Anor and Optus Administration Pty Ltd and Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] AATA 832
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the AAT involved the balance between the procedural fairness to the respondents and the need for the applicants to have access to evidence in administrative proceedings. The respondents contended that they should not be required to disclose the surveillance material until they had an opportunity to cross-examine the applicants, as this would allow them to challenge the material's relevance and reliability. The applicants argued that such a delay in disclosure would unfairly impede their ability to prepare their case.
The AAT found that while the respondents were entitled to procedural fairness, the applicants' right to a fair hearing also needed to be considered. The tribunal granted the respondents' application to withhold the actual surveillance material until cross-examination, as this would allow the respondents to challenge the material's admissibility and relevance. However, the AAT refused the respondents' application to withhold the existence of the surveillance material, as this would unduly hinder the applicants' ability to prepare their case. The AAT also imposed conditions on the disclosure of the decision to prevent premature publication, ensuring that the applicants received notice of the decision at an appropriate time.
The final orders included granting the respondents' application for withholding the surveillance material until cross-examination and prohibiting premature disclosure of the decision. The AAT carefully balanced the rights of both parties, ensuring that the respondents' procedural fairness was protected without unduly delaying the applicants' ability to prepare their case. The specific timelines for the disclosure of the decision were also set to prevent premature publication, ensuring that both parties could adequately prepare for the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application made by each respondent for orders under s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) that they not be required to provide to the applicant a copy of the “surveillance material” until such time as it has had an opportunity to cross-examine the applicant, or until further order of the Tribunal, is granted.
2. The application made by each respondent for an order under s 35 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) that it not be required to disclose to the applicant the existence of the “surveillance material” until such time as it has had an opportunity to cross-examine the applicant is refused.
3. Order 2 does not take effect until 29 November 2011 in the matter of Towers and Optus Administration Pty Ltd (2010/4903) and, 8 December 2011 in the matter of Phillips and Thales Australia Limited (2010/4825; 2010/ 5109).
4. This decision is not to be provided to the applicant in Towers and Optus Administration Pty Ltd (2010/4903) before 29 November 2011 and the applicant in Phillips and Thales Australia Limited (2010/4825; 2010/ 5109) before 8 December 2011. Further publication of this decision is prohibited until 8 December 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi