Todd v Commissioner for Fair Trading

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS TRIBUNAL GENERAL DIVISION

CITATION:      Todd v Commissioner for Fair Trading [2004]  NSWADT 278

PARTIES:      APPLICANT
Roderick John Todd
RESPONDENT
Commissioner for Fair Trading

FILE NUMBERS:      043144

HEARING DATES:   20/09/2004

SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 12/11/2004

DECISION DATE:     02/12/2004

BEFORE:      Montgomery S - Judicial Member

LEGISLATION CITED: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 2002

CASES CITED:       

APPLICATION: Property, Stock and Business Agents Act - Real Estate, Business, Stock and Station Agent - cancellation of licence
Property, Stock and Business Agents Act - Real Estate, Business, Stock and Station Agent - disqualification
Real Estate, Business, Stock and Station Agent - cancellation of licence
Real Estate, Business, Stock and Station Agent - disqualification

MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter

APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE:            APPLICANT
In person

RESPONDENT REPRESENTATIVE:      RESPONDENT
J Coss, legal officer

ORDERS:      I declare that Mr. Roderick John Todd is a disqualified person pursuant to section 16(l)(m) of the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 2002. Accordingly, the decision to cancel Mr. Todd’s licence was the correct and preferable decision. To that extent the decision of the Commissioner for Fair Trading is affirmed. The decision is otherwise set aside.

Reasons for Decision:

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is a review of a decision by the Commissioner for Fair Trading to cancel a Real Estate Agent's and Stock and Station Agent's Licence held by Mr. Todd under the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 2002 ("the Act") and to permanently disqualify Mr. Todd from holding a licence or certificate or being involved in the direction, management or conduct of a Licensee effective from 17 May 2004.

Background

  1. Mr Todd was the holder of a Real Estate Agent's and Stock and Station Agent's Licence. He was a sole trader and was the registered proprietor of the business names CCR Ryans Real Estate Batlow and Batlow Real Estate.

  2. In mid 2001 the Oriental Hotel at Tumut, the Royal Hotel at Adelong and the Criterion Hotel at Gundagai were on the market. On 7 August 2001 Mr. Melvin Woods arranged to pay $45,000 to Mr. Todd as a holding deposit. Mr. Woods was not the successful purchaser and sought the return of his $45,000 deposit. Mr. Todd had in fact used Mr. Woods’ deposit by transferring the monies out of his Trust Account to his General Account.

  3. Mr. Todd claimed that Mr. Woods had given him a personal loan of $45,000 under a verbal agreement. Mr Woods asserted that the funds were used without his authority. Mr. Todd was unable to indicate the term, interest rate, and conditions of this loan.

  4. In October 2001 Mr. Todd repaid $16,000 to Mr. Woods. Mr. Woods took action in the Local Court to recover the amounts outstanding. Judgement was made in Mr. Woods' favour and on 22 February 2002 Mr. Todd was ordered to repay $36,291.34.

  5. Mr. Todd did not pay the judgement debt. Mr. Woods attempted various enforcement actions including threatened bankruptcy and subsequently made a claim on the Property Services Compensation Fund (“the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Todd v Commissioner for Fair Trading and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWADT 278
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Todd v Commissioner for Fair Trading involved the applicant, Roderick John Todd, appealing the cancellation of his Real Estate Agent's and Stock and Station Agent's Licence by the Commissioner for Fair Trading, under the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 2002. The Commissioner had also permanently disqualified Mr. Todd from holding a licence or being involved in the direction, management, or conduct of a Licensee. The dispute centred around Mr. Todd's alleged misuse of a $45,000 holding deposit from Mr. Melvin Woods, which was intended for the purchase of three hotels in 2001. Mr. Todd claimed that the funds were a personal loan from Mr. Woods, a claim that was refuted by Mr. Woods. Following a judgment in Mr. Woods' favour in the Local Court, Mr. Todd failed to repay the outstanding amount of $36,291.34, leading to a claim on the Property Services Compensation Fund. The Commissioner issued a Notice to Show Cause, leading to the cancellation of Mr. Todd's licence and his disqualification as per the Act.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Mr. Todd was a disqualified person under section 16(l)(m) of the Act, which defines a disqualified person as someone who has failed to pay an amount due as a debt to the Crown by way of recovery of an amount paid out of the Compensation Fund and the failure continues. The court had to determine if the Commissioner's decision to cancel Mr. Todd's licence and disqualify him was justified based on the evidence and the applicable legislation.

The court examined the evidence and concluded that Mr. Todd had indeed failed to repay the amount due to the Crown from the Compensation Fund. Despite Mr. Todd's claim of a personal loan agreement with Mr. Woods, the court found that there was no evidence to support this claim and that Mr. Woods had not consented to the use of the funds for Mr. Todd's personal use. Additionally, the court noted that Mr. Todd had not fulfilled his undertaking to repay the outstanding amount by the specified date. Consequently, the court held that Mr. Todd was a disqualified person under section 16(l)(m) of the Act, affirming the Commissioner's decision to cancel his licence and disqualify him from holding a licence or being involved in the management of a licensee.

The court's decision was that the Commissioner's decision to cancel Mr. Todd's licence and disqualify him was correct and preferable. The Tribunal affirmed the Commissioner's decision to the extent that Mr. Todd's licence was cancelled and he was declared a disqualified person. The decision was otherwise set aside.