Tova Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Tova Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council [2004] NSWLEC 282
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
Tova Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT
Parramatta City Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 11545 of 2003
CORAM: Bly C
KEY ISSUES: Development Application :- Demolition of heritage listed cottage
LEGISLATION CITED: Environmental Planning and Assessment Act; s 97
CASES CITED:
DATES OF HEARING: 26/03/2004 and 14/05/2004
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 06/09/2004
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT
Mr M Campbell, barrister
SOLICITORS
Matthews Folbigg Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT
Mr J Johnson, barrister
SOLICITORS
Storey & Gough



JUDGMENT:


    IN THE LAND AND
    ENVIRONMENT COURT
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES

    11545 of 2003 Bly C 9 June 2004

    Tova Pty Ltd
    Applicant

    v Parramatta City Council
    Respondent Judgment

    Introduction

    1 . This appeal relates to a development application for the demolition of an existing heritage item comprising a cottage prominently sited in the centre of the large site being 328 Woodville Road, Guildford. The building has recently been damaged by fire and vandalism.

    Statutory provisions

    2 . The whole of the site, being the cottage and its grounds, is a listed heritage item under the provisions of Parramatta Local Environmental Plan 1996 (Heritage and Conservation) ("the heritage LEP") and development consent is required for demolition. The site is also subject to council's Development Control Plan - Heritage ("the DCP") .

    The issues

    3. The identified issues in the case are whether the demolition of the cottage is warranted, taking into account:
          (a) the structural adequacy of the heritage item.
          (b) the heritage significance of the item in its present state; and

    The evidence

    4 . On behalf of the respondent council expert evidence was given by:
          • Miss J. Somerville – architect and heritage specialist,
          • Mr S. Wiltshier – structural engineer,
          • Mr A. Caledine – town planner

    5 . On behalf of the applicant expert evidence was given by:
          • Mr N. Ghosn – structural engineer
          • Miss G. Cowell – architect and heritage specialist

    Structural adequacy

    6 . Mr S. Wiltshier the respondent's structural engineer inspected the building and formed the conclusion that the majority of the heritage listed component of the building is, notwithstanding fire damage, structurally sound. Where elements of the building are unsound they are readily repairable or replaceable using conventional building techniques. He acknowledged that there are currently potentially unstable components of the building, referring in particular to the unsecured roof. However this could be rendered reasonably safe with some fairly simple temporary remedial works. He did not accept that the damage caused to the building by fire and general deterioration was sufficient to warrant demolition on the basis of structural unsoundness.

    7 . Conversely, Mr N Ghosn the applicant's structural engineer having inspected the building concluded that the existing damaged timber frame of the building is not structurally adequate to support the roof and the walls. He pointed out that many frame members have been reduced in size or even completely burned down. Wind bracing units in the walls and tie-down connections between the roof and wall…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tova Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWLEC 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tova Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council, heard by the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, involved an appeal against the refusal of a development application for the demolition of a heritage-listed cottage located at 328 Woodville Road, Guildford. The cottage had been damaged by fire and vandalism, prompting the application for demolition. The central issues in the case were whether the structural adequacy of the cottage and its heritage significance justified its demolition.

The court considered expert evidence from both parties regarding the structural integrity of the cottage. The respondent's structural engineer, Mr. Wiltshier, concluded that the cottage, despite some damage, was structurally sound and repairable. In contrast, the applicant's engineer, Mr. Ghosn, argued that the damage was severe enough to warrant demolition. The court found that the cottage could be restored using conventional techniques, and thus, its structural condition did not justify demolition.

Regarding the heritage significance, the court noted that the cottage was listed under the Parramatta Local Environmental Plan 1996 (Heritage and Conservation) and the Development Control Plan - Heritage. Both heritage experts agreed on the significance of the cottage but differed on whether its preservation was feasible after the fire damage. The respondent's expert, Miss Somerville, argued that conservation efforts would maintain the cottage's historical significance, while the applicant's expert, Miss Cowell, believed that extensive reconstruction would effectively be a re-creation, diminishing the building's historical value. The court concluded that the necessary repairs and reconstruction could be carried out in a manner consistent with conservation practices, preserving the cottage's significant attributes.

Ultimately, the court decided that the cottage could be conserved and utilized in a manner that respects its heritage value. The appeal for demolition was dismissed, and development consent for the demolition was refused. The court ordered that the appeal be dismissed and that the development application be refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.