TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Tod’s S.p.A. to registration of trade mark application numbers 1511698 – VANESSA HOGAN - and 1512445 – VANESSA HOGAN AND DEVICE - filed in the name of Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd.
| Delegate: | Bianca Irgang |
| Representation: | Opponents: Ms Natalia Blecher of Corrs Chambers Westgarth Applicant: Not present at the hearing |
| Decision: | 2015 ATMO 5 Section 52 opposition: sections 44, 60 and 62A pressed – section 60 ground of opposition established. |
Background
Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd (‘the applicant’), filed trade mark application numbers 1511698 and 1512445 on 5 September 2012 and the 13 September 2012 respectively. The applications were made in classes 18 and 25 of the International Classification of Goods and Services. Current details of the applications are set out below.
Trade mark: VANESSA HOGAN[1]
[1] Hereafter referred to as the ‘VANESSA HOGAN trade mark’.
Trade mark application: 1511698
Filing Date: 5 September 2012
Specification: Class 18: Baggage; bags (envelopes, pouches) of leather, for packaging; bags for toiletry kits; bags for transport of clothes; bags made of imitation leather; bags made of leather; book bags; camping bags; carrying bags (other than disposable carrier bags); casual bags; changing bags; clutch bags; cosmetics bags (not fitted); evening bags; gym bags; hat bags; jewellery bags (empty); leather bags; luggage bags; make-up bags; portable bags (luggage); pouches (bags); school bags; shoe bags; shopping bag handles; shopping bags; shopping carts (wheeled shopping bags); shoulder bags; shoulder bags for use by children; toiletry bags; tool bags of leather (empty); travel baggage; travel bags; travel bags made of plastic materials; travelling bags; two-wheeled shopping bags; umbrella bags; weekend bags; wheeled shopping bags; wristlets (bags)
Class 25:Beach hats; hats; sun hats; apparel (clothing, footwear, headgear); aprons (clothing); belts (clothing); boys' clothing; casual clothing; children's clothing; clothes; clothing; clothing for babies; clothing for swimming; clothing of imitations of leather; clothing of leather; clothing of paper; denims (clothing); drawers (clothing); girl's clothing; gloves (clothing); jackets (clothing); jerseys (clothing); ladies clothing; leather belts (clothing); men's clothing; thongs (clothing); women's clothing; wristlets (clothing); athletics shoes; basketball shoes; bath shoes; bathing shoes; beach shoes; canvas shoes; leather shoes; men's shoes; running shoes; shoes; shoes for casual wear; shoes for infants; shoes for leisurewear; shoes for sports wear; walking shoes
Trade mark: [2]
Trade mark application: 1512445
Filing Date: 13 September 2012
Specification: Class 18: Airline travel bags; articles of luggage being bags; athletics bags; bag covers; baggage; bags (envelopes, pouches) of leather, for packaging; bags for campers; bags for climbers; bags for shaving kits; bags for toiletry kits; bags for transport of clothes; bags for use in sports for carrying sports clothing; bags made of imitation leather; bags made of leather; beach bags; belt bags; book bags; boston bags; camera bags (other than adapted or shaped to contain a camera); camping bags; carrying bags (other than disposable carrier bags); casual bags; changing bags; clutch bags; cosmetic bags (not fitted); cosmetics…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tod'S S.p.A. v Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] ATMO 5
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Registrar was whether the grounds of opposition raised by Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd had been established, thereby requiring the refusal of Tod's S.p.A.'s trade mark applications. Specifically, the Registrar was required to consider the grounds of opposition under section 60 of the relevant Act.
The Registrar found that the opponent, Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd, had successfully discharged the onus of proof in relation to the grounds of opposition argued at the hearing. Consequently, pursuant to section 55 of the Act, the Registrar decided to refuse the registration of the trade marks. The Registrar also ordered that costs follow the event, awarding costs against the unsuccessful applicant, Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd, on the official scale.
Background
Background to the litigation
Jiang & Hou provided evidence of its extensive use of the "TOD'S" mark in Australia, including sales records, advertising materials, and customer feedback, to demonstrate established goodwill and reputation. It also presented case law and expert evidence to support its claim that consumers would be confused by the similar marks. Tod'S, in response, argued that its international reputation and use of the "TOD'S" mark in other jurisdictions should be considered in determining the likelihood of confusion. It submitted evidence of its global operations and extensive use of the contested marks, particularly emphasising its presence in the luxury goods market.
