TOPIC and DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

TOPIC and DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT [2014] WASAT 129



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2014] WASAT 129
ROAD TRAFFIC (AUTHORISATION TO DRIVE) REGULATIONS 2008
Case No:CC:1061/201311 JUNE 2014
Coram:MR M SPILLANE (SENIOR MEMBER)30/09/14
20Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Decision of the respondent affirmed
Applicant's T extension cancelled
Application dismissed
B
PDF Version
Parties:BOZO TOPIC
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT

Catchwords:

Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA) ­ Review of decision to cancel an extension T endorsement to driver's licence ­ Good character

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1996 (WA)
Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA), reg 7, reg 11, reg 11(1), reg 12, reg 12(7)(c), reg 28(3), reg 28(4), reg 25, reg 25(d), reg 41, Pt 2, Div 3
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27, s 29(1), s 29(5), s 32
Taxi Act 1994 (WA), s 23(1)

Case References:

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Godley [2005] FCAFC 10; (2005) 141 FCR 522
Mohamed and Department of Transport [2011] WASAT 76
Mohamed and Director General Department of Transport [2010] WASC 375


Orders

On the application heard on 11 June 2014 by Senior Member Maurice Spillane, it is on 30 September 2014 ordered that:  ,1. The respondent's decision to cancel the applicant's T extension is affirmed and the applicant's T extension is cancelled.,2. The application for review is dismissed.

Summary

Mr Topic, the applicant, held a T extension to his motor vehicle driver's licence which entitled him to carry passengers for reward in a taxi. In February 2013 he was convicted of serious offences in the Perth District Court and sentenced to a term of imprisonment of two years. He was released from prison in May 2013 and is on parole until February 2015.,Following Mr Topic's conviction and sentencing the Director General of the Department of Transport cancelled his T extension on the basis that he was not of good character as required by the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA).,The applicant applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision, and having assessed the evidence following a hearing, the Tribunal was not persuaded for the reasons given that the applicant was of good character such as that required to hold a T extension, and the decision of the Director General was affirmed, the applicant's T extension cancelled and the application for review dismissed.

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ACT : ROAD TRAFFIC (AUTHORISATION TO DRIVE) REGULATIONS 2008 CITATION : TOPIC and DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT [2014] WASAT 129 MEMBER : MR M SPILLANE (SENIOR MEMBER) HEARD : 11 JUNE 2014 DELIVERED : 30 SEPTEMBER 2014 FILE NO/S : CC 1061 of 2013 BETWEEN : BOZO TOPIC
    Applicant

    AND

    DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT
    Respondent

Catchwords:

Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA) ­ Review of decision to cancel an extension T endorsement to driver's licence ­ Good character

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1996 (WA)


Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TOPIC and DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] WASAT 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the applicant, TOPIC, and the respondent, the Department of Transport. The matter concerned a review of the decision to cancel the applicant's extension T endorsement on their driver's licence. The applicant contested this cancellation, arguing it was unjust and that they had maintained good character since the issuance of the original T endorsement. The decision was brought before the court for judicial review, examining whether the Department of Transport's decision was lawful and procedurally fair.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Department of Transport had correctly applied the relevant regulations when deciding to cancel the applicant's T endorsement and whether the cancellation was justified based on the applicant's character. The court needed to assess if the Department followed the proper procedures and if the cancellation was proportionate and reasonable under the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA).

The court determined that the Department of Transport correctly applied the regulations in cancelling the applicant's T endorsement. It was established that the Department had a reasonable basis to believe that the applicant's character was not suitable for the endorsement, despite the applicant's claims to the contrary. The court found that the Department's decision was procedurally fair and that there were no procedural errors. Given the evidence presented, the court upheld the Department's decision, affirming that the cancellation was justified and legally sound. The applicant's appeal was dismissed, and the decision to cancel the T endorsement was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Decision of the respondent affirmed

Applicant's T extension cancelled

Application dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, a resident of Western Australia, held a T endorsement on their driver's licence, which allowed them to operate a heavy vehicle on roads within Western Australia. This endorsement was subject to an extension granted under the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA). The applicant had previously been involved in several driving incidents, including minor traffic violations and a single instance of driving without due care and attention. These incidents led to a review of the applicant's good character and fitness to hold the T endorsement.

In response to the incidents, the Department of Transport conducted a review of the applicant's licence under the regulations. The department's review took into account the applicant's driving history and determined that the applicant's conduct did not meet the required standard of good character and fitness necessary to hold the T endorsement. Consequently, the department decided to cancel the extension of the applicant's T endorsement. The applicant subsequently lodged an application for review of the department's decision, seeking to overturn the cancellation of their T endorsement and maintain their ability to operate heavy vehicles within Western Australia.

The proceedings before this Court involve a review of the decision by the respondent, the Department of Transport, to cancel the T extension to the applicant's driver's licence under the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA). The applicant, contesting the decision, sought judicial review of the respondent's determination, which was originally made in accordance with the statutory provisions governing the cancellation of licence endorsements. This matter came before the Court as a first-instance judicial review application, following the applicant's unsuccessful appeal to the Department of Transport's internal review process. The Court was required to examine the procedural fairness of the decision-making process, as well as the correctness of the decision itself, while strictly adhering to the principles of administrative law.

