Tou's Garden Pty Ltd v Redline Automotive

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

CITATION:Tou’s Garden Pty Ltd v Redline Automotive [2010] NTMC 038

PARTIES:TOU’S GARDEN PTY LTD

v

DERRECK FRANZ SPERRER T/AS REDLINE AUTOMOTIVE

TITLE OF COURT:  Local Court

JURISDICTION:  Small Claims

FILE NO(s):20938319

DELIVERED ON:  26 May 2010

DELIVERED AT:  Darwin

HEARING DATE(s):  25 May 2010

JUDGMENT OF:  J Johnson A/JR

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR VEHICLE – COST OF REPAIRS – MUST NOT BE EXTRAVAGANT OR UNREASONABLE

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:Mr Quin

Defendant:Mr Sperrer

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:N/A

Defendant:N/A

Judgment category classification:        C

Judgment ID number:  [2010] NTMC 038

Number of paragraphs:  21


IN THE LOCAL COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN

TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 20938319

BETWEEN:

TOU’S GARDEN PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND:

DERRECK FRANZ SPERRER T/AS REDLINE AUTOMOTIVE

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 26 May 2010)

Mr J JOHNSON A/JR

The Issue Stated

  1. In September 2008 the plaintiff entrusted the repair of a Volkswagen Caravelle (“the vehicle”) to the defendant automotive repair business. The vehicle is relatively aged, being a 1985 year model with 222,778 kilometres on its odometer and, I am told in evidence by the defendant automotive repairer, is unusual in that it has a water-cooled engine. The vehicle was ultimately repaired by the defendant for a total tax invoiced cost of $7,478.46.

  2. The plaintiff has paid $2,000.00 by way of “deposit” for the repair work thereby leaving $5,478.46 in outstanding payment due. The plaintiff takes exception to the total cost of repair and asserts in its Statement of Claim that “The defendant failed in their duty of care to contain costs in the repair”.

  3. So it is that an impasse has arisen between the parties: the vehicle remains in the possession of the defendant pending payment of the outstanding cost of repairs; and the plaintiff claims the return of the vehicle subject to payment of a lesser amount of $3,067.48 against the outstanding amount of $5,478.46.

    The Law

  4. In Stocovazv Fung [2007] NSWCA 199, Handley AJA observed, inter alia,  (and with references omitted) that:

    36. The claimant submitted that the answers to questions 2(i) and 2(ii) were inconsistent. Considered in isolation this may appear to be the case. However the questions and answers must be read with his Honour’s reasons for judgment. His Honour treatedextravagant and unreasonable as synonymous in this context. This was also the understanding of Dr Lushington in The Pactolus (1856) Swab 173,  which his Honour referred to. Ever since courts and commentators have treatedextravagant and unreasonable in this context as interchangeable. The authorities and texts which establish this are summarised in his Honour’s judgment.

    37. In my judgment the answers to question 2 can be reconciled when one bears in mind that there may not be a single fair and reasonable cost for repairing a damaged motor vehicle, especially a Mercedes costing $95,563 new. There is likely to be a range of costs all of which are fair and reasonable. In such a case acceptable evidence that a lower cost would be fair and reasonable cannot of itself establish that a higher cost was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tou's Garden Pty Ltd v Redline Automotive and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NTMC 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tou's Garden Pty Ltd sought relief from Redline Automotive, a vehicle repair service, in the Federal Circuit Court over the cost of repairs to a vehicle engine. The plaintiff argued that the cost of repairs charged by the defendant was extravagant and unreasonable. Tou's Garden contended that the defendant charged excessive labour hours to remove the engine, that the hourly rate charged was too high, and that the mechanics were unsupervised, affecting productivity. Tou's Garden offered to pay $3,067.48 against the $5,478.46 billed by Redline Automotive. Redline Automotive defended the charges, stating that the engine had significant corrosion and that the repair process was complex due to the engine's condition. The defendant argued that the plaintiff had been charged for only 14 out of approximately 24.6 hours of work and that the total cost of repairs, including GST and other fees, amounted to $1,602.70.