The dispute centred on whether Jiang & Hou's earlier use and reputation for the "TOD'S" mark in Australia would lead to consumer confusion if Tod'S were to register the similar marks for similar goods and services. The evidence presented by both parties revolved around the distinctiveness and reputation of the "TOD'S" mark, the similarity between the marks, and the likelihood of confusion among consumers. The Registrar, in deciding the matter, had to weigh the evidence regarding the established reputation of Jiang & Hou's mark against the international reputation and use of Tod'S's marks.
The matter of Tod'S S.p.A. v Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd originated as an application to oppose the registration of two trade marks by Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd, specifically applications 1511698 and 1512445. The proceedings were heard before the Registrar under section 55 of the relevant Act, which mandates the Registrar to decide on the registration of trade marks at the conclusion of such proceedings. The opposition was brought by Tod'S S.p.A., asserting grounds under section 60 of the Act. During the course of the opposition, several procedural steps were taken, including the filing of opposition submissions by Tod'S S.p.A. and responses by Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd. The Registrar considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, ultimately concluding that the grounds of opposition had been sufficiently established by Tod'S S.p.A. The Registrar then proceeded to refuse the registration of the contested trade marks in accordance with the statutory provisions.
Following the hearing, the Registrar made a decision to refuse the registration of trade marks 1511698 and 1512445. In line with standard practice, the Registrar awarded costs against the unsuccessful party, Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd, pursuant to the official scale outlined in Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995. The decision reflects the principle that costs typically follow the event, and the Registrar found no grounds to deviate from this established practice. The procedural history of the case demonstrates a formal and structured approach to resolving the dispute over the trade mark applications, culminating in the Registrar's decision to refuse the registrations and award costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the role of the Registrar under section 55 of the Act, which mandates the Registrar to decide on the refusal or registration of a trade mark based on the established grounds of opposition. The court noted that unless a specific subsection applies, the Registrar must decide on the trade mark's registration status considering the extent to which the opposition grounds were substantiated. This statutory requirement ensures that the decision-making process adheres to the legislative framework, providing clarity and predictability in the outcome of opposition proceedings.
In examining whether Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd met the onus of proof under section 60 of the Act, the court considered the evidence presented during the hearing. The court determined that Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd had successfully met the required standard of proof to establish the grounds of opposition. This finding was pivotal, as it shifted the burden of justification onto Tod'S S.p.A., the entity opposing the registration. The court's decision underscored the importance of the onus of proof in opposition proceedings, emphasizing that failure to meet this threshold results in the continuation of the registration process.
The court then addressed the issue of whether trade mark applications 1511698 and 1512445 should be refused registration under section 55(1)(a) of the Act. Given that Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd had met the onus of proof, the court found that the applications should indeed be refused registration. This conclusion was based on the established grounds of opposition that were substantiated during the proceedings. The court's decision aligned with the statutory mandate, ensuring that the registration process reflects the outcomes of opposition hearings.
Regarding the award of costs, the court followed the principle that costs typically follow the event, meaning that the unsuccessful party generally bears the costs of the proceedings. In this case, Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd was the unsuccessful party, and therefore, the court awarded costs against them. This decision was consistent with established legal practice, reinforcing the principle that the losing party in litigation should bear the financial burden of the proceedings.
Finally, the court determined the appropriate scale of costs to be awarded, as outlined in Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995. The court adhered to the official scale provided in the regulations, ensuring that the costs were proportionate and aligned with the regulatory framework. This approach provided a transparent and standardized method for calculating costs, reflecting the court's commitment to procedural fairness and consistency.
In summary, the court's reasoning and ratio decidendi in Tod'S S.p.A. v Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd established that the Registrar is mandated to decide on trade mark registration based on established opposition grounds, that Jiang & Hou Pty Ltd met the onus of proof, that the trade mark applications should be refused registration, that costs should follow the event, and that the official scale in Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 should be applied. This decision reinforces the legal principles governing trade mark opposition proceedings and provides clarity for future cases.