Prior to the Court's hearing, the applicant had lodged a formal complaint with the Department of Transport, arguing against the cancellation of the T extension to their licence. This initial complaint triggered an internal review process, wherein the Department reassessed the applicant's good character and the circumstances surrounding the cancellation decision. Upon the conclusion of this internal review, the Department upheld its initial decision, prompting the applicant to seek judicial review in this Court. The application was filed within the requisite timeframe, and the Court issued a notice of hearing, directing both parties to file and exchange relevant documentation. The procedural steps included the submission of affidavits, written submissions, and the eventual hearing of the matter. Throughout the process, the Court considered the procedural fairness and adherence to statutory requirements, as well as the correctness of the decision in light of the evidence presented.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does section 67(1)(b) of the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA) permit the respondent to cancel the applicant's T endorsement based on a lack of good character?

2. What constitutes a "breach of good character" under section 67(1)(b) of the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA)?

3. Did the applicant's criminal record, including the offence of possession of a prohibited drug, sufficiently demonstrate a breach of good character to warrant cancellation of the T endorsement?

4. Was the respondent's decision to cancel the T endorsement based on the applicant's criminal history procedurally fair and in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions?

5. Did the applicant provide adequate evidence to rebut the presumption of a breach of good character arising from their criminal record?

Held
1. The court concluded that section 67(1)(b) of the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA) does permit the respondent to cancel the applicant's T endorsement based on a lack of good character. Result: Held in favour of the respondent.

2. The court held that a "breach of good character" under section 67(1)(b) involves any conduct or conviction that demonstrates a lack of moral integrity or trustworthiness. Result: Defined "breach of good character."

3. The court concluded that the applicant's criminal record, including the offence of possession of a prohibited drug, sufficiently demonstrated a breach of good character to warrant the cancellation of the T endorsement. Result: Held in favour of the respondent.

4. The court determined that the respondent's decision to cancel the T endorsement was procedurally fair and in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions. Result: Held in favour of the respondent.

5. The court found that the applicant did not provide adequate evidence to rebut the presumption of a breach of good character arising from their criminal record. Result: Held in favour of the respondent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced its analysis by addressing whether section 67(1)(b) of the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA) permits the respondent to cancel the applicant's T endorsement based on a lack of good character. The court examined the legislative framework and found that section 67(1)(b) indeed authorises the respondent to cancel a T endorsement if the applicant fails to maintain good character, a criterion essential for the safe operation of vehicles. The court relied on the plain language of the regulation and the legislative intent to ensure that only drivers who uphold certain moral standards are allowed to operate heavy vehicles.

In determining what constitutes a "breach of good character" under section 67(1)(b), the court considered relevant case law and statutory interpretation principles. The court held that a breach of good character involves conduct that falls short of the standards of honesty, integrity, and reliability expected of a person holding a T endorsement. The court referenced previous judicial interpretations of "good character" in similar contexts, finding that it encompasses a broad spectrum of behaviour, including criminal activities, that may reflect poorly on the applicant's moral fibre. This broad interpretation aligns with the regulatory objective of maintaining high standards among drivers of heavy vehicles.

The court then assessed whether the applicant's criminal record, including the offence of possession of a prohibited drug, sufficiently demonstrated a breach of good character warranting cancellation of the T endorsement. The court noted that the possession of a prohibited drug is inherently dishonest and unreliable, aligning with the statutory requirement for good character. The court applied a principle of proportionality, weighing the seriousness of the offence against the need for stringent standards in the transport industry. It concluded that the offence was significant enough to warrant the cancellation of the T endorsement, as it demonstrated a clear breach of the expected standards of honesty and reliability.

The court further examined whether the respondent's decision to cancel the T endorsement was procedurally fair and in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions. The court found that the respondent had followed proper procedures, including providing the applicant with an opportunity to be heard and to present evidence. The court emphasized that procedural fairness was upheld, as the respondent considered the applicant's submissions and evidence before making the decision. The court relied on administrative law principles, confirming that the respondent's actions were in line with statutory requirements and did not infringe upon the applicant's procedural rights.

Finally, the court considered whether the applicant provided adequate evidence to rebut the presumption of a breach of good character arising from their criminal record. The applicant attempted to present mitigating circumstances and rehabilitation efforts, but the court found these submissions insufficient to overcome the clear evidence of the offence. The court applied the principle that the burden of proof lies on the applicant to demonstrate that they still possess good character despite their criminal history. The court concluded that the applicant failed to provide compelling evidence to rebut the presumption, and therefore the decision to cancel the T endorsement stood.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that under section 67(1)(b) of the Road Traffic (Authorisation to Drive) Regulations 2008 (WA), the respondent is authorised to cancel a T endorsement if the applicant's conduct demonstrates a breach of good character, and this decision must be procedurally fair and supported by the evidence. The court applied a broad interpretation of "good character," found the applicant's criminal record sufficient to establish a breach, and held that the respondent's decision was fair and in accordance with statutory provisions. The applicant did not provide adequate evidence to rebut the presumption of a breach of good character.