The court needed to decide whether the cost of repairs charged by Redline Automotive to Tou's Garden was extravagant or unreasonable. The plaintiff had to prove that the cost was "outside the range" and therefore "extravagant or unreasonable." Tou's Garden relied on three main arguments to support its claim: excessive labour hours, an overcharged hourly rate, and poor supervision of mechanics. The defendant, on the other hand, presented evidence of significant engine corrosion and provided a detailed breakdown of the hours spent on the repair process. The court had to determine if the evidence provided by Tou's Garden was sufficient to prove that the cost of repairs was extravagant or unreasonable.

The court found that Tou's Garden had not proven that the cost of repairs was extravagant or unreasonable. The court noted that the plaintiff had not provided sufficient evidence to support its claims regarding excessive labour hours, an overcharged hourly rate, and poor supervision of mechanics. The court also found that the defendant had provided evidence of significant engine corrosion and a detailed breakdown of the hours spent on the repair process, which supported the defendant's charges. The court concluded that the plaintiff had not met its burden of proof and that the cost of repairs charged by Redline Automotive was not extravagant or unreasonable. The court dismissed Tou's Garden's claim and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In my view therefore the plaintiff must prove, on the ordinary civil standard of persuasion, that the subject cost of repair is “outside the range” and, thereby, “extravagant or unreasonable”, albeit that in this context those words are “interchangeable”.The Evidence The thrust of the plaintiff’s argument as to the cost of repairs being “outside the range” founded upon 3 principal assertions. These were, firstly, that the defendant had charged 14 hours labour to “remove engine, strip, inspect and quote” (exhibit “D4”). This, in the plaintiff’s submission, was an “error of judgement”. The defendant ought to have recognised at a very early stage that the engine was beyond economic repair and it was “extravagant” to incur that amount of labour to arrive at such an explicitly obvious conclusion. Secondly, the plaintiff asserted that the hourly rate charged by the defendant ($85.00 per hour) was “too expensive” and offered in support that a specialist diesel engine repair service which he utilised in the course of his business charged only $80.00 per hour for an arguably more specialised and complex engine repair service. Thirdly, the plaintiff attempted to establish that during the repair period the defendant’s mechanics were largely “unsupervised” and that their “effectiveness” or “productivity” was, thereby, questionable. The argument proceeded, as I understood it, upon assertion that the defendant was absent for a significant part of the repair period; that he employed mechanics on so-called “457 Visas”; and that the repairs were used as a “filler job to book hours to”. The sub-class 457 visa program is, as I understand it, the most commonly used program for employers to sponsor overseas workers to work in Australia on a temporary basis. The plaintiff, by vehicle of its Statement of Claim, offers to pay $3,067.48 against the outstanding cost of $5,478.46. The methodology for arriving at that figure is detailed in a letter to the defendant dated 2 August 2009 (not exhibited). The plaintiff subsequently made a further offer of compromise to the defendant but the defendant has stood firm in its demand for payment of the “documented” cost of repairs. The defendant’s evidence was that, upon inspection, the subject engine exhibited significant corrosion and a “weeping head”. This was said to have been caused by poor attention to coolant and coolant system maintenance and, because the engine had aluminium “blocks” and “heads” held by steel “studs”, this resulted in significant aluminium oxidisation of the blocks and heads and corrosion of the steel studs. Thus it was very difficult to remove the engine and strip it down for the purpose of assessing its reparability. In support of this contention the defendant put into evidence a copy of the Jobcard for the repair showing a breakdown of the total number of hours (by date and time) spent in removing, dismantling and inspecting the engine (exhibit “D3”). As I understood that evidence, the actual time spent (after allowing for meal breaks) was in the vicinity 24.6 hours but the plaintiff had only been charged for 14 of those hours (exhibit “D4”). At the end of that process the defendant issued the plaintiff with a Tax Invoice which, when ultimately amended, amounted to $1,602.70 including, inter alia, GST, towage fees, and the 14 hours labour.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established