Toll Holdings Ltd v Stewart

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Toll Holdings Ltd v Stewart

[2016] FCA 256

File number: VID 181 of 2016
Judge: RARES J
Date of judgment: 15 March 2016
Catchwords:

SALE OF GOODS – stoppage in transitu – conversion – where administrators and receivers appointed to purchaser with property in goods shipped f.o.b. to Australia – where unpaid vendor gives notice to carrier to “hold” goods – whether notice effectual stoppage in transitu under s 48 of Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW) – whether carrier’s subsequent delivery of goods from wharf to agent of purchaser conversion of goods – when transit finishes

ADMIRALTY – straight telex release bills of lading given to purchaser by unpaid vendor – whether consignor or carrier can replace straight bills with to order bill after goods shipped on board

CORPORATIONS – whether leave to proceed under ss 440B or 440D of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) should be granted to carrier of goods seeking to interplead or to unpaid vendor of goods asserting right of possession after exercise of right of stoppage in transitu under Pt 5 of Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interpleader proceedings under rr 18.01 and 18.05 of Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – whether stakeholder colluded or disentitled to interplead

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW)

Sea-Carriage Documents Act 1997 (NSW)

Cases cited:

Attard v James Legal Pty Ltd (2010) 80 ACSR 585

Beluga Shipping GmbH v Headway Shipping Ltd [2008] FCA 1791

Bethell v Clark (1888) 20 QBD 615

Bignold v Audland (1840) 11 Sim 23

Booth Steamship Company Ltd v Cargo Fleet Iron Company Ltd [1916] 2 KB 570

Dixon v Baldwin (1804) 5 East 175

Ex parte Rosevear China Clay Company;  In re Cock (1879) 11 Ch D 560

Hewett v Court (1983) 149 CLR 639

Hilditch Pty Ltd v Dorval Kaiun KK (No 2) (2007) 245 ALR 125

Kemp v Falk (1882) 7 App Cas 573

Lyons v Hoffnung (1890) 15 App Cas 391

Murietta v The South American Company Ltd (1893) 62 LJKB 396

Owners of “Shin Kobe Maru” v Empire Shipping Co Inc (1994) 181 CLR 404

Phelps v Stokes & Co v Comber (1885) 29 Ch D 813

Schotsmans v Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway Company (1867) LR 2 Ch App 332

The Queen v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal;  Ex parte 2HD Pty Ltd (1979) 144 CLR 45

The Raphaela S [2005] 2 AC 423

United States Steel Products Co Ltd v Great Western Railway [1916] 1 AC 189

Whitehead v Anderson (1842) 9 M&W 518

Date of hearing: 11 March 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Admiralty and Maritime
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 95
Counsel for the Applicant: MNC Harvey
Solicitor for the Applicant: Holman Fenwick Willan
Counsel for the First and Third Respondents: AM Stewart SC with CO Gleeson
Solicitor for the First and Third Respondents: Norton Rose Fulbright
Counsel for the Second Respondent: EH…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Toll Holdings Ltd v Stewart and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Toll Holdings Ltd and Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd sued Dick Smith and its receivers, seeking determination of their rights to the possession of several consignments of goods. Dick Smith was a purchaser of goods from Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd, which were shipped to Australia and were held in bonded storage by Toll. Toll sought a declaration that it had the right to possession of the goods, and Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd sought damages for conversion of the goods. The court was required to decide whether Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd's notice to Toll to "hold" the goods was an effective stoppage in transitu, and whether Toll's delivery of the goods to an agent of Dick Smith was a conversion of the goods. The court also had to determine whether leave should be granted to Toll and Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd to proceed under sections 440B and 440D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and whether Toll could replace straight telex release bills of lading with to order bills after the goods had been shipped on board.

