I
(FOR LIMITED DISTRIBUTION)
| IN THE FEDERAL | COUET | OF ArJSTRXLiX I |
&S TEMFORE JUDGMENT
Betxeen: TNT AUSTRALIA FT'i. LTD.
(Applicant)
| U: | WILTON | NOMINEES | P T i . | LTD., |
JASEL NOMINEES FTY. LTD.
| and | JOSEFH | W I L L I M 4 GEORGE |
WILTON
!First Bespondents)
| , decond | 7 - | Respondents] |
r-'Jram: Rlzan J.
W: 14 November 1386
EX TEMFORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Ey these proceedmgs, the appllcant seeks interlocutory
in]unctions In the course of an applicatlon far rellef under
the Trade Frac t l ces Act 1974 rC'th1, t"th2 Act") and
otherwise, In respect of an agreement f o r the purchase by the
| appllcant of a busmesa | from the respondent. The agreement |
| =as by deed dated | October 1386 and provlded |
| of a busmess carrled on undec the buslness | names | " . h t o | Care" |
| and "Auto Trans", yhlsh Involved the provlslon of | certaln |
| speclallzed iervlces In respec: cf 1mr;ortsd | and | l o c a i l y |
| manufactured nctor vehicle;. |
| It rjas reclted In c1.4.1 | b ~ f the deed that ths bus1nesE |
| belng sold comprised qoodwlll, equipment, stock, rjcrk | ln |
| orogress and the two | busmess names. | It xas aclpulated In |
| cl.4.2 that the | grlce payable bp the appllsant should be |
| calculated by addlng to the value | of | the stock and vork In |
| progress on the completlon date . an amount of ;l.l00.000 | for |
| the | equipment: | and | $3,180,000 | for the qoodwill | and | the |
businzss names.
| The deed further provlded f o r payment of a deposlt | of |
| $418,500 sn executlon, to be held bp the | respondent's |
| solicitors as stakeholder pendlng csmplctron. The prlse | for |
| the equlpmsnt and stoc!c | v a s to | be pald | on the completlon |
| date, rjhlle the | amount f o r work in | progress was t o bc | pald |
for as soon as practicable after the work had been completed
and. pald For by the customers for xhom It was done.
| That part of | the price referable to the | qoodxl l l | and |
the busmess names. after deducting the amount of the deposlt and an allowance In relation to employee benefits, was to be
| pald on completion. Sublect to the condition speclfied | In |
| c1.21 of the | deed, c1.5.1 speclfied that completlon | of the |
| purchass should sccur an 3 1 Ostcbsr L 3 3 6 , but I ;as | lnformed |
| by counsel that the complstlon da%e | gas subsequently ?xtsnded |
| by mutual agreement to | 5 November 1386. |
| Under the headlng | "Assistance by | the Vendor". | c1.6.1 |
reclted that:
"As from the dats hereof and untll completlon the
| Vendor | and | :Hr. Wilton m11 afford | to | tke |
Furchaser S rspressntatives reasonable access to a l l operations, accounts, books and records of
| the busmess I n order | that thsy may observe | the |
| varlous facsts sf | the buslneas and Inspect and |
| take extrarts and copies from the | accounts, boGka |
| and recorda thereof | . " |
| Clause 7 | contamed an | extensl-".e recltal of the ;-endor | S |
ijarrantlea, Incluclmg:
| " 7 . 3 | Each af %he | Vendor | and | the | Covenantors |
| zarrant | to the | Purchaser |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read TNT Australia Pty Ltd v Wilton Nominees Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1986] FCA 606
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court determined that the applicant had indeed raised a serious question to be tried, specifically whether the "Management Accounts" accurately represented the financial state of the business and whether there had been any material adverse changes between April and October 1986. However, the court was not persuaded that an interlocutory injunction of the limited form sought was necessary. The court reasoned that such an injunction would effectively extend the completion date for the contract, afford the applicant final relief, and compel the respondent to continue managing the business. The balance of convenience favoured the respondent as there was no real risk of the respondent being unable to satisfy any monetary judgment the applicant might recover against it. Therefore, the application for interlocutory relief in the form of a limited injunction was refused, and the previously granted injunction was dissolved. The court concluded that granting discovery and interrogatories would appropriately secure the applicant access to the necessary information for the trial of the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.