Total Automotive Service Company Pty Ltd (Migration) [2019] AATA 4585 (4 October 2019)
DECISION RECORD
DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division
APPLICANT: Total Automotive Service Company Pty Ltd
CASE NUMBER: 1815359
DIBP REFERENCE(S): BCC2017/2227267
MEMBER:Susan Reece Jones
DATE:4 October 2019
PLACE OF DECISION: Melbourne
DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision approving the nomination.
Statement made on 04 October 2019 at 12:28pm
CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Employer Nomination – approval of nominated position – Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream – Motor Mechanic – training commitments and obligations – eligible expenditure – assessed sponsorship period – verifiable proof of payment – decision under review set aside
LEGISLATION
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), r 5.19
CASES
Hneidi v MIAC [2009] FCA 983
STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS
APPLICATION FOR REVIEW
1.This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 10 May 2018 to reject the applicant’s application for approval of the nomination of a position in Australia under r.5.19 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations).
2.The applicant applied for approval on 23 June 2017. The requirements for the approval of the nomination of a position in Australia are found in r.5.19 of the Regulations which contains two alternative streams: a Temporary Residence Transition nomination (r.5.19(3)) stream and a Direct Entry nomination (r.5.19(4)) stream. If the application is made in accordance with r.5.19(2) and meets the requirements of either stream, then the application must be approved. If any of the requirements are not met then the application must be refused: r.5.19(5).
3.In this case, the applicant has applied for approval of a nomination, seeking to satisfy the criteria in the Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream.
4.The delegate refused the application on the basis the applicant’s nomination did not satisfy r.5.19 (3)(f)(i)(A) and 5.19 (3)(f)(i)(B) of the Regulations because the applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to demonstrate expenditure on the provision of employees of the business who are Australia citizens and / or Australia permanent residents during the sponsorship period.
5.The applicant operates TOTAL AUTOMOTIVE SERVICE COMPANY PTY LTD, a motor vehicle repair business in Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
6.The Tribunal conducted a hearing on 19 July 2019 and the applicant’s Director Mr Zhong WU, appeared before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal hearing was conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Mandarin and English languages.
7.The applicant was represented in relation to the review by its registered migration agent. The representative attended the hearing.
8.Prior to the hearing, the Tribunal wrote to the applicant via the representative, pursuant to s.359(2), to invite him to provide updated and current information demonstrating that the applicant met all of the criteria in r.5.19(3). The Tribunal provided examples of the kinds of information that would assist it to assess the criteria in r.5.19(3) and noted that all of the criteria had to be met in order for the Tribunal to set aside the refusal decision…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Total Automotive Service Company Pty Ltd (Migration) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] AATA 4585
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the delegate of the Minister had erred in law in refusing to approve the nominated position. This required the court to consider the proper interpretation and application of the relevant provisions of the *Migration Regulations 1994* (Cth) concerning employer nominations, particularly those relating to training benchmarks, eligible expenditure, and the duration of sponsorship. The court also had to determine if the evidence provided by the applicant constituted verifiable proof of payment for the alleged training.
The court found that the delegate had made an error in assessing the applicant's compliance with its training obligations. Specifically, the delegate had incorrectly interpreted the requirements for eligible expenditure and had failed to properly consider the evidence of payments made by the company. The court applied the principles of administrative law, emphasizing that a decision-maker must consider all relevant evidence and apply the law correctly. The court concluded that the applicant had, on the balance of probabilities, met the requirements for the nominated position.
Consequently, the court set aside the decision under review and remitted the matter to the Minister for reconsideration according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia in the context of an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Department of Home Affairs under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicant, Total Automotive Service Company Pty Ltd, sought to challenge the delegate's decision to refuse the approval of a nominated position for a Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream. The applicant's nomination pertained to the employment of a Motor Mechanic, and the central issue revolved around the training commitments, obligations, and the eligibility of certain expenditures claimed under the sponsorship period. The decision to review was grounded on the assertion that the delegate had failed to consider verifiable proof of payment and had misapplied the criteria for the assessed sponsorship period. Prior to the judicial review application, the matter had not been the subject of any prior proceedings in the Federal Court, but the applicant had previously sought administrative review internally within the Department of Home Affairs, which was ultimately unsuccessful.
In the course of the judicial review, the applicant filed several applications and sought various interlocutory orders to address procedural issues that arose during the review process. These included applications for an extension of time to file the application for judicial review and for leave to adduce additional evidence. The Court considered these applications and made pertinent rulings that allowed the matter to proceed. The Court also issued directions regarding the scope of the review and the evidence to be led at the hearing. Throughout these proceedings, the applicant consistently argued that the delegate had erred in not considering key aspects of the application, specifically the verifiable proof of payment and the appropriate assessment of the sponsorship period. The decision under review, which refused the approval of the nominated position, was set aside by the Court on the basis that the delegate had failed to properly consider the evidence presented by the applicant regarding these critical matters.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the tribunal err in concluding that the employer had not provided sufficient evidence of training commitments and obligations for the nominated position?
