Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Ltd v Chapman

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL PANEL
CITATION: Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Ltd v Chapman [2023] NSWPICMP 701
APPELLANT: Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT: Ray Samuel Chapman
APPEAL PANEL
MEMBER: Marshal Douglas
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: James Bodel
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Chris Oates
DATE OF DECISION: 22 December 2023
CATCHWORDS: 

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; Medical Assessor (MA) assessed permanent impairment of the respondent from several injuries the respondent suffered to his knees; whether, with respect to two of those injuries, the deduction the MA made under section 323(1) for proportion of respondent’s permanent impairment that was due to a previous injury or pre-existing condition was wrong or was based on incorrect criteria; Appeal Panel held that the deduction made with respect to one injury involved error; Held – Medical Assessment Certificate revoked.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO APPEAL

  1. On 26 September 2023 Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Ltd, the appellant, lodged an
    Application to Appeal Against the Decision of a Medical Assessor. The medical dispute was assessed by Dr Rob Kuru, a Medical Assessor, who issued a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) on 29 August 2023.

  2. The appellant relies on the following grounds of appeal under s 327(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (1998 Act):

    ·        the assessment was made on the basis of incorrect criteria, and

    ·        the MAC contains a demonstrable error.

  3. The delegate is satisfied that, on the face of the application, at least one ground of appeal has been made out. The Appeal Panel has conducted a review of the original medical assessment but limited to the ground(s) of appeal on which the appeal is made.

  4. Rule 128 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (PIC Rules) and Procedural Direction PIC7 - Appeals, reviews, reconsiderations and correction of obvious errors in medical disputes set out the practice and procedure in relation to the medical appeal process under s 328 of the 1998 Act. An Appeal Panel determines its own procedures in accordance with r 128(1) of the PIC Rules.

  5. The assessment of permanent impairment is conducted in accordance with the SIRA NSW Workers Compensation Guidelines for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 4th ed
    1 March 2021 (the Guidelines) and the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 5th ed (AMA 5).

RELEVANT FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  1. Ray Samuel Chapman, the respondent, commenced employment as an operator with the appellant in August 1998. He ceased his employment in July 2022. In a statement he signed on 14 June 2022 he described that his employment required him to tap metal out of pots into a large ladle and to change anodes in aluminium pots. He was required to wear clothing that the appellant provided him which included boots that each weighed one kilogram. His work required him to walk many kilometres on concrete floors in each shift and to walk on uneven ground. His work required him to negotiate stairs and uneven ground. Further, he spent long periods standing,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Ltd v Chapman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMP 701
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Ltd v Chapman involved a dispute concerning the assessment of the respondent's permanent impairment due to several injuries sustained to his knees. The dispute was brought before the Appeal Panel under the provisions of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The appellant, Tomago Aluminium Company, sought to challenge the deductions made by the Medical Assessor (MA) regarding the proportion of the respondent’s permanent impairment attributable to previous injuries or pre-existing conditions. Specifically, the appellant argued that the MA had erred in the deductions made for two of the injuries to the respondent’s knees.

The legal issues before the Appeal Panel centred on the correctness of the deductions made by the MA under section 323(1) of the 1998 Act. The appellant argued that the MA had incorrectly assessed the proportion of the respondent's permanent impairment attributable to previous injuries or pre-existing conditions. The appellant contended that the MA should have made a similar deduction for the left knee injuries as was made for the right knee injury, given the similar nature of the prior surgeries. The respondent, on the other hand, argued that the MA had appropriately assessed the injuries based on the distinct nature of the injuries and surgeries to each knee.

The Appeal Panel found that the MA had indeed erred in the deduction made for one of the left knee injuries. The Panel held that the MA had failed to consider the relevant prior surgery when making the deduction, and that the deduction made was not in accordance with the correct criteria as outlined in relevant case law. As a result, the Appeal Panel revoked the Medical Assessment Certificate. The Panel did not find any error in the other deductions made by the MA, and no challenges were made to those assessments.

The final orders included the revocation of the Medical Assessment Certificate with respect to the left knee injury on 18 June 2018 and the injury deemed to have happened on 8 August 2022. The Appeal Panel ordered a review of the assessment of the respondent's permanent impairment in relation to these injuries, ensuring that the correct criteria and considerations were applied in future assessments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

EVIDENCE The Appeal Panel has before it all the documents that were sent to the Medical Assessor for the original medical assessment and has taken them into account in making this determination. Both parties made written submissions. They are not repeated in full, but have been considered by the Appeal Panel. In summary, the appellant submitted that the Medical Assessor applied incorrect criteria and made an error when assessing the deductible proportion under s323(1) of the 1998 Act relating to respondent's left knee injury on 18 June 2018 and from the left injury that was deemed to have happened on 8 August 2022. The appellant submitted that given the Medical Assessor made a deduction of three-quarters when assessing the degree of permanent impairment of the respondent's right knee injury on 8 August 2022 due to the respondent having a partial meniscectomy of the right knee, the Medical Assessor ought to have applied a similar deduction when assessing the respondent's permanent impairment relating to the injury he suffered to his left knee on 18 June 2018 and to the injury to his left knee that was deemed to have happened on 8 August 2022. The appellant noted that the respondent had arthroscopic debridement of his left knee with partial meniscectomy and medical femoral chondroplasty on 15 February 2008. The appellant submitted that the Medical Assessor failed to consider this surgery when considering what deduction was to be made under s 323(1) when assessing the permanent impairment the respondent had from the injury to his left knee on 8 June 2018 and the injury deemed to have happened on 8 August 2022. The appellant referred to the case of Cole v Wenaline Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 78 (Cole) and to Fardell v Clinton Industries Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 111 (Fardell). The appellant submitted that based on those authorities the Medical Assessor was required not to base his assessment on an assumption or hypothesis and was required to analyse how a prior injury or pre-existing condition contributes to the permanent impairment from the injury that is the subject of the assessment. In reply, the respondent submitted that the appellant's appeal is based on unreasonable generalisations and repetitious assertions. The respondent submitted that the appellant ignores that each knee suffered separate and distinct insults and was subjected to surgery of a different nature at different times. The respondent submitted that it is apparent from the MAC that the Medical Assessor took into consideration the meniscectomy that he had done to his left knee in 2008. The procedures on appeal are contained in s 328 of the 1998 Act. The appeal is to be by way of review of the original medical assessment but the review is limited to the grounds of appeal on which the appeal is made. In Campbelltown City Council v Vegan [2006] NSWCA 284 the Court of Appeal held that the Appeal Panel is obliged to give reasons. The Appeal Panel notes that no challenge has been made to the Medical Assessor's assessment of the respondent's permanent impairment from the injury to his left knee on 18 August 2007 and from the injury to his right knee that was deemed to have happened on 8 August 2022. Further, no challenge has been made to the Medical Assessor's conclusion that the permanent impairment from the respondent's injury to his right knee on 18 November 2018 is not assessable. Also, no challenge has been made to the Medical Assessor's assessment that the respondent had a good result from his left knee replacement and that as a consequence, he has 15% WPI overall following the injury to his left knee that was deemed to have occurred on 8 August 2022.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.