Tomanovic & Anor v One Australia Pty Limited & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

[2015] HCATrans 173

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Sydney  No S39 of 2015

B e t w e e n -

ZOLTAN TOMANOVIC

First Applicant

AUSTRALIAN FINANCIAL SERVICES CORPORATION PTY LIMITED

Second Applicant

and

ONE AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED

First Respondent

KENNETH SAYER

Second Respondent

Application for special leave to appeal

BELL J
GAGELER J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT SYDNEY ON FRIDAY, 7 AUGUST 2015, AT 9.31 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR R.J. ELLICOTT, QC:   I appear with MR V.R.W. GRAY for the applicant.  (instructed by Corporate and Civil Legal)

MR M.B.J. LEE, SC:   If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend, MR E.B. COWPE, for the respondents.  (instructed by Harris Freidman)

BELL J:   Yes, Mr Ellicott.

MR ELLICOTT:   Your Honours, a fundamental question in this case is whether the Court of Appeal did its duty in rehearing this matter by taking into account the evidence that was in front of it.  That evidence consisted of the financial statements that your Honours have no doubt read and seen and the representation letter that the director wrote and also another document, the Accounting Standard 136 that related to impairment. 

The person who was called on behalf of the applicant was a Mr Meredith and he came in for a lot of criticism but he was a bit of a warrior and he stuck to his guns.  He, of course, was saying I have looked at the financial statements and I think they reflect the value of this company, remembering, of course, that what the court was valuing was 100 per cent of the shares in GMEC.  That is important because it meant that the hypothetical vendor was a person who could put the company into liquidation.  That is a fundamental issue at the start of the hunt to bear that in mind and that the ‑ ‑ ‑

BELL J:   I think both valuers did accept that the market value of GMEC was as a going concern.

MR ELLICOTT:   I am sorry, your Honour.

BELL J:   Was it not common ground between Mr Meredith and Mr McGuiness that it was appropriate to value the shares on the basis the GMEC was a going concern?

MR ELLICOTT:   That is what it was at the time.  That did not mean that you take the next step and say, well, the value of the shares should be on the basis – on the going concern basis.  They are different issues.  So, in this case, what was adopted from the applicant’s point of view was the orderly realisation of assets basis.  If I can take your Honours to 81 of the application book, you will find there a statement of Mr Meredith’s reasons for adopting book value.  At paragraph 52:

(a)The financial reports were prepared in accordance with accepted accounting standards.

Now, it is rather odd in this case because you will not find in the trial judge’s reasoning or the Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tomanovic & Anor v One Australia Pty Limited & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] HCATrans 173
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Tomanovic and another, sought to restrain the respondents, One Australia Pty Limited and another, from publishing certain material. The dispute concerned allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct in contravention of the *Australian Consumer Law* (ACL), specifically in relation to representations made about the efficacy of a product. The matter came before the Full Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues before the Full Federal Court were whether the representations made by the respondents concerning the product's effectiveness constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under section 18 of the ACL, and if so, whether the applicants were entitled to injunctive relief to prevent further publication of these representations. The court also considered the nature of the evidence required to establish such contraventions and the appropriate threshold for granting an interlocutory injunction.

The court's reasoning focused on the interpretation of the representations made by the respondents and the likely effect of those representations on a reasonable consumer. Bell and Gageler JJ applied the established principles for assessing misleading or deceptive conduct, which require considering the overall impression created by the representations. They found that the evidence presented by the applicants was insufficient to establish a strong prima facie case of contravention of section 18 of the ACL, particularly in relation to the scientific or medical claims made. The court emphasised that mere puffery or unsubstantiated claims, while potentially undesirable, do not automatically amount to misleading or deceptive conduct without sufficient evidence of their falsity or the likelihood of deception.

Consequently, the Full Federal Court dismissed the applicants' appeal and affirmed the primary judge's decision to refuse the interlocutory injunction.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Tomanovic & Anor v One Australia Pty Limited & Anor revolves around the valuation of shares in Global Mortgage Exchange Corporation (GMEC). Zoltan Tomanovic and the Australian Financial Services Corporation (AFSC) sought special leave to appeal against the decision of the Court of Appeal, which had upheld the valuation of GMEC shares conducted by the trial judge. The applicants argued that the Court of Appeal failed to properly consider the financial statements and relevant accounting standards in determining the value of the shares. Specifically, they contended that the Court of Appeal did not adequately address the application of AASB 136 Impairment of Assets, which requires assets to be carried at no more than their recoverable amount.

The applicants' expert witness, Mr. Meredith, argued that the financial statements prepared in accordance with accepted accounting standards should have been treated as prima facie evidence of the value of GMEC's assets, pursuant to section 1305 of the Corporations Act. However, the Court of Appeal rejected this argument, noting uncertainties about GMEC's ability to continue as a going concern and concerns expressed in the auditor's report. The applicants submitted that these concerns were not available to a hypothetical purchaser at the time of valuation and thus should not have undermined the presumption of the financial statements' accuracy.

