Toan Van Pham v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Toan Van Pham & Ors v Brisbane City Council [2011] QLC 38

PARTIES:Toan Van Pham, Hoang Van Pham, Huang Van Pham Tay Thi Pham as TTE of Pham Family Superannuation Fund and Tetra & Associates Pty Ltd

(Applicants)

v.

Brisbane City Council

(Respondent)

FILE NO:AQL455-10

DIVISION:General Division

PROCEEDING:  •   General Application filed on 13 May 2011 on behalf of the Applicants seeking directions for the efficient and timely conduct of the Applicants’ claim by Originating Application filed on 9 September 2010 seeking compensation for resumption of land. Costs are also sought.

•General Application filed on 30 May 2011 on behalf of the Respondent seeking that pursuant to Rule 171 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules paragraph 1 of the Applicants’ Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions be struck out. Also sought are further and better particulars of certain matters, directions to progress the claim for compensation and costs.

DELIVERED ON:                  23 June 2011

DELIVERED AT:                   Brisbane

HEARD ON:  2 June 2011

HEARD AT:Brisbane

MEMBER:His Honour WA Isdale

ORDER/S:1.  Paragraph 1 of the applicants’ statement of facts, issues and contentions filed on 20 December 2010 be struck out.

2.The applicants pay on the standard basis the respondent’s costs of and incidental to this application.

CATCHWORDS:         PLEADING - STRIKING OUT

Land Court Act 2000, ss 7(b), 9

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, R5, R149, R171

CH4 Pty Ltd v The Minister for Natural Resources, Mines and Energy and Minister for Trade [2010] QLC 0037

Cidneo Pty Ltd v Chief Executive, Department of Transport and Main Roads [2011] QLC 0018

Colgate Palmolive Co & Anor v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 248, 257

APPEARANCES:                  Mr E Morzone of Counsel, instructed by Emanate Legal for the applicants

Mr DA Quayle of Counsel, instructed by the Brisbane City Legal Practice for the respondent

The background

  1. The applicants filed an originating application on 9 September 2010 seeking compensation for the resumption of land. Pursuant to Court orders made to progress the matter the applicants filed a statement of facts, issues and contentions on 20 December 2010. It commences with the following:

    “The Claimants are unable to fully formulate or particularise their Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions until after receipt of agreed and disputed facts, issues and contentions identified by the joint experts meeting process and of its own experts’ opinions.

    But, by way of a preliminary Statement, the Claimants identify the following facts, issues and contentions:

    1.   The Claimants continue to rely upon the facts, issues and contentions detailed in the Amended Claim for Compensation delivered to the Respondent on 25 May 2010, including Schedule 1 to Schedule 14 (inclusive).”

  2. The respondent’s general application filed on 30 May 2011 seeks an order under Rule 171 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 that paragraph 1 be struck out.

  3. The “Amended Claim for Compensation” took the form of a 32 page letter with 14 schedules containing 132 further pages. Much of the material is evidentiary or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Toan Van Pham v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QLC 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Toan Van Pham v Brisbane City Council, the applicant sought to bring an action against the Council for compensation. The Brisbane City Council applied for the applicant's claim to be struck out on the basis that the applicant had failed to comply with a court order. The applicant’s response to the order was deemed to be non-compliant, and the Council submitted that the applicant's response was also vexatious and oppressive. The court was required to decide whether the applicant's response was indeed non-compliant, and if so, whether it warranted a strike-out and what costs, if any, should be awarded.

The court found that the applicant's response did not comply with the court’s order, which mandated that a statement of facts, issues, and contentions be filed and served by a specific date. The court also noted that the applicant's attempt to incorporate by reference material already provided did not meet the requirements of the order. The court concluded that the applicant's response had a tendency to delay the fair trial of the proceeding and was not compliant with the order. However, the court did not find the response to be oppressive or vexatious, as it did not impose an undue burden on the Council other than requiring it to bring the matter to court. As a result, the court ordered the applicant's response to be struck out and awarded the Council costs on the standard basis.

The court found that while the applicant had not complied with the court’s order, there was no evidence of oppression or vexatiousness. Therefore, the court did not deem it appropriate to award indemnity costs. The court noted that Rule 171(2) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules makes specific provision for costs on an indemnity basis, which may make it more likely that a court will make such an order. However, in this case, the court decided that standard costs were sufficient.

The court ordered that the applicant's response be struck out and that the applicant pay the Council's costs of and incidental to the application on the standard basis. The court also noted that it was not necessary to consider the other matters raised in each party's general application, as the parties had agreed to await the court's decision on the strike-out application before proceeding further.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The relevant part of the orders made by consent on 11 November 2010 is as follows:“Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions 1. The applicants file and serve a statement of facts, issues and contentions upon which they propose to rely by 10 December 2010.” I am satisfied that paragraph 1 of the applicants’ statement filed on 20 December 2010 is not in compliance with Order 1 made on 1 November 2010, that much is clear from its terms as compared to the Order requiring it. In addition, I am satisfied that incorporating by reference the material already provided “as an amended claim for compensation”[6] is not provision of the statement as required by Order 1 made on 11 November 2010.[6] Letter dated 25 May 2010 from Emanate Legal to Brisbane City Council at page 4. I am satisfied that paragraph 1 of what is expressed to be the “Claimants’ Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions in accordance with Order 1 of Orders made on 11 November, 2010” does have a tendency to delay the fair trial of the proceeding within the meaning of Rule 171(1)(b) UCPR and also that it simply is not compliant with Order 1. On both bases the court orders that it be struck out. I am not satisfied that it is either oppressive or vexatious as it fails to impose a burden on the Council other than to bring the present application and there is no suggestion of any intention to provide annoyance. UCPR rule 171(2) allows the court to order costs on an indemnity basis. As I am satisfied that the applicants have not complied with this Court’s order and so necessitated the Council’s bringing the matter to the Court I am satisfied that the applicants should pay the Council’s costs of and incidental to the application. In view of the absence of oppression or vexatiousness I am not satisfied that indemnity costs are appropriate and order costs on the standard basis.[7][7] Colgate Palmolive Co & Anor v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 248 at 257. I note that R171(2), making specific provision for costs on the indemnity basis, will however make it more likely that a court will make such an order. The parties agreed to await the Court’s decision on the strike-out application before proceeding further so it is not necessary at present to consider the other matters raised in each party’s general application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.