DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 514
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No Q2001/906
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re TAMARA TONITE
Applicant
And AUSTRALIAN ELECTORAL OFFICER FOR QUEENSLAND
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Senior Member KL Beddoe
Date27 June 2002
PlaceBrisbane
Decision The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
(Sgd) K L Beddoe
SENIOR MEMBER
Decision No: 514/2002
CATCHWORDS
ELECTORAL - STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – name change - whether name on electoral roll fictitious - whether name on electoral roll not in the public interest
Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 s 93, 98
Electoral and Referendum Amendment Act (No 1) 2001 Item 81, Part 2 of Schedule 1
Sinclair v Mining Warden (1975) 132 CLR 458 at 480
Freemarijuana & Australian Electoral Officer for Queensland [2001] AATA 917
Botany Bay City Council v Minister for Transport and Regional Development and Others (1996) 137 ALR 281 at 307
REASONS FOR DECISION
27 June 2002 Senior Member KL Beddoe
The applicant seeks review of a decision by the Australian Electoral Officer for Queensland to remove the applicant's name from the Electoral Roll and substitute the name of "Roderick Peter Paterson".
Sub-sections 98A(2) and 98A(3) of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 read as follows:
"(2)A Divisional Returning Officer or Australian Electoral Officer may refuse to include in a Roll, or transfer to a Roll, a person's name if the Divisional Returning Officer or Australian Electoral Officer considers that the name:
(a) is fictitious, frivolous, offensive or obscene; or
(b) is not the name by which the person is usually known; or
(c) is not written in the alphabet used for the English language.(3)A Divisional Returning Officer or Australian Electoral Officer may refuse to include in a Roll, or transfer to a Roll, a person's name if including the name in the Roll, or transferring it to the Roll, would be contrary to the public interest."
The Electoral and Referendum Amendment Act (No 1) 2001 being Act No 34/2001 contains transitional provisions including item 81 in Part 2 of Schedule 1 of the Act which, so far as is relevant, reads as follows:
"81(1) This item applies if:
(a)before sections 93A and 98A of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (the CEA) commence, a person's name (the current name) is included in a Roll, or transferred to a Roll, under a provision of the CEA; and
(b)a Divisional Returning Officer (the DRO) or Australian Electoral Officer (the AEO) is of the view that if he or she were considering, after sections 93A and 98A of the CEA commence, whether to cause the current name to be included in, or transferred to, the Roll under the same provision, the DRO or AEO would refuse, under either of those sections, to cause the name to be included or transferred.
(2) If:
(a)there is another name under which the person has been included in a Roll; and
(b)the DRO or AEO is of the view that if he or she were considering, after sections 93A and 98A…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tonite and Australian Electoral Officer for Queensland and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] AATA 514
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether Tonite's name on the electoral roll was fictitious, and if so, whether it was in the public interest. The court had to interpret the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 and the Electoral and Referendum Amendment Act (No 1) 2001 to determine if Tonite's use of "Tamara Tonite" for entertainment purposes constituted a formal adoption of that name. The court also had to consider the public interest aspect, examining whether Tonite's use of "Tamara Tonite" for electoral purposes was consistent with the public interest.
The court found that while Tonite had formalised the name "Tamara Tonite" on certain documents, his continued use of "Roderick Peter Paterson" in everyday life indicated that "Tamara Tonite" was not his recognised name for all purposes. The court noted that Tonite's adoption of the name "Tamara Tonite" was tied to his entertainment career, particularly his role in a television show, and not for general use. The court concluded that Tonite's name on the electoral roll was not fictitious but that it was not the name by which he was generally known in the community or for day-to-day purposes. The court further found that Tonite's use of "Tamara Tonite" for electoral purposes was not in the public interest because it did not reflect his commonly used name.
The court ordered that the name "Tamara Tonite" on the electoral roll be changed to "Roderick Peter Paterson" to accurately reflect the name Tonite used in his everyday life and to align with the public interest.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The only formal documents adopting the name "Tamara Tonite" are the deed poll and income tax returns. All other documents are in the name of "Roderick Peter Paterson" even though the applicant has had ample opportunity to change the name. The lease of the applicant's name has been renewed in the name of "Paterson" after the date of the deed poll. The name has not been adopted for everyday purposes.Consideration The issue here has not been the subject of any previous decision that I am aware of. The present case differs from the Re Freemarijuana case because here there is an ambivalence about the use of two names in stark contrast to each other. In everyday living, including formal matters (excluding income tax returns), the applicant uses the name "Roderick Peter Paterson". I gained the distinct impression that the use of "Paterson" is consistent with the applicant being "out of costume". He told me that when he travels by air he does so under the name of "Paterson". It is clear enough that the reason is that his documents which identify him are in the name of "Roderick Peter Paterson" and he therefore uses that name in everyday life. The name "Tamara Tonite" is identified with the television show of the same name and of which the applicant is now the presenter and executive in charge of production. However, there is even an ambivalence about the television show because the applicant also uses the name "Rod Paterson" in the credits for his work as editor and camera operator. I accept the applicant's explanation as to why there should be an appearance of independence between producer and editor but that does not alter the fact that the applicant uses the name "Paterson" when it suits his purpose. Because the applicant identifies with the television show and members of the public also identify him with the television show, he has adopted the name "Tamara Tonite" both informally and formally for purposes which are connected with the show, in particular, and when he is "in costume", generally. I am satisfied that the name "Tamara Tonite" is the applicant's recognised name as an entertainer. I am not satisfied that the name "Tamara Tonite" is recognised as the applicant's name in his capacity as a citizen. He uses "Paterson" in his day-to-day dealings with others albeit that those who recognise him when he is not "in costume" refer to him as "Tamara Tonite". Given that "Tamara Tonite" is the name of the television show, it might be argued, as the respondent does, that the name adopted by the applicant is a fiction. The fact of the applicant adopting the name of the show does support the contention but it does not follow, in my view, that it must be accepted that such an adoption of name thereby creates a fiction. A stage name can become a real name if formalised. The applicant has done so in this case. The problem here is the use of "Roderick Peter Paterson" in everyday life. I am far from satisfied that it can be accepted that the name "Tamara Tonite" is the name he uses from day-to-day. Further, because of the evidence about his everyday affairs and his maintenance of "Roderick Peter Paterson" in relation to his everyday personal affairs, I cannot be satisfied that "Tamara Tonite" is the name by which the applicant is generally known in the community in which he resides and in relation to which he is enrolled on the roll for the division in which he resides.