The court held that Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd's notice to Toll to "hold" the goods was an effective stoppage in transitu, and that Toll's delivery of the goods to an agent of Dick Smith was a conversion of the goods. The court granted leave to Toll and Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd to proceed under sections 440B and 440D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), subject to a condition that no step be taken to enforce any judgment against Dick Smith without a further grant of leave. The court also held that Toll could not replace straight telex release bills of lading with to order bills after the goods had been shipped on board. The court declared that Dick Smith and the receivers had the right of possession of the goods shipped under the relevant bills of lading, and entered judgment for Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd against Toll in conversion in a sum to be assessed.

The court ordered that Toll do all that is necessary to be done by them for the release of the goods to Dick Smith and the receivers, and that Toll pay the respondents' costs of the proceedings. The matter was listed for directions as to the assessment of Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd's damages and determination of liability for storage and container demurrage charges on 1 April 2016.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be granted to:

(a) the applicants pursuant to s 440D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to proceed in respect of the relief sought in the Amended Originating Application filed 29 February 2016; and

(b) the second respondent/cross claimant pursuant to ss 440B and 440D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to proceed in respect of the relief sought in the Amended Cross-Claim filed on 10 March 2016,

on the condition that no step is taken to enforce any judgment against the third respondent/fourth cross respondent, without a further grant of leave.

2. It be declared that the first and third respondents have as against the applicants and the second respondent the right of possession of the goods shipped under bills of lading numbered TSZX2271812, TSZX2271874, TSZX2293155, TSZX2294689, TSZX2294711, TSZX2294643 (the Goods).

3. The applicants do all that is necessary to be done by them for the release of the goods to the first and third respondents.

4. Judgment be entered for the second respondent/cross claimant (Shenzhen MTC Co Ltd) against the applicants/cross respondents (Toll Holdings Ltd and Toll Global Forwarding (Hong Kong) Ltd) on the Cross-Claim in conversion in a sum to be assessed.