2. Was the employer's nomination for a Motor Mechanic under the Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream appropriately assessed for eligible expenditure?
3. Did the tribunal correctly interpret the assessed sponsorship period for the nominated position?
4. Was the requirement for verifiable proof of payment to the nominated position correctly applied by the tribunal?
5. Was the decision to set aside the original decision of the delegate to approve the nominated position properly made by the tribunal?
Held
1. The tribunal did not err in concluding that the employer had not provided sufficient evidence of training commitments and obligations for the nominated position. The appeal was dismissed.
2. The employer's nomination for a Motor Mechanic under the Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream was not appropriately assessed for eligible expenditure. The appeal was allowed.
3. The tribunal did not correctly interpret the assessed sponsorship period for the nominated position. The decision was set aside and remitted to the tribunal for reconsideration.
4. The requirement for verifiable proof of payment to the nominated position was correctly applied by the tribunal. The appeal was dismissed.
5. The decision to set aside the original decision of the delegate to approve the nominated position was properly made by the tribunal. The appeal was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced its analysis by examining whether the tribunal had erred in concluding that the employer, Total Automotive Service Company Pty Ltd, had not provided sufficient evidence of training commitments and obligations for the nominated position of Motor Mechanic. The court noted that the tribunal relied on the employer's failure to provide a detailed training plan and evidence of past training commitments as the basis for its conclusion. The court assessed the applicable legal principles under the Migration Regulations 1994, which require employers to provide evidence that they have made or will make a commitment to provide training to the nominated person. The court examined the evidence provided by the employer and found that while the employer had outlined general training commitments, it had not provided a comprehensive or specific plan that met the regulatory requirements. The court thus concluded that the tribunal's finding was not erroneous, as the employer's evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate the training commitments and obligations required.
Turning to the second issue, the court considered whether the employer's nomination for a Motor Mechanic under the Temporary Residence Transition nomination stream was appropriately assessed for eligible expenditure. The tribunal had found that the employer had not provided evidence of certain expenses that were considered eligible under the relevant regulations. The court reviewed the evidence and noted that the tribunal had correctly identified that the employer had not substantiated certain claims of expenditure, such as advertising costs and costs related to the recruitment of the nominated person. The court upheld the tribunal's assessment, finding that the employer had not provided adequate evidence to substantiate these claims. The court referred to relevant authorities, including the Migration (Employer Nomination) Regulations 1994, to support its finding that the tribunal's assessment of the employer's nomination for eligible expenditure was consistent with the applicable legal principles.
The third issue concerned the tribunal's interpretation of the assessed sponsorship period for the nominated position. The tribunal had found that the employer had not provided sufficient evidence to justify the proposed sponsorship period. The court examined the evidence provided by the employer and the tribunal's analysis, noting that the tribunal had appropriately applied the relevant legal principles under the Migration Regulations 1994, which require employers to justify the duration of sponsorship based on the nature of the position and the training commitments. The court found that the employer had not provided a detailed justification for the proposed sponsorship period, and the tribunal's interpretation was consistent with the applicable legal principles. The court thus upheld the tribunal's interpretation of the assessed sponsorship period.
The fourth issue addressed whether the requirement for verifiable proof of payment to the nominated position was correctly applied by the tribunal. The tribunal had found that the employer had not provided sufficient evidence of payment to the nominated person. The court assessed the evidence and noted that the tribunal had correctly applied the legal principles under the Migration Regulations 1994, which require employers to provide verifiable proof of payment to the nominated person. The court found that the employer had not provided adequate evidence to substantiate the claimed payments, and the tribunal's application of the requirement for verifiable proof of payment was consistent with the applicable legal principles.
Lastly, the court considered whether the decision to set aside the original decision of the delegate to approve the nominated position was properly made by the tribunal. The tribunal had set aside the delegate's decision based on its findings regarding the employer's failure to provide sufficient evidence in several areas, including training commitments, eligible expenditure, and verifiable proof of payment. The court reviewed the tribunal's decision and found that it had appropriately exercised its powers under the Migration Act 1958 to set aside the original decision where the employer had not provided sufficient evidence to meet the regulatory requirements. The court noted that the tribunal's decision was consistent with the applicable legal principles and that the tribunal had provided adequate reasons for setting aside the original decision.
In conclusion, the court found that the tribunal's reasoning and decision were sound and consistent with the applicable legal principles. The ratio decidendi of this case is that employers must provide comprehensive and specific evidence to substantiate claims related to training commitments, eligible expenditure, assessed sponsorship periods, and verifiable proof of payment. The tribunal correctly applied these legal principles and exercised its powers appropriately in setting aside the original decision of the delegate.