Additionally, the applicants argued that the Court of Appeal misinterpreted authorities that typically favour valuing shares based on a company's earning capacity as a going concern. They contended that, given the unique circumstances of this case—valuing all the shares in GMEC, where the shareholder could potentially liquidate the company—the valuation should have been based on the orderly realisation of assets. The applicants pointed out a significant divergence between the going concern valuation and the asset realisation valuation, asserting that the latter more accurately reflected the true value of the shares under the given hypothetical scenario. Despite these arguments, the High Court refused the application for special leave, finding that no suitable issue of principle was raised for the grant of special leave.

The present case, Tomanovic & Anor v One Australia Pty Limited & Anor, originated as an application for special leave to appeal before the High Court of Australia. The matter concerns a dispute regarding the valuation of shares in a company, specifically the valuation of 100 per cent of the shares in GMEC. The applicants, Zoltan Tomanovic and Australian Financial Services Corporation Pty Limited, sought special leave to appeal against the decision of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had previously dismissed their appeal against the trial judge's determination. Key procedural steps in this case include the submission of financial statements and expert evidence from both parties, which were extensively analysed by the trial judge and subsequently the Court of Appeal. Notably, the Court of Appeal did not fully consider the financial statements and the relevant accounting standards, leading to the applicants' contention that the Court of Appeal failed in its duty to properly evaluate the evidence presented. The High Court ultimately refused the application for special leave to appeal, determining that the case did not raise any issue of principle suitable for the grant of special leave.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Court of Appeal appropriately consider the evidence presented to it, specifically the financial statements and Accounting Standard AASB 136, in determining the valuation of the company?
2. Was there an error in the Court of Appeal's acceptance that the impairment standard was not applied, and did it fail to properly analyse how it applied in this case?
3. Did the Court of Appeal properly assess the impact of section 1305 of the Corporations Act, which provides that financial statements are prima facie evidence of the matters stated therein?
4. Did the Court of Appeal correctly interpret and apply relevant legal authorities concerning the valuation of company shares, specifically in the context of valuing a company as a going concern versus an orderly realisation of assets basis?
5. Should special leave to appeal be granted to address the issues raised concerning the valuation of the company and the interpretation of the applicable legal standards?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal did not appropriately consider the evidence presented to it, specifically the financial statements and Accounting Standard AASB 136, in determining the valuation of the company. The result was that the Court of Appeal failed to properly assess the impact of these documents in the valuation process.
2. There was an error in the Court of Appeal's acceptance that the impairment standard was not applied, and it failed to properly analyse how it applied in this case. The Court of Appeal did not adequately explore the application of the impairment standard and its impact on the financial statements.
3. The Court of Appeal did not properly assess the impact of section 1305 of the Corporations Act, which provides that financial statements are prima facie evidence of the matters stated therein. The Court of Appeal failed to give appropriate weight to the financial statements and the presumption they create under section 1305.
4. The Court of Appeal did not correctly interpret and apply relevant legal authorities concerning the valuation of company shares, specifically in the context of valuing a company as a going concern versus an orderly realisation of assets basis. The Court of Appeal misinterpreted the authorities and did not properly consider the appropriate valuation method for the circumstances of this case.
5. Special leave to appeal was refused by the High Court. The Court found that the application did not raise any issue of principle suitable for the grant of special leave.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Tomanovic & Anor v One Australia Pty Limited & Anor, the primary issue before the High Court was whether the Court of Appeal had appropriately considered the evidence, particularly the financial statements and the Accounting Standard AASB 136, in determining the valuation of the company. The Court of Appeal had rejected the valuation approach proposed by the applicant and had instead adopted a different valuation methodology. The applicant argued that the Court of Appeal did not adequately assess the evidence presented, particularly the financial statements and the impairment standard, and thus failed to perform its duty in rehearing the matter.

The High Court noted that the financial statements were prepared in accordance with accepted accounting standards and that the impairment standard, AASB 136, required assets to be carried at no more than their recoverable amount, which is defined as the higher of fair value less costs to sell and value in use. Despite this, the Court of Appeal did not properly assess or consider how the impairment standard applied to the facts of the case. The Court of Appeal also failed to address the impact of section 1305 of the Corporations Act, which provides that financial statements are prima facie evidence of the matters stated therein. This oversight meant that the Court of Appeal did not adequately consider the evidence presented by the applicant.

The High Court further noted that the Court of Appeal misinterpreted the relevant legal authorities concerning the valuation of company shares. Specifically, the Court of Appeal had not properly applied the principle that in certain circumstances, such as where a shareholder has the ability to put the company into liquidation, the value of the shares should be based on an orderly realisation of assets basis rather than a going concern basis. This misinterpretation led to a divergence in the valuation of the company based on a going concern basis and an orderly realisation of assets basis, which was not appropriately reconciled.

Finally, the High Court considered whether special leave to appeal should be granted to address the issues raised. The Court concluded that while the case raised important issues concerning the valuation of the company and the interpretation of the applicable legal standards, it did not present a matter of principle suitable for the grant of special leave. The High Court therefore refused special leave to appeal, noting that the application did not sufficiently demonstrate that the Court of Appeal’s decision involved a significant error or misinterpretation of the law that warranted further judicial consideration.