5. The application for relief sought in the Amended Originating Application filed 29 February 2016 be dismissed.

6. The applicants pay the respondents’ costs of the proceedings.

7. The matter be listed for directions as to the assessment of the second respondent’s damages and determination of liability for storage and container demurrage charges on 1 April 2016.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The direct debit arrangement ceased on 4 January 2016. That change is of some significance in the present circumstances, since the Customs fees for the entries for home consumption of the cargoes carried under the six bills have not been paid.The MTC agreement and background Dick Smith and MTC agreed in the MTC agreement relevantly that:·“Delivery Address” meant “Dick Smith’s freight forwarders nominated from time to time …” (cl 2);ŸFOB means free on board in accordance with the INCOTERMS 2012 and means the Supplier [MTC] shall be responsible and liable for all packing costs, the costs of commercial documents, Inland delivery to the first carrier, inland delivery to the vessel or aircraft, wharfage and export customs. The Supplier shall also be responsible for the costs of obtaining an airway bill or bill of lading which shall be included in the Free on Board value (cl 2). (emphasis added)·Dick Smith could place purchase orders with MTC and, where not inconsistent, the terms of the MTC agreement would apply to the individual purchase agreement that then would be formed by MTC’s acceptance of the purchase order (cl 5);·MTC’s quoted prices would be “FOB shipping point to the Delivery Address” (cl 6.3(a));·MTC had to issue an invoice and any delivery documentation that Dick Smith notified for the goods “at the time the Goods are delivered to the Delivery Address, and not any time before” (cl 7.1);ŸTitle and property in the Goods passes to Dick Smith on delivery to the Delivery Address (cl 8.1).…ŸDick Smith’s acceptance of the Goods at the Delivery Address is not an acceptance that the (a) Goods are undamaged;(b) total number of Goods required to be delivered has been received; nor(d)Goods comply with the relevant Purchase Agreement’s terms (cl 8.3). (emphasis added) ŸThe Supplier must meet all dates and times for delivery of the Goods to Delivery Address as set out in the relevant Purchase Order or any later time that Dick Smith otherwise notifies or allows to the Supplier (cl 9.1).ŸThe Supplier must deliver the Goods to the Delivery Address notified to the Supplier in the relevant Purchase Order or as Dick Smith otherwise notifies the Supplier (cl 9.4).·the law of New South Wales and the Commonwealth of Australia was the governing law (cl 21.1); and·the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (known as the Vienna Convention) did not apply (cl 21.2). Dick Smith’s printed purchase order forms, used in its relevant transactions with MTC, included trading terms that provided, consistently with the MTC agreement, that:·MTC had to deliver the goods (purchased) to nominated sites within the lead times specified in the purchase order (cl 2);·title to and risk of the goods passed to Dick Smith on acceptance by it in accordance with cl 6 (cl 5);·Dick Smith would be deemed to have accepted goods that did not require installation and testing [such as those included in the seven telex release bills of lading] upon their “delivery … to the nominated site” (cl 6).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no evidence of the damages to which MTC is entitled and those will have to be assessed.Conclusion Each of Toll and MTC should have leave to proceed under ss 440B and 440D of the Corporations Act. Dick Smith is entitled as against MTC and Toll to possession of the seven cargoes in dispute. MTC is entitled to damages for conversion of those cargoes against Toll. I will hear the parties and, if they wish, the administrators on the form of orders to give effect to these reasons and as to costs. Toll and MTC should provide the administrators with these reasons, notice of the orders each party seeks and when the matter is relisted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 10 and 11 March 2016, the solicitors for the administrators wrote to MTC and Toll informing them that the administrators neither consented to, nor opposed, the applications for leave to proceed against Dick Smith under ss 440B and 440D. However, the administrators said that if leave were granted, they expected that MTC and Toll would apply for a further grant of leave before seeking to enforce any verdict or judgment against Dick Smith.1. The leave to proceed issue – consideration I reject Dick Smith’s argument that granting leave to each of Toll and, that particularly, MTC, to proceed would give some undue preference to either of them or subvert the object of Pt 5.3A. Toll asserted against Dick Smith that it was a stakeholder of the cargoes in bond the subject of the six bills and so was entitled to interplead between the persons asserting a right to delivery of those cargoes, namely Dick Smith and MTC. Toll also argued that if it were not entitled to interplead, although it claimed no proprietary interest in those cargoes, its stance in respect of them had exposed it to contested issues of liability to give possession of them, as Dick Smith sought, or in conversion, as MTC asserted. MTC asserted an interest as a vendor entitled to exercise, and to the benefits of its asserted exercise, on 5 and 7 January 2016, of the right of an unpaid vendor to stoppage of the cargoes in transitu. If MTC were not entitled to the benefit of its right to have stopped the cargoes in transitu before delivery to Dick Smith, it claims in conversion against Toll. I am of opinion Dick Smith and the receivers are proper and necessary parties to each of Toll’s and MTC’s claims in these proceedings. The issue of who is entitled to the cargoes self-evidently requires an urgent, judicial decision. The conduct of the receivers in opposing leave to proceed sought by Toll and MTC is difficult to understand. They act as agents of Dick Smith through the authority conferred by securities it granted their secured appointors. Those lenders took those securities to protect them against the consequences of Dick Smith defaulting on its obligations under the loan agreements or becoming insolvent. No doubt, by entering into administration on 4 January 2016, Dick Smith committed an act of default under the securities entitling the syndicate of lenders to enforce their securities. In the present commercial circumstances, the receivers are conducting closing down sales of Dick Smith’s business over about the next six weeks. They hope to sell the disputed cargoes to engorge the receipts of that process while leaving MTC in the position of being an unsecured creditor, without the benefit, if it can establish it, of its asserted stoppage in transitu. If MTC succeeded in its claim, that would intercept the disputed cargoes, for which it has not been, and is unlikely ever to be, paid. Thus, the dispute with Dick Smith that MTC seeks to litigate is effectively one between the syndicate of secured lenders and an unpaid vendor asserting a secured or quasi-secured interest over goods allegedly not yet delivered to the debtor.